Newsline

National Security , Newsline

Biden’s Middle East Failure Comes into Full Focus as China’s Xi Visits Saudi Arabia

Posted on Thursday, December 15, 2022
|
by AMAC Newsline
|
41 Comments
|
Print

AMAC Exclusive – By Daniel Berman

To say U.S. policy in the Middle East has been a failure under the Biden administration would be an understatement of mammoth proportions. From a failed effort in 2021 to isolate Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman (MBS), to the now aborted “pivot” to Iran represented by efforts to revive the dead nuclear deal, Biden rejected the approach which had allowed his predecessor to clinch the Abraham Accords and oversee numerous other successes in the region. Chinese President Xi Jinping’s long-awaited visit to Saudi Arabia, which finally took place over three days from December 7-9, only further highlighted the scope of Biden’s mishandling of Middle East relations.

As the second year of his presidency nears its conclusion, it is clear that Biden has not only failed to create any alternative Middle Eastern power structure to the Abraham Accords, but has also demonstrated that the Accords were strong enough to prosper without him or the United States. Biden’s actions have opened the door to Chinese influence, which was on full display last week.

The communiqué released by the two governments following meetings between Xi and MBS stated they would “continue to firmly support each other’s core interests, support each other in maintaining their sovereignty and territorial integrity, and exert joint efforts to defend the principle of non-interference in the internal affairs of states, rules of international law and basic principles of international relations.” These communiqués are products of diplomatic spin, and it is necessary to read between the lines. Both sides wish to create an impression that they have agreed on as much as possible while limiting their commitments.

However, the wording of this document, when combined with the contrast between Xi Jinping’s reception and that of Joe Biden just a few months ago during his visit to Saudi Arabia, should be of concern to the U.S. and the West. As the communiqué makes clear, the Saudi-Chinese relationship is warmer than the Saudi-American one. As Saudi analyst Ali Shihabi told CNN, “There is very much an alignment on key issues” between the China and the Saudis.

This alignment includes key issues like “non-interference in the internal affairs of states,” “the rules of international law,” and “the basic principles of international relations.” Both Saudi Arabia and China have been subject to what they perceive as not only U.S. efforts to police their internal affairs, but also efforts to force the international community to join in those efforts. In the case of China, the West has sanctioned Chinese officials and companies over the treatment of Uyghur Muslims in Xinjiang, including blocking the export of goods produced by forced labor in the region. When it comes to Saudi Arabia, the Biden administration has continued to lob criticisms at the regime for the death of Jamal Khashoggi, holding the Saudi Crown Prince directly responsible. Biden officials have even bragged to the press that the Biden administration intended to use the issue to force the Saudi King to change the succession. These policies have driven Beijing and Riyadh together.

U.S. treatment of China and Saudi Arabia also sets a wider precedent that draws other countries closer to China. The Biden administration has not restricted its interventions into domestic politics to authoritarian states. The administration has also tried to dictate the makeup of Benjamin Netanyahu’s new cabinet and condemned the dress codes of schools in an Indian state. The only global consensus the Biden team seems to be establishing is one where the rest of the world wants the United States to mind its own business.

At the same time, while U.S. military support of Ukraine has done much to strengthen the American position in Europe, and the credibility of the U.S. military globally, the aggressive efforts to isolate Russia through sanctions have been a different matter. Not only is there evidence they have inflicted crushing damage on the European economy while possibly aiding the Russian government’s balance of payments, but the diplomatic campaign to isolate Russia has also alienated states like India and Saudi Arabia. The U.S. has treated the refusal of India to cease purchasing spare parts for its Russian-made weapons (purchased because the U.S. refused to sell its own to New Delhi) as a hostile act, while Democrats outright called Saudi Arabia an enemy after the Saudis declined to produce more oil out of charity to aid U.S. policy in Ukraine. “If you are not with us, you are against us,” was the foolish encapsulation of a foolish policy the Bush administration took against critics of its invasion of Iraq. Biden now appears to be pursuing the same strategy, and it is an act of madness.

The combination of these poorly conceived policies has left the United States ill-placed to counter the final dangerous common interest outlined in the China-Saudi Arabia communiqué: “support[ing] each in other in maintaining their sovereignty and territorial integrity.” This line has been taken to refer to the status of Taiwan, the question that increasingly occupies the days and nights of U.S. national security professionals. According to a joint statement from the Saudi-led Arab League and China, “We have agreed on … the firm commitment of the Arab countries to the principle of one China, their support for the People’s Republic of China’s efforts to preserve its sovereignty and territorial integrity, reaffirming that Taiwan is an integral part of Chinese territory.” The statement is unambiguous when it comes to where the Arab League and the Saudis come down on the legal status of Taiwan: It is part of China.

