Newsline

National Security , Newsline

Russia Bogged Down, Losing Ground

Posted on Monday, March 7, 2022
|
by AMAC, Robert B. Charles
|
102 Comments
Russia and Ukraine

Russia knows the drill because Nazi Germany used it against them between June and December 1941. Blitzkrieg,” or “lightening warfare,” is the idea that speed, mechanized infantry, air dominance, and surprise can deliver a fast victory at low cost by catching an enemy off guard, advancing, regrouping, or repeating. Russia is trying it in Ukraine – and failing badly.

Ironically, Ukraine is doing intuitively what Russia did in WWII to stop the Germans, stopping the enemy by using the equivalent of asymmetric warfare, misdirection, amateur explosive devices, roving snipers, defensive weapons, well-positioned obstructions, and spontaneous engineering. See, e.g., Operation Barbarossa.   

The double irony is that Russia’s boasts about a modern military seem more empty than full, like their scuttled tanks. The Russians are fumbling, getting bogged down, losing ground – or not quickly gaining it – in the face of highly motivated Ukrainians. See, e.g., Ukrainian Ambassador Oksana Markarova: The Russian Blitzkrieg Was Not Successful; Putin escalates the war on Ukraine as blitzkrieg calculations fail.

As global support for Ukraine grows, morally and materially, the whole story Russia has told, the whole lie that Ukraine or NATO was preparing to attack, becomes a farce. War, the assault begins to look, even if eventually successful in grabbing land, increasingly like “David and Goliath,” with the Russian Goliath stumbling, and caught off guard by Ukrainian “blitz-defense.”

Put differently, as you look at the map of Ukraine, Russia should have been in key cities within hours if the planning, intelligence, operations, and supply lines had been prepared, and they certainly seemed to be obsessed with planning – throughout the Biden Administration’s tenure.

But no, the assault has foundered. In the north, even by the end of a week, Kyiv – Ukraine’s gemstone city – was not in Russian control, nor was city number two, Kharkiv. Attempts at encirclement were almost amateur, incomplete, held by lack of fuel, and mysterious inability to operate at night, along with many other errors.

Meantime, Ivanki to the north should have been taken before Kyiv and yet held its own as the week progressed. To the south, Chernihiv and – very close to the Russian border – Mariupol should have fallen easily. Kherson appears to have fallen, Odesa is fighting. But confirming control of any of these cities is hard, and Russia has stumbled badly in the attempt.

What else is surprising? Air dominance was supposed to be easy for the Russians, and – remembering WWII and other conflicts – airpower is critical for “lightning warfare” to work. With the combination of manned and unmanned systems, sustainable command and control, and sheer grit, Ukraine has denied Russia that component of the battlespace.

Then go to cyber, and ask – why and how is it possible that Russia, which many imagined consummate at targeted cyberattacks, has not been able to decisively end the internal communications that have allowed Ukraine to keep resisting? No obvious answer emerges, except that they spluttered.

Then think about the strategic downside to not winning fast. If this story continues much longer without some level of decisive end, a capitulation by the Ukrainian citizens, as well as government, and a sense that the mass engagement is in retreat, the story just gets worse and worse for Russia.

Beyond not taking the ground needed fast, they begin sliding sideways, losing greater and greater international support, losing sympathy, losing hope of any credible storyline to justify the immoral, brutal, almost medieval assault on a peaceful, contiguous nation. They start to look more like WWII Germany than post-Soviet Russia, which accelerates economic, diplomatic, and political losses.

Back in Moscow, St. Petersburg, and other parts of Russia, all this is not playing well. The Russian people – most of whom are Christian, decent, and have no interest in becoming WWII Germany – are not happy. 

Here is another Putin miscalculation. If the population becomes as hard to hold as world opinion, the world begins to change in ways that are increasingly unpredictable for him. If the Army becomes disillusioned, distressed, and demoralized and begins to hear their views reflected in protests around the country, where might that lead? The answer is unknown, but a question worth asking.

