Newsline

Education , Newsline

More Bad News for DEI

Posted on Thursday, December 12, 2024
|
by Andrew Shirley
|
55 Comments
|
Print

In the latest blow to “Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion” (DEI) programming, the University of Michigan announced earlier this month that it would no longer require DEI statements as part of hiring decisions and is considering a “broader shift” away from DEI policies.

Michigan’s reversal is particularly noteworthy because the school has been a trailblazer in the DEI space, pouring a staggering $250 million into DEI initiatives and hiring some 241 employees to work in DEI offices over the past decade. Since 2016, every graduate of the university has been forced to attend DEI trainings or produce a DEI statement, and every university “unit” is required to have a DEI plan.

The practice of requiring diversity statements in admissions and hiring, a policy employed by Michigan and a majority of other colleges and universities, has become particularly controversial following the Supreme Court’s 2023 decision in Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard.

While the Court in that case ruled that race-based affirmative action programs violate the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause, critics have contended that requiring “diversity statements” is a loophole for administrators to still consider the race of applicants when making decisions for admission or hiring. As detailed by The Chronicle of Higher Education, job candidates are often eliminated from consideration based solely on their diversity statements.

DEI advocates have long insisted that DEI requirements promote a “sense of belonging” and make everything from university campuses to private businesses more “welcoming” for minorities. But a bombshell New York Times investigative report into Michigan’s DEI regime released this October points to precisely the opposite conclusion.

“In a survey released in late 2022, students and faculty members across the board reported a less positive campus climate than at the [DEI] program’s start and less of a sense of belonging,” the Times notes. “Students were less likely to interact with people of a different race or religion or with different politics—the exact kind of engagement DEI programs, in theory, are meant to foster.”

Far from promoting a sense of community on campus, Michigan’s aggressive DEI programming coincided with an explosion in race and gender-based tensions. “Everyday campus complaints and academic disagreements are now cast as crises of inclusion and harm,” the Times writes, stating that DEI has “helped fuel a culture of grievance.”

Perhaps most damningly of all, Michigan’s quarter-of-a-billion-dollar investment in DEI hasn’t even led to an uptick in Black enrollment – a major stated goal of the program. In a state where 14 percent of the population is Black, the percentage of Black students at the school has remained largely stagnant.

Following the initial Times report in October, Michigan said that it had no plans to back down from its support for DEI. Less than two months later, however, the university has done just that. Along with removing the requirement for diversity statements, Michigan reportedly plans to shift a significant portion of its DEI budget “into recruitment programs and tuition guarantees for lower-income students.”

Michigan is hardly alone in its shift away from DEI. In 2023, public university systems in Missouri, Ohio, and Wisconsin all stopped requiring diversity statements. The Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Harvard’s Faculty of Arts and Sciences have also discontinued the practice.

The University of North Carolina system, headquartered in Chapel Hill, will also no longer require each school to submit annual DEI reports, and the board recently voted to divert $2.3 million away from DEI programs. In Texas, Governor Greg Abbott signed a bill last year banning DEI programs on state college campuses. In Florida, the state government passed a law limiting public funding for DEI, resulting in the University of Florida system gutting its DEI program.

Even outside of the education space, DEI appears to be in retreat. Walmart recently announced that it will be rolling back its DEI policies. Along with not renewing a five-year commitment for a so-called “racial equity center” the world’s largest employer also will no longer give priority treatment to suppliers based on race and sex. Walmart also told The Associated Press that the company will better monitor its third-party marketplace items to make sure they don’t feature sexual and transgender products aimed at minors.

Other major American companies, including Ford, Harley-Davidson, Lowe’s, and Tractor Supply have also reversed course on their DEI policies after facing intense backlash from customers.

After years in which DEI was a seemingly untouchable force in American culture, these developments suggest conservatives may finally be turning the tide in the war on woke.

Andrew Shirley is a veteran speechwriter and AMAC Newsline columnist. His commentary can be found on X at @AA_Shirley.

We hope you've enjoyed this article. While you're here, we have a small favor to ask...

The AMAC Action Logo

Support AMAC Action. Our 501 (C)(4) advances initiatives on Capitol Hill, in the state legislatures, and at the local level to protect American values, free speech, the exercise of religion, equality of opportunity, sanctity of life, and the rule of law.