But a closer read reveals more ambiguity, which can only be deliberate, especially as this will be the “best Beijing could get.” It agrees on “the firm commitment of the Arab countries to the principle of one China” and reaffirms “that Taiwan is an integral part of Chinese territory,” but only pledges “their support for the People’s Republic of China’s efforts to preserve its sovereignty and territorial integrity” not to its efforts to preserve or assert its sovereignty over all of China. The statement is an unambiguous rejection of the suggestion that Taiwan, currently the Republic of China, is not part of “China”, but it is also a defense of the status quo, with no expression of support for China changing it. The only sop to Beijing regarding territorial integrity is a reference to Hong Kong, which Beijing already controls.

This announcement, which has garnered the most attention in Washington from the Saudi-Chinese summit, is ironically the one where China achieved the least. Nonetheless, it is a warning for American and Chinese policymakers. The Taiwan issue is of vital importance to almost every major power on earth. It is too important to be treated as a geopolitical game. The consequences of a Sino-American war would be catastrophic to almost everyone, and the Saudis were making clear that they felt an effort by China to take control of Taiwan, or an effort by the U.S. to abandon the “One China” policy, both made a war more likely.

There is also a secondary consideration at play. As the Clinton administration failed to realize when it backed armed intervention to support the secession of Kosovo from Serbia in 1999, there is nothing states fear more than a precedent that regions can secede unilaterally. If Taiwan alone can determine whether it is “China” or not, then why not Kashmir? Kurdistan? Scotland? South Carolina? The status quo is not merely about appeasing Beijing with the ambiguous “One China” policy. By insisting that Taiwan is the Republic of China, everyone can “grandfather” in Taiwanese sovereignty independent of Beijing without pretending they are creating any sort of new nation.

A U.S. administration less prone to flights of delusion and panic could seize upon this to realize there is a broad-based coalition available to defend the status quo of Taiwanese de facto sovereignty, one strong enough that even the angry and resentful Saudis, with so many other reasons to back Xi Jinping over Joe Biden, could not bring themselves to repudiate. But it will involve listening and working to promote genuine common interests, instead of threatening the common interests of countries we need as allies.

The Middle East is a microcosm of everything that has gone wrong for the United States in foreign policy over the past two years. It is also a reminder that even when things are at their worst, there is still room for the United States to rebuild. If only the Biden administration could bring itself to listen.

Daniel Berman is a frequent commentator and lecturer on foreign policy and political affairs, both nationally and internationally. He holds a Ph.D. in International Relations from the London School of Economics. He also writes as Daniel Roman.

Share this article:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
41 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Max
Max
1 year ago

Two more years of suffering for this nation and the inept administration that is in charge. The current captain of this ship and its officers had better go down with the ship because it will take decades to correct the errors that have been made.

PaulE
PaulE
1 year ago

China sees an opportunity to take advantage of the Democrats’ incredibly inept handling of not only foreign policy over the last 2 years, but also the insane energy decisions the Democrats have taken in terms of crippling our domestic energy production. So they are happy to fill the void left by the United States.

Saudi Arabia sees a United States, under the so-called leadership of Joe Biden and the Democrats, as both weak and incompetent. Hardly someone that can be counted on in an increasingly unstable Middle East with the United States bending over backwards to get a worthless nuclear deal with Iran, a sworn enemy of most Middle Eastern countries.

The Chinese are NOT stupid. The Saudis are NOT stupid. So one should NOT be surprise by what has been transpiring in the Middle East over the last 6 months between China and various Middle Eastern nations. We, as a country, will continue to lose our standing in the world the longer Joe Biden and the Democrats hold power in Washington. That is NOT speculation. That is FACT. Elections have consequences and this is yet another consequence of the 2020 elections.

Gabe hanzeli Kent wa
Gabe hanzeli Kent wa
1 year ago

Name a part or action of the biden administration that is not a failure other then voter fraud and corruption?

Robin W Boyd
Robin W Boyd
1 year ago

Having gone from one of the best foreign negotiator to the worst really shows how horrible the Biden administration is. Can anyone think of anything the Biden administration has done that it has not failed miserably at? We’re in trouble!

Joey Mize
Joey Mize
1 year ago

Saudi Arabia sees a United States, under the so-called leadership of Joe Biden and the Democrats, as both weak and incompetent. 
The administration has also tried to dictate the makeup of Netanyahu’s new cabinet and condemned the dress codes of schools in an Indian state ??? The only global consensus the Biden team seems to be establishing daily is one where the rest of the world wants the United States to mind its own business.

Most all of the STATES that are issuing open verbal backlash at the Biden Administration are the ones that need to be challenged hard on any number of critical world shaking issues. But that will never happen with this administration. They are too consumed with Trumps next move and how to keep CRT curriculum in the US schools. Both of which lend to zero impact on what the U.S. needs and the world at large expects or would like to expect from the U.S.

