Opinion / Politics

Elizabeth Warren’s “Stop Wall Street Looting Act” Would Devastate Investors, Retirees, Jobs and the U.S. Economy

Elizabeth WarrenIf Senator Elizabeth Warren (D – Massachusetts) described the sky as blue, one would be wise to peek out a window just to reconfirm.

It’s not that every single utterance from Senator Warren is necessarily false, but let’s just say that her reliability falls well below the proverbial broken clock that’s at least accurate twice per day.  And that reliability plummets even further when fellow extremists like Senator Bernie Sanders (I – Vermont) and Representative Rashida Tlaib (D – Minnesota) join her discordant chorus.  

Such is the case with proposed legislation entitled the “Stop Wall Street Looting Act” that Warren is poised to reintroduce in the new Congress.  That bill possesses a prototypically alluring title, but could wreak havoc upon American financial markets and our struggling economy and job market more broadly.

In a nutshell, Senator Warren’s proposal would impose crippling new taxes, potential legal liabilities and a thicket of bureaucratic regulations on the private equity sector while broadly remaking the nation’s bankruptcy code to her liking.  She would also tax private equity profits at ordinary income tax rates rather than capital gains.  That may sound alluring for the uninformed, but it makes no sense because private equity investments come with an inherent risk of loss, unlike ordinary wages.  Why would someone take a chance and risk capital when any earnings would be taxed the same as ordinary wages that impose no risk of loss?  If private equity investments fail, managers lose their money.

Accordingly, Senator Warren’s proposal seeks to starve the private equity sector out of existence.

For anyone understandably unfamiliar with private equity and its critical role in our economy, private equity firms basically identify struggling or underperforming companies that could become more profitable with improved management.  Private equity firms therefore invest for the longer-term in such companies and turn a profit by eliminating their inefficiencies and improving their performance.

And while private equity may remain unfamiliar to anyone outside the industry, its firms often employ capital from mutual funds and pensions, and account for millions of jobs at well-known companies, as noted by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce:

The private equity funds created by private equity firms to invest in various companies throughout the economy are often backed by capital from institutional investors, including public pension funds.  PE funds have long played a major role in the development of a broad range of companies, which employ 8.8 million people across the United States, including several hundred thousand people across every state, such as Hilton Hotels, Popeyes, Uber, Airbnb, Dollar General, Dunkin Donuts, Jiffy Lube, LA Fitness, Tate’s Bake Shop, Beats Electronics, The Nature’s Bounty, and McGraw-Hill Education.  All told, the private funds industry drives a significant amount of economic growth in the United States and supports millions of jobs across the country.  After multiplier effects on the economy, such PE-backed companies and the PE firms themselves support over 26 million jobs and contribute over $475 billion in annual federal and state/local tax revenues.  

It’s therefore no surprise that a 2019 study by the U.S. Chamber found that Senator Warren’s bill would have a devastating economic impact.

Specifically, the bill would cost between 6.9 million and 26.3 million jobs across the U.S.  It would reduce federal, state and local tax revenues between a whopping $109 billion and $475 billion each year.  It would cost investors between $671 million and $3.36 billion per year (with pension fund retirees accounting for many of those investors).  It would drive many private equity firms out of business due to the bill’s imposition of higher risk and regulation.  And it would drastically reduce available funding for private equity going forward.

Moreover, the pre-pandemic ten-year average annual return for private equity investments was 10.2%, compared to 8.5% for stocks and 6.7% for investments overall.  Retirees and everyday investors, take note.

For these and other reasons, even moderate Democrats find Senator Warren’s proposal objectionable, as Politico reports.  “It’s setting up a clash with moderate Democrats who say private equity is a crucial tool to keep capital flowing to businesses and propel economic growth,” it noted, “but progressives now emboldened by the party’s full control of Washington are showing no signs of backing down.”

So much for “unity.”

Senator Warren’s proposal has nothing to do with improving markets or making our economy more fair.  It’s about steamrolling her radical agenda, centralizing power and aggregating authority even more for Washington, D.C., bureaucrats.  And who would pay the price?  Millions of American workers, retirees, investors, public pension beneficiaries and well-known companies.

Warren’s bill wouldn’t stop “Wall Street looting,” it would merely hammer the American economy and deserves to be stopped in its tracks.

Reprinted with Permission from - Center For Individual Freedom by - Timothy H. Lee

If You Enjoy Articles Like This - Subscribe to the AMAC Daily Newsletter
and Download the AMAC News App

Sign Up Today Download

If You Enjoy Articles Like This - Subscribe to the AMAC Daily Newsletter!

Sign Up Today
Read more articles by Outside Contributor
Subscribe
Notify of
3 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Joy
9 months ago

They r not really socialists they are opportunists. How is it when elected not many are rich, but within 4/6 years they r all rich? And it owns them, they don’t want to share; they want the power money brings. Let’s follow the money & how they get it, then we can impeach all of them for bribery & insider trading. They love money, they love power; not us, not our country.
If allowed, they will steal all & drag the USA down then wag their fingers & sneer at the poor & disadvantaged.

PaulE
9 months ago

Warren has never made any secret of her goal to crush the capitalist system and impose a government controlled economy on the United States. The difference is with the Democrats now in total control of both the Executive Branch and the Legislative Branch, her bad policies actually stand a better than even chance of being enacted. So don’t be too quick to laugh off the threat.

Of course the policies outlined in her legislation would wipe of the liquidity of the stock and bond markets, destroy the financial industry and cripple most mid to large size companies from having ready access to capital to grow and expand their businesses and jobs. Banks pay interest on those CD’s many of you own by either lending out money or investing it to generate a return on capital. If Warren’s polices are enacted, that lending and the interest you earn all dries up. Her polices would also render the portfolios and retirement accounts of everyone quickly worthless, as the assets contained in those accounts lose value.

(Sarcasm mode on)
Who needs jobs or money to pay for things like food, rent mortgages and other daily necessities? The government will just build massive slums for the people to live in, like the governments that Warren and Sanders admire so much. Then the government dole out some meager food rations, from the nationalized companies they’ve seized, until the economy completely implodes. What could possibly go wrong?
(Sarcasm mode off)

The Democrats have a number of legislative bills in the works to completely transform this country into something most of you would never recognize or survive in.

Barry Courtnay
9 months ago

It’s hard for me to take people like her seriously. When she doesn’t even know her nationality. I look at the people in congress (both sides) as bad actors. They would have trouble making a B movie. I saw Alexandria Ocasio Cortez on the news, telling her story on what happened on 01/06/2021 she might want to try out for a 007 movie. Pray WE THE PEOPLE can take back all that the government has done wrong, and is trying to do wrong. Believe in (Freedom) it’s all we got!

3
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x