Finally, the idea of acting fast and winning has more than immediate implications. If you say you will hit the basket, net, or goal line – and then miss badly in warfare – your credibility sinks fast. This moral, economic, diplomatic, and now military misstep will affect perceptions of Russia’s preparedness, well beyond Putin’s own loss of personal credibility.

This conflict is far from over and may evolve into an extended, expensive, and politically disastrous decision for Putin – if it has not already. But the bigger point is that Russia’s status in the world is fast eroding. The lightning warfare idea worked in WWII for their adversary, but Russia is bogged down, losing ground.

Share this article:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
102 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
John Alley
John Alley
2 years ago

We need to do more for Ukraine. First, stop buying oil from Russian. We don’t need it,but they need our money. Send Ukraine everything they need to fight this war.

Dave
Dave
2 years ago

I am amazed that Putin is showing just how superior his military is, not really so I guess all that we’ve been led to believe about Russia looks like propaganda folks I look at their military equipment compared to ours there is no comparison and definitely not a sufficient. I imagine Putin is peeing And his post Toasties now

Dan W.
Dan W.
2 years ago

Russia spends billions on planes, missiles and weapons systems but doesn’t have a viable fleet of vehicles. Could explain why Russia is not a player in the global auto market. They are just not very good at designing and manufacturing vehicles.
 
And maybe they forgot that when they were bombing the rebels in Syria into submission, the equally significant ground war was fought by Assad’s troops. No Russian vehicles were required.
 

Peggy
Peggy
2 years ago

Continued prayers for Ukrainian people God is in control

Lynn
Lynn
2 years ago

The US is walking a fine line when it comes intervention. Putin is a dangerous individual. I believe that he would us the nuclear option if he feels that he is losing and “has nothing to lose”. What needs to happen is a revolt within his administration to stop his campaign to suppress the breakaway nations/countries from the old Soviet Union. Unfortunately the US has an administration that is weak in the eyes of Putin and he has used the weakness to his advantage. God help us all, this could into a nightmare.

Thatguy
Thatguy
2 years ago

Zelensky Ready To ‘Discuss & Find Compromise’ On Crimea, Donbas Status As CIA Warns “Ugly Next Few Weeks” Coming
zerohedge.com/markets/here-are-all-latest-news-and-developments-ukraine-war-march-8

Go Russia!

Patriot Will
Patriot Will
2 years ago

Personally, I am not sure what to think when it comes to Putin and his military. Russia has a long history of sacrificing its own people, no mater what, as long as Russia is the ultimate victor. Is Putin playing a cat and mouse game, or does he have major logistical weaknesses? He is a ruthless and cunning dictator who should not be underestimated. I pray that the Ukrainian people will keep their independence. I pray that the Ukrainians and Russians will not lose massive numbers of humans. I pray that America will not be sucked into a catastrophic war with Russia and/or China.

Gen. Grant
Gen. Grant
2 years ago

God is on Ukraine’s side, God bless your brave countrymen and women.

Stephen Russell
Stephen Russell
2 years ago

Russia experiencing what Nazis went through in Op Barbarosa 1941 then
This is the Mirror War:
o Blitz into Country
o citizens shelter in subways, London Blitz 1940
o issue arms to citizens: UK 1940, Germany 1945

Alligator
Alligator
2 years ago

Well, the same cast of characters who were screaming for rona, masks, lockdowns and shots for the last two years are now screaming for Ukraine. So why is that? What is the agenda?

Stephen Russell
Stephen Russell
2 years ago

Movies /TV about Guerillas WW2:
Definace
633 Squadron
TV show Combat
Is Paris Burning
The Train

Nobody’s Business
Nobody’s Business
2 years ago

We need to stop buying oil from Russia, and all other countries need to be told to not buy oil from Russia and to buy our oil or we pull out of the UN and NATO. Then we need to start producing all pharmaceuticals and computer chips over here. We have let our future die at the hands of other countries. We give aid and buy necessities from countries that want to kill us. Politicians should not be able to receive or accept any Monies from other countries, 10 years before serving and none forever after serving. This fix needs to start now.

joe mchugh
joe mchugh
2 years ago

OK, I admit to being somewhat confused about the fate of Ukraine. I must ask why this country, that is led by a corrupt government that is almost as bad as ours, is important to the average American.

