Newsline

National Security , Newsline

No, The US Shouldn’t Push Israel to Create a Palestinian State

Posted on Friday, December 1, 2023
|
by Outside Contributor
|
14 Comments
map of israel

“Ultimately,” contends Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.), the next Israeli government “is going to have to put us back on a path to have a Palestinian state. That’s not easy, but it is the only way forward for Israel, is the only way forward for long-term peace.”

Well, it’s not the only way forward, right? Israel could clamp down on Palestinian autonomy until the violence against innocent Jewish civilians stops, and residents start living peacefully with their neighbors and begin accepting history’s outcomes. That’s another option.

While the situation today is appalling, creating a three-front Iran-backed terror state on the borders of a nation the size of New Jersey would make things significantly worse. No sane citizenry would sign off on such a suicidal policy. No genuine ally would pressure a friend to do it.

But that is exactly what a new country called “Palestine” is destined to be: an Islamic autocracy and, more than likely, a proxy of Iran (who may well have nuclear weapons at some point).

Perhaps Murphy is unaware that the last time Israelis handed autonomy of Gaza to the Palestinian Authority in 2005 — ejecting thousands of Jews who would otherwise have been murdered by the only “ethnic cleansers” in this conflict — it quickly lost power.

And does any sentient person believe that Hamas or the Islamic Jihad or Muslim Brotherhood-proper wouldn’t end up running a Palestinian state again? Does Murphy want to send in American troops to Gaza when they do? Because Israel, compelled to act on the inevitable provocations from this freshly created nation with unfettered access to weaponry, surely would. The resulting war would be deadlier than the one going on now.

Rest assured, when Hamas runs a state in the West Bank that bumps right up against major civilian Jewish populations, it won’t be “us” — certainly not a Connecticut politician’s home — that are targeted by missiles.

These days, we keep hearing how Hamas is a tyrannical organization that doesn’t truly represent the will of the Palestinian people. If they only had real elections, things would be different. This, too, is either a lie or wishful thinking.

While Hamas might not be quite as popular with Palestinians as it is with American Ivy League students, it nevertheless garners significant support. In 2021, the Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research found that 53% of Palestinians believed Hamas was “most deserving of representing and leading the Palestinian people,” while only 14% preferred the somewhat less terroristic Fatah. Most polls show similar or more enthusiastic support for Hamas. It’s the reason there hasn’t been an election in the West Bank in over a decade. Hamas would win. Easily.

It doesn’t have to be this way. Palestinian culture is steeped in generational, self-destructive, virulent animosity toward Jews that manifests in waves of extremism and violence. This was the case in the early 20th century when Arabs began sporadically massacring Jews before Israel existed, throughout the 1940s when Palestinian leadership embraced Hitler and during a post-war faux nationalism phase (also before Israel existed), in the 1960s when the Palestine Liberation Organization introduced the world to modern terrorism (before “occupied territories” existed), and to the present Islamist iteration of that violence.

Yet, Palestinians, and their defenders, remain the only people in the world who think they can reset history every time they lose a war of aggression. Their very claim to a state is contingent on the myth that Israel invaded and “occupied” the West Bank and Gaza (and Tel Aviv) in an act of colonialism, when the “occupied territories” were taken in defensive wars against Egypt and (the existing Palestinian-majority state of) Jordan.

But forget history. Forget that you can dig anywhere in the ground and find ancient Jewish artifacts. Forget that Israel offered Arabs back the land on numerous occasions in exchange for basic recognition. More importantly, there is zero evidence that Palestinian self-governance will lead to more peace — quite the opposite, in fact.

Murphy’s notion that the only way to bring about coexistence is to reward the vilest act of Jewish murder since the Holocaust speaks to the destructive, insular, morally confused nature of the Brookings-approved D.C. blobthink. Every time the sides revisit the negotiations on the terms dictated by these people, it ends in disappointment and, inevitably, violence.

Fortunately, this state can’t be willed into existence by Hamas-friendly newspaper and editorial boards, nor by resolution-happy tyrants at the United Nations. And that’s fine. Just as there is no independent Hungarian nation in Transylvania and no Republic of Basque, there may never be a “Palestine” — or rather, a second Palestine (Jordan being the first).

Nothing says there has to be. Yes, the situation might be intractable right now. But that is no reason to make it worse.