Biden walked into the Mideast without a clue as to how to address any issues that were outstanding and needed shoring up. Then as a rebuttal Xi steps in at a critical point offering any and all with whomever he had contact, an open door policy to whatever China could place at their feet. I am sure Xi gave up much to ensure his trip was viewed as a win win for both sides. China plays the political game as well as any on the planet. China has the resources to parlay and influence at every level and no one to challenge them at any turn, and they know it. If you were an up and coming player on the world scene, wouldn’t you want the clout that China offers so freely as a leg up against a threat whether it be with TRADE or WEAPONS or INFLUNCE, ENERGY, or TECHNOLOGY. Least we forget that Saudi Arabia has the means to acquire just about anything CHINA is selling. No matter what words or handshakes behind close doors were unofficially offered and accepted, the stakes are high and the day will come when Saudi Arabia will have to pay the piper. If PUTIN felt safe about leaving his conclave I would expect he would be at the door of the ARABS next fully overlaying Chinas impact.

Recovery from the last 2 years will takes at least 10 to regain what BIDEN and his idiots have managed to drop the ball on. Sophomoric is an understatement for the group that is now running the railroad..

Stephen Russell
Stephen Russell
1 year ago

Source for Nuclear War??

Joey Mize
Joey Mize
1 year ago

The more of the comments below that I read the more I believe that the Liberal Demorats really had nothing except total destruction of America as we know it in mind going forward. There must be a well thought out plan being played out other than Marxism, or is it the fact that they have the patience to just wait us out and watch as we implode. I envision the end of it all will look something like that image of the snake eating its own tail. Once the free world countries are shut down, influence and power are taken away, the only thing left are those who caused it and then what will they do? destroy themselves from within I would expect.

David Whitton
David Whitton
1 year ago

In this entire article, there is not one mention of Antony Blinken, Sec. of State. Is he another administration failure hired by Biden for ethnic reason, having no experience in foreign affairs? It is astonishing to me, the conservative Democrats sit idly by while the greatest nation on earth slowly slides toward a footnote in world history. Are these people really that stupid or uncaring about America?

Paul W
Paul W
1 year ago

I think space/time could be saved by merely typing or stating: biden’s ——-(whatever the topic, from foreign policy to air-stair climbing). No need to add the word “failure”…that goes completely without saying!

Del
Del
1 year ago

I wonder every day who could possibly support Biden on most anything as he oversees one disaster after another. His presidency has been a catastrophe for the U.S. and for the world at large. He is a dishonest, self-interested backslapper who rose tot the WH via the Peter Principle and maybe a special wink and nod here and there. How embarrassing and dangerous – with 2 years to go of his Lftist handlers and probably B.O. really in charge of this debacle.

Tim Toroian
Tim Toroian
1 year ago

Every day I dry fire practice at red stars.

Grace
Grace
1 year ago

This miserable failure has the conceit and audacity to think he can run a country. Ruin a country is more like it. He is running America like he ran his crime empire, The Biden Crime Family in congress for the forty five years he was milking the citizens. He was already on the road to crime before he even entered politics. He plagiarized his graduation theses in law school. Got caught and had to write another one before he got his law licence. It’s hard to get information about him anymore because he archived his records. You don’t get to see them till at least four years after is death. Which means he won’t have to testify about his and Hunters adventures in Ukraine, Russia and China. Archiving your criminal records is comparable to a robber filling off their finger prints.

Donald King
Donald King
1 year ago

The Biden administration [Biden in name only] is by no means a failure. Things are moving along quite nicely in the eyes of Joe’s controllers. The objective is the total destruction of the America that we grew up to respect and love. And, kin that aspect, they’re happily moving right along. And, with the assistance of the numerous Rinos over at the RNC, I’m pretty confident that they will accomplish their goal. We no longer have a Democrat Party and a Republican Party. What we have are progressive/socialists and conservatives. And the conservatives are taking a shellacking so far. If it hadn’t been for Trump interrupting their progress, we’d be far worse off than we are right now.

Rich
Rich
1 year ago

Very simple. You allow a vacuum to exist and soon something will fill that vacuum. So many examples of a vacuum in this “administration”.

Daniel Smith
Daniel Smith
1 year ago

He and his minions could not negotiate with a sixth grader!

An older blonde women laughing in the kitchen with a grey haired man.
AMAC’s Medicare Advisory Service
The knowledge, guidance, and choices of coverage you’re looking for. The exceptional service you deserve.
The AMAC App on 3 different iPhone
Download the AMAC App
The AMAC App is the place to go for insightful news wherever you are and whenever you want.
esg graphs
biden blinken
glenn youngkin

Stay informed! Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

41
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Subscribe to AMAC Daily News and Games