Newsline

Education , Newsline

Campus Drones, Student Norms, and the Toxic Collegiate Culture

Posted on Friday, September 29, 2023
|
by Outside Contributor
|
24 Comments
racist and homophobic incidents of hate speech protest at college campus

It has become exhausting to catalog the ways in which higher education has lost the plot. The DEI loyalty oaths. The way conservatives get harassedthreatened, and subjected to double standards. Plenty of professors acknowledge they’d be less likely to hire colleagues who are Republican or evangelical.

All of this has come in for well-deserved criticism. Indeed, red-state legislators have started to take long-overdue steps to address some of these issues.

But there are two enabling factors that tend to get less attention than they deserve (perhaps because they’re less susceptible to legislative solutions). One is the role of deep-set student attitudes, and not just the stylings of ideologues, in stifling speech. The other is how an army of campus administrators has made things worse. These student norms and bureaucrats have contributed mightily to the toxic collegiate culture.

About those student biases: College Pulse and the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression recently published their invaluable annual report on the state of campus free speech, documenting the erosion of student respect for the free exchange of ideas and the normalization of ideological bias. Sixty-three percent of students say it is acceptable to shout down speakers on campus. More than a quarter say the same about using violence to stop a campus speech.

Of course, it’s not conservatives driving this illiberalism. Students are systematically more hostile to right-leaning sentiments. When asked if their college should “allow” a speaker who argues that “transgender people have a mental disorder,” 44% of students would bar them from campus. For a speaker who urges banning all abortions, 39% would.

The results were very different for left-leaning speakers. Just 9%, for instance, would bar a speaker from campus who calls for repealing the Second Amendment. Overall, about 4 in 10 students would bar right-leaning speakers from campus. For left-leaning speakers, the figure was more like 1 in 10.

The Constructive Dialogue Institute reported that nearly a quarter of college students say they’ve been involved in “calling out, punishing, or ‘canceling’” someone. Again, this is driven by the Left, with 42% of students who identify as “very liberal” saying they’ve canceled someone. The figure among “very conservative” students? Eight percent. The result? Perhaps not so surprisingly, a remarkable 45% of students say they’re frequently afraid to share their thoughts in the classroom.

Then there are the ranks of campus bureaucrats. A few years ago, my colleague Sam Abrams reported that, among college administrators, liberals outnumber conservatives by 12 to 1! This was twice the (already lopsided) rate among faculty, making administrators “the most left-leaning group on campus.” Abrams aptly observed, “When it comes to collegiate life — living in dorms, participating in extracurricular organizations — the ever growing ranks of administrators have the biggest influence.” These midtier functionaries invite speakers, set campus norms, deliver training, and explain what it means to be “tolerant” or “open-minded.”

As student-run social hubs such as fraternities and sororities become less influential while campuses seek to expand social and emotional supports, more and more of college life is shaped by this petty officialdom. And the associations that speak for these administrators make no bones about their shared agendas. Student affairs administrators think their job is to advance “social justice” and that “anti-bias” response teams are swell. Admissions counselors almost uniformly believe the Supreme Court was wrong to strike down the use of race-based admissions preferences. DEI officials embrace an approach to “anti-racism” that teaches that our institutions help subjugate “people of color” and “overserve white people.”

So, by all means, treat DEI loyalty oaths as the coercive instruments they are. Insist upon more transparency when it comes to hiring and outcomes, and push back on ideological instruction. But that won’t be enough unless we also change campus culture by teaching students to understand and respect free inquiry while defanging bloated, agenda-driven bureaucracies.

How do we do all this? A few places to start:

We should demand that K-12 schools do much more to teach an understanding of basic rights, especially those embodied in the First Amendment. Institute mandatory trainings for new students in what it means to respect free speech on campus, like James Madison University did this fall. Boards of trustees should insist that campus officials pare nonessential or unduly ideological administrative roles. And college leaders should make clear that respect for intellectual diversity must be a big consideration in staff hires.

None of this will miraculously “fix” the corrosive culture that has taken hold in many institutions of higher education. But such measures will help, doubly so if pursued in concert with the more direct legal and statutory efforts that are underway.

Frederick M. Hess is a senior fellow and the director of education policy studies at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), where he works on K–12 and higher education issues. The author of Education Week’s popular blog “Rick Hess Straight Up,” Dr. Hess is also an executive editor of Education Next, and a Forbes senior contributor. He is the founder and chairman of AEI’s Conservative Education Reform Network.