David Harsanyi is a senior editor at The Federalist. Harsanyi is a nationally syndicated columnist and author of five books — the most recent, “Eurotrash: Why America Must Reject the Failed Ideas of a Dying Continent.” His work has appeared in National Review, the Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, Reason, New York Post and numerous other publications. Follow him on Twitter @davidharsanyi.

COPYRIGHT 2023 CREATORS.COM

Share this article:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
14 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
anna hubert
anna hubert
4 months ago

Moslem is not happy in his own state He moves to happier state of USA or Canada or France Once there he is not happy and sets to make things exactly the same as the ones he left but would not return to the land of honey There does not seem to be anything that is not a thorn in his side Why are we cow towing and pacifying that which is not compatible with others and is not willing to co exist peacefully

Martie
Martie
4 months ago

I believe that the US should stop trying to tell Israel how to fight her own wars.

Robert Moore
Robert Moore
4 months ago

I cheated; I’ve already read the end of the book. Israel wins.
From the river to the sea,
Palestine will cease to be.

Mark
Mark
4 months ago

Finally someone else who knows so called Palestinians are actually Jordanians.
There will never be peace as long as there are muslims in the world.
The so called moderate muslims are starting to show their colors. It is a mob thing. Once they hit a large enough number they show themselves.

Lance
Lance
4 months ago

Why do people keep saying this about two states? The Palestinians have zero interest in that. They have been offered this time and time again. All they want is Israel to die. They say it over and over. Why aren’t people listening? I have not heard anyone in power for the Palestinians mention a two state solution.

Sally Duncan
Sally Duncan
4 months ago

Senator Chris Murphy abounds in destructive thought about another country in the middle east that he obviously has no education on. It has been historically understood that Palestine is not a country in and of itself, they are the people who are the occupiers, not the owners of that space called Gaza. Isreal was kind enough to allow them to stay, gave them food, water, electricity, etc. for free and the palestinians turn around and crap on them. Isreal should and has every right to go after Hamas, Hesbollah and destroy them and move the palestinians out of Gaza and spread them far and wide throughout the middle east. And Murphy with his ilk should keep his thoughts to himself.

Jim M
Jim M
4 months ago

The land there belongs to Israel.. There should never be a Palestine in Israel. If people in Middle East want a Palestinian state let them do so in any Arab country, not Israel. Gaza and the West Bank must leave Israeli land. America must back Israel 100% and let their leader determine tge operation of this military action. America and Israel must always stand Together.

Jim M.
Jim M.
4 months ago

America must always stand side by side with Israel. The only thing that should be taking place now is our supporting our great Ally in every way. Hamas, Hezballa, and Iran are enemies of America and must never be allowed to attack without knowing they face obliteration in response. That is Israel’s plan, and we must back them 100%. Those who are anti Israel have no place in any civilized society especially USA. God bless Israel always.

jimm
jimm
4 months ago

Is there any spare land available in the middle of Africa? Maybe the arctic?

Carol Expósito
Carol Expósito
4 months ago

NO, NO. NO to a Palestinian State. They are TERRORISTS! Wipe them off the face of the earth!

J.R
J.R
4 months ago

As of now our US government is part of the problem and not a rational solution

Linda
Linda
4 months ago

We have no business telling Israel what to do!!!!Learn their history.

An older blonde women laughing in the kitchen with a grey haired man.
AMAC’s Medicare Advisory Service
The knowledge, guidance, and choices of coverage you’re looking for. The exceptional service you deserve.
The AMAC App on 3 different iPhone
Download the AMAC App
The AMAC App is the place to go for insightful news wherever you are and whenever you want.
Demonstration for stop the persecution Falun Gong in China. New York, USA - September 23, 2014:Stop the persecution of Falun Gong in China in 47 street and 1st Ave.
Ronald Reagan makes a dapper picture with a boutonniere in his lapel. The occasion was Reagan`s address before the Chicago Council on Foreign Relations on St. Patrick`s Day, March 17, 1980. At the time, the former movie actor and two-term California governor was running for the Republican Party nomination for president.
Usa and Venezuela Realistic Half Flags Together
US House of Representatives - January 6th Committee Logo

Stay informed! Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

14
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Subscribe to AMAC Daily News and Games