Donate Now
Share this article:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
55 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
USN Retired
USN Retired
5 days ago

As one would say in the military “About time we unf**k this!” Maybe we will start hiring qualified people based on ability, experience, knowledge, etc . . . Instead of gender (how many of those do “they” have?) and ethnicity. DEI needs to go away completely.

Jack
Jack
5 days ago

Maybe common sense is making a comeback! Obama’s “fundamentally change America” policy nearly destroyed it.

Nick
Nick
5 days ago

Walking away from merit-based hiring just blows my mind! If a Democrat had a spouse or a child in need of critical surgery, would they select the surgeon that checked all of the Dei boxes or would they select surgeon that was most qualified to perform the operation? The lives of their spouse or children hang in the balance. Their answer tells you what’s right and what’s wrong.

Robert Zuccaro
Robert Zuccaro
5 days ago

If anyone wonders where “Luigi” got radicalized, look at the school he went to.

Uncle Bruce
Uncle Bruce
5 days ago

DEI also means – Didn’t Earn It.

Glenn Lego
Glenn Lego
5 days ago

Bad news for DEI. Good news for the rest of us.????

Honey
Honey
5 days ago

We all know that when discussing diversity in hiring, or equity or inclusion, if you asked how many conservatives have you hired as professors or administrators or have you solicited to be students, that measurement would be irrelevant. If we checked the percentage of conservatives, it would be mighty low. So much for DEI.

Stephen Russell
Stephen Russell
5 days ago

Victory for US

Theresa Coughlin
Theresa Coughlin
5 days ago

Bad news for DEI is good news for everybody else.

Uncle Bruce
Uncle Bruce
5 days ago

Reading this article again makes me think that I sure wish I had a quarter billion dollars to just pi$$ away. That’s what U of Michigan did. Oh well, we’ll just raise tuition to cover it. The paying dummies won’t notice it.

Musaiga
Musaiga
5 days ago

Presenting my not surprised face here.

Melinda
Melinda
5 days ago

It’s good that DEI has gone to die, and was a fairly short lived experiment. These universities spent so much money implementing this travesty, one would hope tuition could go down, or at least spent more wisely.

PLZ1123
PLZ1123
5 days ago

It’s about time these colleges and universities stop screwing with our children’s minds.
I’m all for diversity, but not at the expense of losing talented people. A certain level should be implemented. I personally find that having diverse people and talent helps growth.
As far as Equity, as long as they are deserving, than so be it. But it should be quantitative and fair.
As far as Inclusion, I know I’ve had to basically make myself known. If people want to be included, speak up!
Finally , no school or university should be spending millions to jump on the ‘weirdo’ bandwagon. Put that money to good use to lower tuitions, costs and other fees.

Rich
Rich
5 days ago

About time!

Robert
Robert
5 days ago

I retired from Grumman Aircraft at age 50 with 30 years back in the 90’s. In the late eighties I saw this DEI garbage come about when numerous promotional positions in my directorate area came about. I wasn’t qualified for any of the positions, but several colleagues were very qualified. They were qualified and were the best for the jobs with knowledge, ability, and outstanding records. They didn’t get the jobs; they went to women and other minorities who didn’t have abilities for what the jobs called for. Employees saw what was going on and it caused moral problems and other issues that I won’t go into. I am so thankful this crap is starting to end, and ability and knowledge will prevail over race and sex.

Susan Zitella
Susan Zitella
5 days ago

one big reason Walmart, Ford, Harley Davidson, Tractor Supply and the other companies mentioned in this article retreated from DEI policies is because of the work of Robby Starbuck’s exposure of their DEI practices or contacting them that he planned to make public those practices to their customers. I am surprised his name was not mentioned in this article as being a driving force behind their changing their DEI stance.

Olga Lena
Olga Lena
5 days ago

In my humble opinion, DEI was just another way to cause division. No positive results.

Marie Saqueton
Marie Saqueton
5 days ago

DEI is actually toxic to any society because it fosters discrimination of the worst kind. Merit based society is more motivational for students to succeed and aspire for success in life based on their talents and efforts, & not just a product of DEI, which to achievers is insulting and demeaning.

anna hubert
anna hubert
5 days ago

Results of leftist policies are all around us. That is the legacy of Biden’s presidency, no different from Obama’s. Disaster not to be forgotten.

Linder
Linder
5 days ago

Good. Finally. Affirmative Action and this stupid DEI mess has hurt the people. It’s very frustrating getting good service at almost everywhere you shop, eat out, and even have to deal with surly clerks. Hire qualified people!