For that matter, why is the United States still acting like the world’s policeman when we can’t even police our southern border? Despite our lack of rubber and Titanium resources, America could easily exist without any foreign trade.

Isolationist? There are worse things to be called, such as a socialist who calls for making the Constitution irellavent. Let other countries involve themselves in foreign entanglements, we should
concentrate on building America into a society that the Founding Fathers envisioned.
Who knows, maybe other countries might view us as a role model that they could emulate, instead of having governments that behave like self-centered children. Hey, we could even get rid of our own Marxist government, and vote in representatives who actually do the right things.

Wayne Peterkin
Wayne Peterkin
2 years ago

Russia will win this conflict because Putin will up the destruction to the point of killing every last Ukrainian including women and children if necessary. He will not allow defeat no matter the cost UNLESS, the Russian people and the very powerful oligarchs turn against him to the point of forcing him to retreat. Putin is evil, and determined to expand his power at any cost to others. Our best hope is to strangle Russia economically to turn public opinion strongly enough against Putin to force an end to this, and it will require circumventing Putin’s silencing of the media in Russia to spread the word of what he is really doing in Ukraine. Very dangerous time to the entire world. Putin’s ambition is likely to go far beyond Ukraine.

Bill
Bill
2 years ago

Ukraine is a Democracy. Set upon by a dictatorship in Russia. By an ex-KGB officer who wants to reestablish the old “Soviet Union” – which was never a ‘Union’ – but captive countries, ruled by Secret Police, Military & Political traitors.
Is there corruption? The Communist Trolls make a big effort to say because of corruption we shouldn’t be involved in any way. [As if Chicago, New York, Boston, or even the Swamp in DC aren’t corrupt.]
This is a Democracy, that has tried to join the European Union to further their economy. Join NATO to have further integration with Europe, not Russia. They are a Free Nation, a Democracy, & deserve our support.

Fred Noel
Fred Noel
2 years ago

Putin is doing what Stalin did after the Russians pushed back the German invaders. Just ruthless tactics against citizens at all cost regardless of Russian loses. He would stop. He doesn’t care about his military personnel or the Russian people! The sad part of all of this is the world just sits back and watches from the sidelines. Hopefully the sanctions will work, however it’s the Russian people that will suffer the most! He doesn’t care!

Fred Noel
Fred Noel
2 years ago

Joey is a joke on the world stage. The American people and the Ukrainian people are not laughing, however Putin is.
Did you hear the one about the old man wondering around Washington D.C. and Delaware befuddled, he thinks he’s the President of the United States

Blessed Patriot
Blessed Patriot
2 years ago

I’m disappointed in AMAC. The truth is that Zelensky is part of the NWO globalists that benefits from war and destabilization. Putin has no desire to give up Russian sovereignty to any NWO. The U.S. DID put bio labs and other weaponry inside the Ukraine, right on Russia’s border, which violates agreements between Russia and the U.S./NATO.

WE ARE TO BLAME. Not to forget that the Ukraine is one HUGE, SWAMP INFESTED nest of corruption and money laundering schemes for the globalist swamp. Burisma is just the tip of the ovomit backed and perpetrated, 2014 coup of the Ukraine ….

Not that Putin is our friend. He is not. But he is not at fault here, as America would have reacted the EXACT same way if our borders were compromised.

KEEP UKRAINE the neutral buffer zone it’s always been as per our AGREEMENTS WITH RUSSIA.

Please SHEEPLE! Do the research! Don’t you ever wonder why the global media is in lockstep with our swamp infested, lame stream media? WELL?

nabu-leaks.org/new-facts-of-international-corruption-and-external-governance-of-ukraine/

MUST WATCH.

Bob
Bob
2 years ago

OMG! Biden is so inept, on so many issues — especially managing Putin — he is making Jimmy Carter seem competent! Biden is putting party over country.

Get the oil going — NOW! Export to Europe. And yes, cut a deal with the Saudis (our ally in the Middle East!) to up production.

Flood Ukraine with weapons. We have more than enough advanced fighter aircraft to meet their needs. Ukraine to supply the pilots.

