Election Coverage / Government Watch / Politics

Is the Left Losing the Left?

AMAC Exclusive – By Seamus Brennan


In recent months, a handful of prominent liberals have displayed growing unease at the increasing totalitarianism of the far left—most notably in response to their attacks on free speech, censorship of their political opponents, and a series of media-contrived manipulations intended to sway public opinion. This under-the-radar development could be the first sign that, after years of monolithic uniformity among the left-wing news media, corporate leaders, and cultural elites, the unity of the progressive movement might be—at long last—starting to crack. Assuming the left’s authoritarian streak continues, the progressive movement may soon find that its once-loyal defenders are jumping ship.

For the evidently small number of figures on the left who still value independent thought, this summer’s Mar-a-Lago raid appears to have served as a “crossing the Rubicon” moment that revealed the disturbing extent to which the radical left will go to harm its political adversaries and seize control of every American institution. Though most of the media’s attitude was predictably celebratory following the raid, several high-profile voices on the left warned of the ways it could backfire and further reveal the totalitarian inclinations of the progressive movement.

Talk show host Bill Maher, for instance—an outspoken leftist who for much of his career has toed the line of the Democrat Party—suggested the raid was a “political nightmare,” stating that it is “saving Trump politically” and making him into a “martyr” figure for conservatives. Maher’s statements are particularly significant given his well-established pattern of anti-Trump commentary and considering that the bulk of his audience is partisan Democrats. Notably, Maher has also been critical of the left’s embrace of radical gender ideology and their general “snobbiness.”

But Maher’s statements only scratch the surface of the rising resistance to the Mar-a-Lago incident from a small but influential group on the left. Shadi Hamid, a fellow at the Brookings Institution, a prominent liberal think tank, has also sounded the alarm. In mid-August, he tweeted that he doesn’t “see any plausible scenario where [the raid] ends up being good for American democracy,” stating that there’s “no reason to celebrate it,” going on to mock “liberals’ sudden, unquestioning trust in law enforcement and the FBI” after years of left-wing skepticism toward federal law enforcement. “What grates when a large number of liberals talk about Trump is the unusual mix of utter self-righteousness and blatant hypocrisy,” he wrote. “Those cheering the Trump investigation on would never apply this same prosecutorial approach to their own side.”

Hamid’s concerns were echoed by notable left-wing journalist Sasha Stone, once a self-proclaimed “true blue Democrat” who “voted faithfully” for Democrats “in every election”—including for Biden in 2020. Following the raid, however, she published a widely read blog post entitled “The Raid that Red-Pilled America,” in which she argued that “Americans have seen, maybe for the first time, that our government has become too powerful, too punitive, and too authoritarian in crushing dissenting voices and outsiders who challenge that authority.” She continued: “I am not MAGA. I am not a Conservative… But the red pill is a powerful one. Once you find your way out of the bubble of hysteria on the Left, it feels more like normal life.”

In another widely read piece published this month by the Claremont Institute’s American Mind, a writer who goes by the pseudonym “Liberal Guy” had a message for the magazine’s intellectual conservative readership: “I want to offer my sincerest apologies for your present illiberal treatment by the Democrats, especially progressive Democrats. Your rights as Americans are being violated—in speech and in deed and in broad daylight. If present trends continue, it’s not going to end well for America.”

The writer continued with wise advice for conservatives: Leftists, he said, “are provoking folks who see themselves as American patriots so that they can cast them as domestic terrorists. Don’t take the bait.”

But indications that progressives’ grip on the prevailing narrative may be loosening extend far beyond just the August Mar-a-Lago raid. In one of the more well-known instances of a major public figure distancing himself from the mantras and orthodoxies of the far left, Tesla CEO Elon Musk—a onetime icon of blue America—famously launched a bid to purchase Twitter, stating that the platform’s failure to “adhere to free speech principles fundamentally undermines democracy.” But he took his comments much further in May, declaring the Democrat Party to be “the party of division & hate” and vowing to vote for Republicans going forward. “Unless it is stopped, the woke mind virus will destroy civilization,” he wrote in a May tweet.

Though progressives of course still wield a disproportionate amount of power in public life, there are signs that even for their own supporters, they have overstepped. Hopefully, that realization will grow rapidly in the months ahead.

We hope you've enjoyed this article. While you're here, we have a small favor to ask...

