Newsline

National Security , Newsline

Turkey’s Erdogan Upstages Biden’s NATO Summit

Posted on Friday, July 14, 2023
|
by Daniel Berman
|
15 Comments
|
Print

AMAC Exclusive – By Daniel Berman

Biden

This week, NATO leaders gathered in Vilnius, Lithuania, to welcome Sweden as the newest member of the alliance. The terms of Sweden’s ascension are a personal triumph for Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the man who has become the de facto arbiter of the alliance’s future amid President Joe Biden’s abdication of U.S. leadership.

Erdogan recently laid out NATO’s policy toward Ukraine, declaring this past weekend, “There is no doubt that Ukraine deserves NATO membership” while standing beside Ukraine’s President Zelensky in Istanbul. Joe Biden, on a trip to London before the NATO summit, seems to not even have been informed of the announcement before it happened.

The incident further illustrated the extent to which U.S. influence around the world is increasingly dependent on the whims of figures such as Erdogan.

In the case of Erdogan, this meant effectively side-lining the president of the United States from negotiations over the future of the alliance America founded. By first vetoing Swedish ascension, and then laying out conditions rather than agreeing to American mediation, Erdogan forced Sweden, the European Union, and Ukraine to approach Ankara bilaterally, excluding the United States from the process. He made clear to the Swedes that whether they joined NATO or not depended not on the preferences of Joe Biden, but on his own.

Here, Erdogan’s willingness to be magnanimous played in his favor, demonstrating why he has been so successful. Had Erdogan held out for impossible conditions, such as initial demands for full European Union membership, Sweden would have rejected them, and NATO states would have sought an alternative mechanism. By keeping his demands “reasonable,” he made it less of a hassle to appease him than to work with Biden to bypass Turkey.

The result was that Sweden’s ascension to NATO was announced not by Joe Biden at the NATO summit, but rather in Vilnius the day before, without Biden present. Instead, the announcement featured NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg, Swedish Prime Minister Ulf Kristersson, and Erdogan, hailing what Stoltenberg proclaimed was a “historic day.”

Joe Biden, who was in London, seems to have been caught by surprise. The official White House statement is remarkably vague, implying strongly that the United States had not been consulted about the progress of the talks, and was uncertain what, if any conditions, were involved.

“I stand ready to work with President Erdogan and Turkey on enhancing defense and deterrence in the Euro-Atlantic area,” Biden’s prepared statement read. “I look forward to welcoming Prime Minister Kristersson and Sweden as our 32nd NATO Ally. And I thank Secretary General Stoltenberg for his steadfast leadership.”

No mention is made of specific ways of “enhancing defense and deterrence in the Euro-Atlantic area” with the clear implication being that Turkey has secured a blank check Biden and his team would be expected to fill in at the summit.

It would be an error to cast the events as a defeat for American interests or goals. Sweden will be joining NATO, and Turkey is likely to adopt a much more pro-Western line for the foreseeable future. It would be out of character for Erdogan to undermine NATO when he has just invested so much work into acquiring a decisive voice in its management.

Nonetheless, it was a defeat for Joe Biden, who was too weak to take yes for an answer when Sweden asked to join NATO, and was forced to tell the Swedes to get Erdogan’s permission first. This represents a shifting power structure within America’s own institutions.

Before the 2004 election, an anonymous advisor to President Bush, bragging to a journalist, declared America to be an empire. “We’re an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality,” the advisor said. “And while you’re studying that reality –  judiciously, as you will – we’ll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and that’s how things will sort out. We’re history’s actors… and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do.”

If that was ever the case, it clearly is no longer so in 2023. The U.S. lacks the ability to will reality into existence. It was unable to will democracy into existence in Venezuela, much less Russia or China.

The idea that Saudi Arabia, widely derided as a U.S. puppet state in 2003, follows orders from Joe Biden in 2023 is laughable. Even Israel not only resists U.S. efforts to meddle in its internal affairs, but Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has announced plans to visit Beijing this month.

The Biden administration cannot be blamed for shifts in geopolitics which began under the Obama administration, though the policies pursued then by many who are now leading figures in the current administration greatly contributed to current dynamics. Furthermore, the U.S. position was never as strong as it appeared during the Clinton and Bush administrations, when delusions about American invincibility tempted policymakers into a belief that free trade could turn China into Canada.

The Biden team, can, however, be blamed for being slow to adapt, with the result that they badly alienated Saudi Arabia, potentially “lost” Brazil to China by backing Lula da Silva over Jair Bolsonaro last year, and are now forced to operate as supplicants to Erdogan and India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

By contrast, it was Donald Trump whose much maligned “personal outreach” to foreign leaders demonstrated a grasp of the changing realities of global politics far in advance of most of the beltway elite. Trump seemed to grasp that the ability of either the United States or China to wield direct influence abroad in a world following the Iraq and Afghanistan wars would depend not on raw force, but the ability to coordinate with key regional actors.

With the support of Israel and Saudi Arabia, Donald Trump demonstrated that it was possible for America to dominate the Middle East without the need for troops or the appeasement of Iran. Joe Biden rapidly learned that without either, the U.S. is powerless to even free a college student in Iraq.

The Trump administration’s mischaracterized “pro-strongman” policy was based on securing the loyalty of key regional actors, most of whom were elected, and whose greatest demands were not U.S. policy concessions but merely to be treated with respect. The act of treating Jair Bolsonaro, Erdogan, and Modi with respect and not lecturing them about “human rights” issues (which were often akin to the complaints American liberals have about states restricting transgender surgeries for minors), was enough to secure their allegiance to American policy in their regions. This in turn allowed America to engage on other issues from a position of strength.