Send a NATO fleet into Odessa. By its very presence, w/o engaging, it will stop the Russian advance westward along the Black Sea coast. (The Russians will not attack that fleet.)

Start knocking-out the Russian power grid. Just do that from sites in Ukraine so Putin can’t track it back to the U.S.

Flood the Russian population with facts. Get the population against Putin and his false “war of repatriation.

The same with Russian troops. Remind them they were duped, and this is not their war — its Putin who has put their lives in jeopardy.

And for Heavens’ sake, shut-up Kamala Harris!

Brian
Brian
2 years ago

At the risk of being eaten by my own, I would offer a different perspective: If China was actively setting up a military alliance with Mexico, right next door, would we not feel threatened and take action? We would – or at least should. This is the position we have put Russia in by making moves to include Ukraine in NATO. Remember, the purpose of NATO is to oppose Russia (the former Soviet Union). With the further revelations that we had a large number of military bio-labs (which are outlawed in out own country) scattered throughout Ukraine, the threat was made all the more urgent. We are being led to “look over there” to take our feeble minds and short attention spans off of the continued destruction and ineptitude of our own government under the Biden Administration. The dollar is eroding to nothing, our people are divided, our economy is in shambles and our people don’t want to work. All of this is GOOD if you are a globalist seeking to bring the American people under the reign of the “ruling elite.” We need to use our God given minds and be critical thinkers. This “Unify against a foreign enemy” is the oldest play in the book. God help us.

Mark B
Mark B
2 years ago

You have to know if Russia wanted to take Kyiv, they would be able to in short order. I think Russia is only using Kyiv as a diversion or decoy to keep Ukranian forces in the north while they attack the areas, they are actually interested in the separates area east of the river.

Tim Toroian
Tim Toroian
2 years ago

He hit Ukraine with a similar number of troops as the Allies used the first day at Normandie, then piled on much more in the next few days. 150,000 or so is not enough to take and occupy a land area the size of Ukraine which bog down any force.

Jeanine
Jeanine
2 years ago

Although this may seem a bit “off topic”, it has a value: I read A Lot, generally 2-4 texts a week. Presently I am reading non-fiction and historical fiction, but also have included a little general fiction, novel, mystery thriller, and short stories.
My point here is that I (like many of you) am no “spring chicken” and I use my reading to relax from the purely unbelievable circumstances in our world. Even reading non-fiction books and articles offers reprieve from the tribulations around us. Usually I am reading 4 to 5 books concurrently, I suppose trying to give myself a little touch of everything. And honestly, reading has the added advantage that it helps me to maintain by issues with pain.
I am certainly not saying to reject or avoid the commerce of life, I am merely suggesting to enhance events. By fortuitous luck, last night I happened to have read on the Blitzkrieg in June and December of 1941. Which coincided well and added depth to this article.
Well, all that said, this was just a little suggestion for those of you who sometimes find the fate of daily events hard to swallow.

RLH
RLH
2 years ago

Leaked intelligence from boots on the ground don’t support your narrative.

Casey C Matt
Casey C Matt
2 years ago

Again…….suggesting that Russia is being bogged down because they aren’t using the American approach to invasion..the “shock and awe” approach. Please listen to the conditions Russia laid out in the peace talks being held with Ukraine. What are they asking? For Ukraine to be neutral and not form anti Russian partnership agreements such as NATO membership……..agree to that and the Russians say they will leave.
Are we saying that the Russians are evil because they havent obliterated Kiev as we did Baghdad? Is everyone insane or just blinded by the narrative coming out constantly from the corporate media?

Bob L.
Bob L.
2 years ago

I can’t imagine what’s going on. Russia has the manpower, equipment, and fuel to have already overrun Ukraine. I now have to wonder if they are intentionally holding back as a global diversion – an all eyes on us in Ukraine while something else is getting ready to come down.

Our, Israel’s, Taiwan’s, Japan’s, as well as NATO’s intelligence branches had better be on the lookout worldwide.