Support AMAC Action. Our 501 (C)(4) advances initiatives on Capitol Hill, in the state legislatures, and at the local level to protect American values, free speech, the exercise of religion, equality of opportunity, sanctity of life, and the rule of law.

Donate Now

If You Enjoy Articles Like This - Subscribe to the AMAC Daily Newsletter
and Download the AMAC News App

Sign Up Today Download

If You Enjoy Articles Like This - Subscribe to the AMAC Daily Newsletter!

Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
1 month ago

Here’s my/my family’s thought:: We will NEVER EVER vote for a democrat again. Everrrrrrrr !!!

Michael Lewis
1 month ago

After Watergate, to protect the public from the appearance of corruption, The Federal Election Campaign Act abridged the freedoms of speech press and assembly of the regulated class: candidates for Federal Office, political parties, PAC’s and individual citizens.
Corporate media were exempted from campaign laws because government could not infringe on their 1st Amendment rights. However, if the 1st Amendment defined the institutional press as the definition of press, there would be no need to exempt them from campaign law:
52 U.S. Code § 30101 – Definitions (9)(B) The term “expenditure” does not include— (i) any news story, commentary, or editorial distributed through the facilities of any broadcasting station, newspaper, magazine, or other periodical publication, unless such facilities are owned or controlled by any political party, political committee, or candidate; – law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/52/30101
52 U.S. Code § 30101 created a “Royal”, “State Approved” press!
if candidates and political parties have to pay for time/space in the media, then editorials have political value. The “press exemption” insures the corporate voice retains more influence than the voice of the electorate.
To restore equal rights to citizens, federal candidates, political parties and PACs “We the People” should ask our representatives in the Senate and House to revisit the “Free All Speech Act of 2014.”
2d Session
S. 2416
June 3, 2014
Mr. Cruz introduced the following bill; which was read twice and referred to the Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation
To apply laws that restrict the political speech of American citizens to media corporations.
1. Short title
This Act may be cited as the Free All Speech Act of 2014 .
2. Application of laws that restrict the political speech of American citizens to media corporations
(a) In general
Any law that restricts the political speech of American citizens shall apply with equal force to media corporations, such as the New York Times, the American Broadcasting Company (ABC), the National Broadcasting Company (NBC), and the CBS Television Network.
(b) No application to American citizens if application to media corporations found unconstitutional
To the extent that the application of a law to a media corporation under subsection (a) is found unconstitutional, such law shall have no force or effect with respect to American citizens.

1 month ago

Don’t break out the champagne just yet. The Left have their intramural squabbles as any group do, but they are remarkably resilient. If they weren’t, they wouldn’t have been able to take over every important institution in the former USA. They do have fragmentation in their future, but that will only occur when whites are reduced to a permanent and persecuted minority.

Kevin Griggs
1 month ago

The dems don’t understand that what they do to us and be done to them. Foolish thinking.

Mario Capparuccini
1 month ago

The radical progressive Democratic Party is energized by their master, the devil. He never sleeps and seemingly his minions never sleep either. They always devise evil, always hate, always divide. You could spread a beautiful banquet in front of them and they would say it represents systemic racism or some such garbage.

Bill Halcott
1 month ago

Whom the gods wish to destroy they first drive insane.

Judy Gonzales
1 month ago
Reply to  Bill Halcott

I didnt, and wouldn’t have given your comment a minus vote, but connecting with your thought about “the gods” part, I didn’t quite feel the connection with driving people insane part. As the ‘gods’ as you put it, are working feverishly to destroy everything this country has stood for in the past, I don’t think it’s driving people insane, I think we’re very angry and disgusted with THEIR insanity.

1 month ago

Bad read on the Mar -A-Largo raid. Many of us seniors served in the military or government. Trumps conduct of safeguarding national security information was reckless and irresponsible all through his Administration and after. Three people – Trump, Harris, and Biden – all unfit for the office of the President.

1 month ago
Reply to  chrisford1

How many classified documents do you think exist among the 30 million documents the Obama Administration has stored in a defunct furniture warehouse in Chicago as I write this? Should he get the same treatment?

Pam Chitwood
1 month ago

When I see Italy vote in a new conservative leader it gives me hope. Just like the hope I got when the brits wanted out of the EU. We got Trump. We are not so different. People all over get tired of the crazy left and have to pull us back to the center….all over.