Despite his best efforts, Biden has failed to break with this policy. All he has managed to do is transform it into a purely transactional one. The United States is once more forced to deal with Saudi Arabia and Turkey, but both countries know the Biden team bares them no goodwill, and they demand to be paid in advance.

This shift to a transactional relationship was not just evident with Erdogan. The contrast was obvious when it came to the recent visit by Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi to the United States. When Modi visited under Donald Trump, it was a sign of genuine friendship culminating in a Howdy Modi rally in Texas attended by tens of thousands. A similar mass outpouring of support was visible in Donald Trump’s visit to India. When Modi came to the United States this time, however, there were remarkable echoes of Erdogan’s approach to NATO.

Modi granted audiences to a series of academics, policy makers, and business leaders desperate to make his acquaintance before addressing a joint session of Congress, but Biden was almost a bystander. That Modi’s reception was a matter of regretful necessity rather than pleasure was evident on both sides, not least by constant leaks from within the Biden administration of lower level officials suggesting that the United States had not “forgotten” his human rights record.

This month, the U.S. Under-Secretary for Democracy and Human Rights will travel to India to meet with “civil society” and “opposition politicians.” The approach is worse than useless. Modi knows he is indispensable. It merely encourages him to reinforce the message as Erdogan did.

Biden is not responsible for American reliance on Erdogan or Modi. Erdogan had a right under the NATO treaty to veto Sweden’s ascension. Modi has helped turn India into a major power. As long as Biden and his team insist on making public their resentment of this situation, they will force the leaders America relies on to respond in kind as Erdogan did. Next time, it might not be a European trip they ruin for Biden.

Daniel Berman is a frequent commentator and lecturer on foreign policy and political affairs, both nationally and internationally. He holds a Ph.D. in International Relations from the London School of Economics. He also writes as Daniel Roman.

We hope you've enjoyed this article. While you're here, we have a small favor to ask...

The AMAC Action Logo

Support AMAC Action. Our 501 (C)(4) advances initiatives on Capitol Hill, in the state legislatures, and at the local level to protect American values, free speech, the exercise of religion, equality of opportunity, sanctity of life, and the rule of law.

Donate Now
Share this article:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
15 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Sharon Ormsby
Sharon Ormsby
1 year ago

Biden messing around in England licking a little girl’s shoulder and scaring her to death, when he is supposed to be at NATO. Way to go Turkey. I truly hate this administration in office.

PaulE
PaulE
1 year ago

Well considering that Biden was the only leader in attendance with dementia, it’s not surprising that he was upstaged by Erdogan. Erdogan saw an opportunity to get something from the United States that he wanted and was previously denied for multiple reasons, namely new F16 fighter jets to update his military, so he took advantage of the mentally compromised old fool. Elections have consequences and we have at least another 18 months of the United States being played for a fool by every other world leader out there. Just be thankful Erdogan didn’t want something like nuclear weapons to play with. No doubt that will be a future “request” from the dictator running Turkey. Now smile and enjoy the beautiful summer day.

Thomas
Thomas
1 year ago

Biden is a soros puppet. Soros (the #1 contributor to the democrat party) hates America, so is it any wonder the direction the pretender-in chief is heading this country?

Granny26
Granny26
1 year ago

Biden is a disgrace to America. He doesn’t even know where he’s at most times, let alone what he’s doing….or suppose to be doing.

anna hubert
anna hubert
1 year ago

Biden is doing what he was put in to do To weaken and diminish American power and influence He is serving the purpose Somehow I do not see Erdogan Putin and Biden singing in harmony

Jeri
Jeri
1 year ago

Upstage Biden, 70 year old me could do that…

Festus
Festus
1 year ago

All Erdogan had to do was show up to up-satge biden

Eamonn Thomas Smyth
Eamonn Thomas Smyth
1 year ago

It seems at times that the Biden administration is mor inclined to identify politics that keep a strong world presence.

Casey C Matt
Casey C Matt
1 year ago

Erdogan played the US like the broken fiddle it has become. Even before the horrid earthquakes that rocked Turkey, their financial situation was dire. Now they need to rebuild/replace thousands of homes but DID lack the funds. Don’t worry, the US Taxpayer will provide the fake money. Need some super updated F-16s? Don’t worry the US will provide them for however much the US can again fleece its citizens for.
And what will Turkey do? Continue to play all sides, taking from each. From the US, from Russia and from China. Only the first eagerly rolls onto its back, pisses its belly and forks over compliantly.
My God, we not only won’t make it to the next stolen election but are already a rotted husk of a wannabe empire.

CB
CB
1 year ago

A dog peeing on a tree would upstage that senile old cute!

Jimbo
Jimbo
1 year ago

Brandon is a joke on the world stage resulting in America being held in disdain. Where the hell are the republicans? They need to get their heads out of the sand and stand up for what we elected them to do. They need to stop worrying about their next election because they will not be re-elected.

tim
tim
1 year ago

Don’t be too hard on Biden – he needs his naps, along with his blankey.

Mario Capparuccini
Mario Capparuccini
1 year ago

The Democratic Jack Ass would make a better president than Biden. In fact, if we put the two side by side, we might have trouble discerning who the real jack ass is.

kirk
kirk
1 year ago

The Constitution and common law provide the means by which the American people can bypass the election process to force government officials back inside the parameters of the LAW. RemedyatLaw.us

Elton Yancey
Elton Yancey
1 year ago

Anybody with half a brain can do it.

Berlin wall monument
Navy Blue AMAC Action Weekly Update
Donald Trump speaking to supporters at an immigration policy speech at the Phoenix Convention Center in Phoenix, Arizona.

Stay informed! Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

15
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Subscribe to AMAC Daily News and Games