Thinking
Thinking
5 days ago

The other day I was talking to someone who told me her son was working in the DEI dept of our state university. I hadn’t realized that there were depts to this movement at universities or businesses. And for almost a decade. DEI like CRT like any other cultural or moral reform cannot be legislated. In order to reach equity they allow stealing up to 999 dollars before being charged or arrested. One benefits but there also a hurt party, suffering a loss. How is that equity or unifying. What does it help by calling an overpass, trees or bridges racist. Who does that benefit. Nobody, maybe the person that says it. It might sound impressive. But if nothing happens then you only gave a voice to more division. And that is what the democrats are doing to this country. DEI doesn’t work. Let society settle this. In time people will get along all on their own. But if you order people under threat of punishment to act a certain way. You are starting a war, at least resentment.

STUDLEY HUNGWELL
STUDLEY HUNGWELL
5 days ago

I’m all FOR DEI: Deport Every Illegal!!

Bil Smith
Bil Smith
5 days ago

Society’s subversives will never quit as long as Saul Alinsky’s acolytes occupy positions of power in the national education industry, governmental agencies and managerial desks and the politicians and their supporters who dismantle traditional American values and traditions. Complete house-cleaning long overdue.

Dave O'Neil
Dave O'Neil
5 days ago

Bye Bye———- DEI!!

Ed Nolan
Ed Nolan
5 days ago

If Affirmative Action was declared illegal then why is DEI not illegal. It’s the same thing with a different name.

MAGA2024
MAGA2024
5 days ago

Never again!

Dale
Dale
5 days ago

Excellent!

Retired in Texas
Retired in Texas
5 days ago

Guess the real question is…. Who got rich on this ideal. Follow the money and you will be educated on the reason for the whole farse.

Staber
Staber
5 days ago

Hopefully a return to sanity, common sense and reason. Obama’s wet socialist dream needs to be burned to the ground, the ashes collected and then jettisoned into deep space.

Steven Parker
Steven Parker
5 days ago

The best way to fix this crap is take the Race question out of everything and hire on qualification

David P. Nelson
David P. Nelson
5 days ago

This DEI crap needs to go – ASAP!

michaelR
michaelR
5 days ago

DEI :
D—–Didn’t
E—–Earn
I——It

Marc
Marc
5 days ago

This is no surprise. People don’t want to be forced to accept others. Any acceptance would happen naturally.

Granny
Granny
5 days ago

It seems as if all these ridiculous and insane practices even when they come to the point of endangerment go away if we wait long enough. Unfortunately, children are mutilated, people die at the hands of the inept, trendy deviance changes everything from education to religious practice for years before the brainless wake up and realize the evil and absurdity of all of these things. Frankly, I’m not going to live long enough to wait out some of this nonsense…but they do pass.

Joe
Joe
5 days ago

I’ve been passed over for several positions with my current and former employer because of this DEI crap and was told by my prior employer that, in spite of my higher level of experience and qualifications, they needed to “practice inclusion” and interview candidates outside the company. My current employer still has an “Inclusion Excellence” director. I can’t wait to retire.

TPS
TPS
5 days ago

All the time, money and hiring people they didn’t need. What a waste. IMO

Drue
Drue
5 days ago

Consider this: Your father needs a heart transplant. Which doctor would you rather have performing the operation; a DEI candidate or the best doctor, regardless of race, gender or religion? That answers the question for me.

uncleferd
uncleferd
5 days ago

I’m not entirely sure the “war on woke” has really had to be a war. It was already misguided and hypocritical, and those aspects tend to rise to the surface, sooner or later. Of course, anything that can expedite it’s disappearance is not unwelcome.

CLIFFORD F GERACI
CLIFFORD F GERACI
3 days ago

What is so hard to understand, WHENEVER a decision is made based on the color of your skin or what’s between your legs is racism and sexism. Democrats and DEI is RACIST and SEXIST!!!

Sarah
Sarah
5 days ago

I just started 3 weeks ago this web income system that my friend recommended to me and I’ve gotten 2 checks for a total of $9,200… this is the best decision I made in a long time! This extra cash has changed my life in so many ways, thank you!

Here is I started_______ abre.ai/smartpay500

Trump, Biden, and Harris 2024 Political Moments
Us capitol on 100 us dollars banknotes background
crime scene tape and handcuffs, safety of america

Stay informed! Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

55
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Subscribe to AMAC Daily News and Games