Reprinted with Permission from AEI.org – By Frederick M. Hess

Share this article:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
24 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
spitfire?1940
spitfire?1940
6 months ago

What a bunch of spoiled brats,absolutely no life experience whatsoever and they think they know everything.Bring back the draft and make them dig ditches in a pioneer corps environment. Then and only then, allow them to express their opinions.

Donna
Donna
6 months ago

I don’t have any confidence that the public school system can be a positive stepping stone for our youth. The school system like our nation has turned its back on God. Our children’s lives are too precious to waste time hoping the schools will improve. Children have one chance at childhood and the input of valuable skill development. Home school or private school are the only options for a successful outcomes.

Rik
Rik
6 months ago

Also, I WOULDN’T TRUST Any of Those on that so-called DEBATE STAGE to Save America because Every One of Them Are Professional Politicians with a Proven Track Record of Allowing This to Happen in the First Place!

Rik
Rik
6 months ago

Colleges today are ALL MARXIST Educational and Training Facilities!

People, We are LOST as a COUNTRY unless President Trump is Elected President again! The Left knows it and FEARS TRUMP’S REELECTION!

And Truthfully, it’s OUR LAST CHANCE at SAVING CAPITALISM!

I fear that CIVIL WAR is Our LAST OPTION but Only Because the so-called Democratic Communists will AGAIN CHEAT and STEAL the NEXT PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION TOO! And our so-called Republican Electorate will just ALLOW IT TO HAPPEN with ONLY A WHIPPER!

PREPARE TO DIE Conservatives!

spitfire?1940
spitfire?1940
6 months ago

Dear Neanderthal (look it up in a dictionary ,pronounced (Dik-Shon-ary) Fred,many years ago William Pitt of the British House of Commons proclaimed,”Necessity is the plea for every infringement of human liberty; it is the argument of tyrants; it is the creed of slaves”.Let that sink in to that empty skull cavity Mr Flintstone before you insult Dr Hess who has more intellectual capacity in one of his toe nail clippings than you,my dear chap possess in your entire waste of space body.Please feel free to reply

Spitfire?1940
Spitfire?1940
6 months ago

Ah yes,thank you Fred for the illustration of what a Democrat voter looks like.I must say you chose your Non de Plume very well.From the contents of your infantile posts you are indeed a cave man,and an extremely ignorant one at that.Please continue posting your childish comments Fred because,well you know!

Rik
Rik
6 months ago

Comrade Punkydoodle, when I went to college they didn’t teach Communism like they do today!

Rik
Rik
6 months ago

This CLARABELLE NEEDS another SPANKING for DISRESPECTING HIS ELDERS!

Rik
Rik
6 months ago

CLARABELLE, what do you know about being a Christian? Brainwashed 15 year old Communist wannabe AMERICAN HATER!

Rik
Rik
6 months ago

Says the 15 year old CLARABELLE who is brainwashed to HATE AMERICA!

spifire?1940
spifire?1940
6 months ago

Separation of Church and State.DOES NO APPEAR IN THE U.S.CONSTITUTION.Thomas Jefferson ln a letter to The Danbury Baptists mentioned that “A wall of separation should exist between the State and the Church”meaning that the State,(government) should not interfere ln Church business.Not the other way round.Read the Constitution if you don’ believe me.And the 1st Amendment.

Tom
Tom
6 months ago

The lefttards has taken over AMAC’s comment board on this article. Trolls all.

An older blonde women laughing in the kitchen with a grey haired man.
AMAC’s Medicare Advisory Service
The knowledge, guidance, and choices of coverage you’re looking for. The exceptional service you deserve.
The AMAC App on 3 different iPhone
Download the AMAC App
The AMAC App is the place to go for insightful news wherever you are and whenever you want.
Joe Biden speaking with attendees
NEW YORK - OCT 10:American homeless sleeps in New York city subway on October 10 2009.A 2013 report show that the number of homeless people recorded in NYC topped 50,000 for the first time.
Former President of the United States Donald Trump speaking with attendees at the 2023 Turning Point Action Conference at the Palm Beach County Convention Center in West Palm Beach, Florida.
gen z and boomers; election - pick your side poster

Stay informed! Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

24
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Subscribe to AMAC Daily News and Games