Donald A Colongeli
Donald A Colongeli
2 years ago

IF THIS “GOLIATH” DOESNT TAKE CONTROL OF A MUCH SMALLER COUNTRY , BY ANY MANNER, SHAPE OR FORM, SOMETHING SMELLS?

Drue
Drue
2 years ago

History repeats itself. Winter and arrogance defeated Hitler in his quest for eastward expansion into Russia. His army lacked winter clothes among other miscalculations. In Ukraine, we see a determined leader and a motivated citizenry that love their country. They are pitted against mostly young men, conscripted into the military with little or no motivation to fight against people they have much in common with. It’s mud season there, not so good for mechanized armor. The Ukrainians may be somewhat outgunned, but they have enough weaponry to vastly slow down the Russians. And that is why my friends, we have the 2nd Amendment here in the United States. To protect us against a tyrannical government.

Ernie
Ernie
2 years ago

Boy, this article seems to be based upon the current media propaganda out of the West and far removed from what is actually happening.

Honey
Honey
2 years ago

They showed on tv that Putin’s tanks are in one lane only. What I would like to see happen is for Ukranians to get one tank and turn it so that no other could pass. Or if they can’t blow one up and put it in the way, get two big trucks and put them in the way. The time it would take to clear that away would slow down the column.

Skeptic
Skeptic
2 years ago

Putin’a next step is to slaughter the civilian population

tika
tika
2 years ago

time to finish-off putskin

Barb304
Barb304
2 years ago

I’m praying for Ukraine and all its citizens. God bless you and keep you safe.

Michael
Michael
2 years ago

People are tired of wars that only bringBloodshed and terrify our children ofThe world…you would think past warsWould teach us…nothing good comesOut of destruction….War what is it good for…nothingA song from the past…

Linda Sweet
Linda Sweet
2 years ago

I find it an interesting coincidence that one of our best past American presidents, Ronald Reagan, was an actor, and the heroic President Zelensky of Ukraine was an actor and comedian before becoming president. Let’s start saying no to career politicians worldwide! Our nation was founded by men from all walks of life, so let’s return to electing the same sort of leaders as our founders.

John Alley
John Alley
2 years ago

We need to do more for Ukraine. First, stop buying oil from Russian. We don’t need it,but they need our money. Send Ukraine everything they need to fight this war.

Dave
Dave
2 years ago

I am amazed that Putin is showing just how superior his military is, not really so I guess all that we’ve been led to believe about Russia looks like propaganda folks I look at their military equipment compared to ours there is no comparison and definitely not a sufficient. I imagine Putin is peeing And his post Toasties now

Dan W.
Dan W.
2 years ago

Russia spends billions on planes, missiles and weapons systems but doesn’t have a viable fleet of vehicles. Could explain why Russia is not a player in the global auto market. They are just not very good at designing and manufacturing vehicles.
 
And maybe they forgot that when they were bombing the rebels in Syria into submission, the equally significant ground war was fought by Assad’s troops. No Russian vehicles were required.
 

Peggy
Peggy
2 years ago

Continued prayers for Ukrainian people God is in control

Lynn
Lynn
2 years ago

The US is walking a fine line when it comes intervention. Putin is a dangerous individual. I believe that he would us the nuclear option if he feels that he is losing and “has nothing to lose”. What needs to happen is a revolt within his administration to stop his campaign to suppress the breakaway nations/countries from the old Soviet Union. Unfortunately the US has an administration that is weak in the eyes of Putin and he has used the weakness to his advantage. God help us all, this could into a nightmare.

Thatguy
Thatguy
2 years ago

Zelensky Ready To ‘Discuss & Find Compromise’ On Crimea, Donbas Status As CIA Warns “Ugly Next Few Weeks” Coming
zerohedge.com/markets/here-are-all-latest-news-and-developments-ukraine-war-march-8

Go Russia!

Patriot Will
Patriot Will
2 years ago

Personally, I am not sure what to think when it comes to Putin and his military. Russia has a long history of sacrificing its own people, no mater what, as long as Russia is the ultimate victor. Is Putin playing a cat and mouse game, or does he have major logistical weaknesses? He is a ruthless and cunning dictator who should not be underestimated. I pray that the Ukrainian people will keep their independence. I pray that the Ukrainians and Russians will not lose massive numbers of humans. I pray that America will not be sucked into a catastrophic war with Russia and/or China.

