Americans Are Ready for a Shift Back to Justice and Safety

The 2024 election delivered a clear and resounding message: Americans demand public safety be restored and criminals be held accountable.

In addition to Republicans sweeping Congress, reclaiming the presidency and holding the state legislative majorities, voters approved critical criminal justice ballot measures like California’s Prop 36, Colorado’s Prop 128, and Arizona’s Prop 314 that take a hard line on public safety.

Voters communicated that they want to shift back to policies that value law and order and reject policies prioritizing leniency over safety. In the future, lawmakers must listen to the concerns of their constituents and, regardless of ideology, implement policies overwhelmingly supported by voters.

For the last several years, reactionary policies have dominated criminal justice discussions. Supporters of these measures said they would promote equity and reduce incarceration rates. Yet, the results often painted a different picture. Cities like San Francisco and Chicago became symbols of rising retail theft, violent crime and a deteriorating sense of safety. Public frustration with these outcomes was palpable, and voters were straightforward about the change they wanted.

The success of California’s Prop 36 — increasing penalties for particular theft and drug crimes — underscores this demand. Even in a deeply liberal state, voters recognized that overly permissive policies had emboldened criminals.

Similarly, Colorado’s Prop 128 gives more resources to combat organized crime and drug trafficking. Arizona’s Prop 314 implements stricter measures for parole eligibility and reflects a growing consensus: criminal accountability is non-negotiable.

While critics may see these measures as a return to outdated tough-on-crime policies, they do not have to abandon the GOP’s commitment to limited, effective government and fiscal conservatism.

In fact, Republicans — especially in statehouses — are positioned to demonstrate that effective criminal justice system changes need not sacrifice their core values.

One of the hallmarks of Republican governance is fiscal responsibility. Tough-on-crime policies often face criticism for being costly, particularly when they lead to swelling prison populations. However, a smart approach to criminal justice change aligns perfectly with conservative values. 

Colorado’s Prop 128 is an example of this principle in action. By channeling funds toward combating organized crime and the opioid epidemic, the state can address pressing issues without resorting to overly broad punitive measures.

As crime is dealt with more so at the state and local level, leaders can champion policies that target violent offenders and organized crime networks without endorsing policies that fill prisons unnecessarily. This approach is tough and smart, emphasizing accountability while addressing systemic inefficiencies. 

The recently passed Oklahoma Survivors Act is an excellent example. It will reduce sentences for people with domestic violence convictions that stemmed from their abuse.

At the heart of criminal justice initiatives is the need to support victims of crime. For too long, policies that prioritize the rights of offenders over victims have eroded public trust in the system. Republicans can correct this imbalance by ensuring victims have a voice in the justice process and expanding resources for crime prevention. Arizona’s Prop 314, which limits parole for certain offenses, aligns with this vision. By ensuring that dangerous offenders serve their sentences, the measure prioritizes victims’ safety. It sends a clear message that justice will be served.

In recent years, one of the toughest challenges has been declining public trust in the criminal justice system. Perceived leniency toward offenders, coupled with rising crime rates and the public’s perception of dangerousness, has left many Americans feeling unsafe and disillusioned. Republicans can restore faith in the system by enforcing laws consistently and transparently, reducing case backlogs and improving court efficiency, and focusing on data-driven policies that deliver real results instead of relying on ideological experiments.

The American criminal justice system is at an inflection point. The public is demanding policies that protect their communities, hold serious and violent offenders accountable, and restore balance to the system. Republicans can lead with policies that are smart on crime, are fiscally responsible, and are focused on victims and public safety.

Reprinted with permission from DC Journal by Jillian Snider.

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of AMAC or AMAC Action.