Michael McBrearty
1 month ago

Anyone stupid enough to believe that Democrats are Communists is stupid enough to believe anything.

J. Shenk
1 month ago

Not so long ago an avowed Marxist such as Senator Bernie Sanders would have been laughed off the stage at any public event. Now he is embraced by the Democratic Party. The man nearly got the 2020 nomination! What does that tell you?

Mario Capparuccini
1 month ago

Any person who is foolish enough to not detect the Marxist/Communist underpinnings of critical race theory and queer theory does not deserve to be taken seriously. Such a person deserves the loss of freedom that the radicals will bring if they increase their power.

Judy Gonzales
1 month ago

Oh boy! We need laughing emojis!!
Lol! I’m curious, who’s rose colored glasses are you looking through?
How can you watch Biden during a speech and not see his inability to stay focused? His mumbling and slurred speech is strikingly obvious. And when he’s finished he doesn’t know where to exit, and sometimes tries to shake hands with the invisible man. Take your blinders off, your making yourself look, well, foolish. And besides not recognizing what Communism looks like in the Dems views and actions, compared to what our ‘competant’ leaders have always demonstrated in the past, your either very uninformed, misinformed, or inept. I’m sorry, but some Americans need to wake up and smell the coffee. Our country is being destroyed by Biden and whomever is pulling his strings.

1 month ago
Reply to  Judy Gonzales

II believe that Obummer is the puppet master.

1 month ago

Richard Blumenthal CT senator went to a communist party gala. Gave a speech and awards when the news questioned him he lied and said he didn’t know it was a communist event .look it up…the progressives want socialism and are honest about it ,open your eyes and realize the democrat party is long gone.George soros and friends are going to get their one world order

Rowdy Mon
2 months ago

The democrat party has become the party of groomers, puberty blockers, fiscal irresponsibility, crime and criminals, no sovereign borders (unless it’s Ukraine) and fealty to the CCP. How anyone can standby and endorse this ilk with their vote, should be imprisoned for Treason. This is intentional sabotage funded by the likes of Soros, to foment corruption and division. We will have to curb this behavior with force, lethal if necessary.

2 months ago
Reply to  Rowdy Mon

Don’t take the bait. Responding with violence is not the answer and will only make our situation worse.

We still have a system within which we can fix this peacefully.

Judy Gonzales
1 month ago
Reply to  wakeupcall

I doN’T KNOW, but I do resort to prayer a lot! Our Constitution allows for the legal American Citizens to form Militia’s to stand against a rogue government, which is exactly what we have in this country right now.
Problem is, these devils have trans-formed our national fighting defenses, namely our Military along with our court systems, and our National Security Agency. So we probably wouldn’t be able to pull it off….unless God himself was leading the charge.

1 month ago
Reply to  Judy Gonzales

I would rather die fighting tyrants than to live under their rule.

1 month ago
Reply to  wakeupcall

You think?

2 months ago

Liberalism is, by its own definition, never content with anything that has already been tried and tested. It always seeks change, no matter how destructive. Occasionally, it stumbles onto something good that works, but generally it is just too aggressive, too disconnected and too uncaring for the accomplishments of past generations to temper its own ambition. Ultimately, it always turns powerful civilizations into decadent whore-houses that collapse under their own weight.

2 months ago
Reply to  Luke

I have a theory that the left is essentially only effective as a minority party. In that role, they do provide a check on some over-reaching acts. Think of ACLU some years ago and their commitment to objectively protect rights even for groups that everyone hates. Fighting against use of torture by military, etc. All things that can be argued for via writing and other media advocacy, without holding the levers of power.

But, when they have majority control of a government, they are ineffective in every key area: fighting poverty, foreign policy, economic health. The roots of their philosophy, socialism, relies on a belief in human nature that has simply proven to be untrue, repeatedly. As soon as they centralize power, the worst people clamor for that position. Eventually, they form a cabal of corrupt leadership whose deeds they can’t keep hidden forever.

2 months ago

Will see if these warnings change anything in November, the left will vote the way they always do thinking dem politicians will change. You know the definition of crazy, doing the same over and over expecting a different result.

2 months ago
Reply to  TPS

I feel that the new “playing field” is in the cheating. The Democrats are already beat by the numbers, badly. But, they have the money to spend on schemes to cheat for the next 100 elections. We have to defeat that through volunteer work, poll monitoring, reporting vote cheating.