Gen. Grant
Gen. Grant
2 years ago

God is on Ukraine’s side, God bless your brave countrymen and women.

Stephen Russell
Stephen Russell
2 years ago

Russia experiencing what Nazis went through in Op Barbarosa 1941 then
This is the Mirror War:
o Blitz into Country
o citizens shelter in subways, London Blitz 1940
o issue arms to citizens: UK 1940, Germany 1945

Alligator
Alligator
2 years ago

Well, the same cast of characters who were screaming for rona, masks, lockdowns and shots for the last two years are now screaming for Ukraine. So why is that? What is the agenda?

Stephen Russell
Stephen Russell
2 years ago

Movies /TV about Guerillas WW2:
Definace
633 Squadron
TV show Combat
Is Paris Burning
The Train

Nobody’s Business
Nobody’s Business
2 years ago

We need to stop buying oil from Russia, and all other countries need to be told to not buy oil from Russia and to buy our oil or we pull out of the UN and NATO. Then we need to start producing all pharmaceuticals and computer chips over here. We have let our future die at the hands of other countries. We give aid and buy necessities from countries that want to kill us. Politicians should not be able to receive or accept any Monies from other countries, 10 years before serving and none forever after serving. This fix needs to start now.

joe mchugh
joe mchugh
2 years ago

OK, I admit to being somewhat confused about the fate of Ukraine. I must ask why this country, that is led by a corrupt government that is almost as bad as ours, is important to the average American.

For that matter, why is the United States still acting like the world’s policeman when we can’t even police our southern border? Despite our lack of rubber and Titanium resources, America could easily exist without any foreign trade.

Isolationist? There are worse things to be called, such as a socialist who calls for making the Constitution irellavent. Let other countries involve themselves in foreign entanglements, we should
concentrate on building America into a society that the Founding Fathers envisioned.
Who knows, maybe other countries might view us as a role model that they could emulate, instead of having governments that behave like self-centered children. Hey, we could even get rid of our own Marxist government, and vote in representatives who actually do the right things.

Wayne Peterkin
Wayne Peterkin
2 years ago

Russia will win this conflict because Putin will up the destruction to the point of killing every last Ukrainian including women and children if necessary. He will not allow defeat no matter the cost UNLESS, the Russian people and the very powerful oligarchs turn against him to the point of forcing him to retreat. Putin is evil, and determined to expand his power at any cost to others. Our best hope is to strangle Russia economically to turn public opinion strongly enough against Putin to force an end to this, and it will require circumventing Putin’s silencing of the media in Russia to spread the word of what he is really doing in Ukraine. Very dangerous time to the entire world. Putin’s ambition is likely to go far beyond Ukraine.

Bill
Bill
2 years ago

Ukraine is a Democracy. Set upon by a dictatorship in Russia. By an ex-KGB officer who wants to reestablish the old “Soviet Union” – which was never a ‘Union’ – but captive countries, ruled by Secret Police, Military & Political traitors.
Is there corruption? The Communist Trolls make a big effort to say because of corruption we shouldn’t be involved in any way. [As if Chicago, New York, Boston, or even the Swamp in DC aren’t corrupt.]
This is a Democracy, that has tried to join the European Union to further their economy. Join NATO to have further integration with Europe, not Russia. They are a Free Nation, a Democracy, & deserve our support.

An older blonde women laughing in the kitchen with a grey haired man.
AMAC’s Medicare Advisory Service
The knowledge, guidance, and choices of coverage you’re looking for. The exceptional service you deserve.
The AMAC App on 3 different iPhone
Download the AMAC App
The AMAC App is the place to go for insightful news wherever you are and whenever you want.
Trending News
european union flag; green deal
Ted Cruz
US Capitol Building - Washington DC - USA. Capitol building in Washington DC, United States of America
Joe Biden speaking with attendees

Stay informed! Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

102
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Subscribe to AMAC Daily News and Games