I think it would be worthwhile for the GOP to consider a messaging drive about this: “A fraudulent vote is a legal vote removed.” Democrats shield these operators from consequences with their liberal attorneys. But, I think it would still be effective to advertise what the penalties for voter fraud are.

Jake the snake
2 months ago

The problem we have starts with the schools. The schools don’t need tobmake a profit, sre not responsible for the quality of their product and do not have to manage any kind of real budget.

We need 100% school vouchers. That will change all of that and make schools competitive

2 months ago
Reply to  Jake the snake

Thank You! School Administrators should have Full Audit of all Personal Finances every 6 months. Most of them have become Multi Millionaires over the past 4-7 years! Just Like the Criminals in Congress! They PUSH the illegal and immoral content of whatever faction is paying them off at that time. Kids are victims of all sorts of mind-bending abuses, but the $$$ keeps rolling in for School Administrators who answer to NO ONE.

2 months ago

“At the core of liberalism is the spoiled child-miserable, as all spoiled children are, unsatisfied, demanding, ill-disciplined, despotic and useless. Liberalism is a philosophy of sniveling brats.” 

 — P.J. O’Rourke

“It is usually futile to try to talk facts and analysis to people who are enjoying a sense of moral superiority in their ignorance.” ― Dr. Thomas Sowell

Judy Gonzales
1 month ago
Reply to  Goldwaterite

Very good!

2 months ago

We have an incredibly large portion of the people in the United States that are politically throughly ignorant. I mean completely vacuous. This has nothing to do with red, blue, black, white, purple or green (although it is no doubt true that the greatest proportion of airheads are politically blue).
My point here is that those (a very large quantity) that voted for Brandon only because they did not want Trump still continue with minds that are devoid of any synaptic processes. When asked they still reply: “I voted for Brandon because I could not vote for Trump because of how he is/how he acts with….” And when asked for an example of this supposed diverse behavior from Trump their reply is “You know” and are virtually unable to provide any examples (other than maybe it is because the mainstream media said Trump is bad).
These same people (the ones with vacuous minds) are likely close to a minimum of 50% of the voting population. While our nation is literally crumbling in front of us all, they really have no clue. It is kind of like getting guns out of the hands of mentally unstable people. How do we do that?
These are the people that the true patriots need to reach. How?
My guess is that, since they are likely blindly watching deceitful duplicity of mainstream media sources, we need to reach them there. Nine of them are here in AMAC. Step out of our own reality and reach down to their level to explain the veracity of the nation.

2 months ago
Reply to  Jeanine

The zombies you refer to are still sleepwalking comfortably. Unfortunately, high gas prices and inflation haven’t been enough to break the spell. More suffering of an acute nature and undeniably caused by the commies will be required. But…the poison media can spin trouble away effectively.

2 months ago

To be clear, Democrats are looters, Tammany thieves, and perverted yuppie materialists. The good people of the USA are soon going to send those leftist parasites to he11.

Janet B
2 months ago

The people who blindly voted for this administration and any of the leftist Senators and Representatives should be waking up to what is happening and move back to the center line if they want to continue to be free. American leadership has become the laughing stock of the world and every day we move closer to destruction and economic disaster. Gas prices are increasing again and very quickly I might add while the cost of everything is continuing to go up. The more the tax and spend party continues in its current path, the closer we come to the end of America as we have known it. We just need to pray that people wake up and come together to end this terror.

2 months ago

The extent of this totalitarian rhetoric is no more red vs blue. It’s good vs evil, it’s American vs anti-American. The people who voted for the empty suit in power better wake up real soon and not vote party but issues. It’s the rich vs the poor/ middle class. The Dems will turn against their voting base once they take total control and they will be standing beside us regretting they supported these Marxist pigs. But fortunately for us GOD is in control and hates pride and injustice especially against HIS people. Fasten your seat belts cause a whirlwind is about to hit them hard….thank you JESUS

2 months ago
Reply to  Anthony

Pray without ceasing!

2 months ago
Reply to  mytake

Our country does need prayers. It is falling apart.

2 months ago
Reply to  Anthony


2 months ago

Self realization comes way too late for many on the left side of sanity.

2 months ago

Tyrant led party doing what tyrants do. Making popcorn to watch the implosion.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x