Government Watch / Politics

The CBO: Democrats Propose Changing Long-Standing Rules to Push More Spending


“Learn the rules, break the rules, make up new rules, break the new rules,” the late American poet Marvin Bell is quoted as saying. One might think he was describing Congressional Democrats. These days, Congressional Democrats spend almost as much time trying to win elections as they do trying to come up with ways to change the rules of the game. While hollow threats from Senate Democrats to end the filibuster have made headlines in recent months, what is lesser known is the fact that Democrats are also playing games with the Congressional Budget Office rules, specifically as they relate to the impending $3.5 trillion FY21 budget reconciliation bill. So how do Democrats propose changing long-standing rules to push more spending?

“When Republicans have used dynamic scoring in the past, Bernie Sanders called it a ‘gimmick’ and a way to ‘cook the books.’ Now Democrats are using the same strategy,” POLITICO reported last month. Right now, Democrats are weighing how much they want to rely on the concept of dynamic scoring in their efforts to offset some of the cost of President Joe Biden’s $3.5 trillion FY21 budget reconciliation bill.

Here’s what Democrats plan to say. They will claim that their wild spending proposals will spur economic growth, increase jobs and wages, and therefore bring in more money into the U.S. treasury. That increased revenue is then factored into the overall cost of the bill as a spending offset or pay for. The problem is that those projections are not always accurate, often exaggerated, and they don’t account for potential economic downturns, like a massive hurricane hitting the East Coast or a global pandemic.

In addition, Democrats plan to add non-budgetary spending proposals to the bill, which, though non-germane, they will argue will have a positive impact on economic growth, will help offset the costs, and therefore should be included.

Interestingly, when Republicans applied the concept of dynamic scoring in the past, it was regarding tax cuts and were used to show the minor associated costs. Now, Democrats are proposing to change the CBO rules in order to use dynamic scoring to illustrate a large revenue windfall it will bring so that they can spend that much more in advance.

But while Democrats scolded Republicans about cheating the system, they are now scraping for revenue and ready to employ dynamic scoring themselves. Republicans called for reasonable reforms that more accurately showed the positive economic effects from letting Americans keep more of their own money. Democrats hope to show that spending has a similarly stimulative effect by changing economic models that were once off-limits to favor their position.

“We’re way beyond the frontiers of what we can be confident of, economically. It’s just a way for members to pretend that they’re paying for something,” stated David Wessel, Director of Fiscal and Monetary Policy at the Brookings Institution.

The Democrats’ “do as I say, not as I do” approach is doomed to backfire. Their tactics reek of desperation and an inability to govern lawfully. If this is the type of Mickey Mouse games Democrats want to play, it won’t be lost on the American people, and it will backfire at the ballot box too.

We hope you've enjoyed this article. While you're here, we have a small favor to ask...

Support AMAC Action. Our 501 (C)(4) advances initiatives on Capitol Hill, in the state legislatures, and at the local level to protect American values, free speech, the exercise of religion, equality of opportunity, sanctity of life, and the rule of law.

Donate Now

If You Enjoy Articles Like This - Subscribe to the AMAC Daily Newsletter
and Download the AMAC News App

Sign Up Today Download

If You Enjoy Articles Like This - Subscribe to the AMAC Daily Newsletter!

Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
11 months ago

Just remember, and it will never change, DEMOCRAT stands for Deeply Entrenched Members Openly Committed to Removing American Traditions. If the last six months have not shown us this truth God help us!

11 months ago

More fantastic ideas of the Biden Administration. Good luck Comrades!

11 months ago

We are in a position,can we use the ballot box as an argument? What is an answer after they treat us like dummies,pass laws that take away states rights??in the name of “justice for all”.I don’t think so.

11 months ago

Try this tactic to run a budget in any circumstances ( business or individual) is basing income on wish/ dream reality. Most corporations that use “predictions of revenue “ are Assuming a result on a maybe. Aside from their less than realistic assumptions we are not getting any real solution to achieve the proposals. Because they say so doesn’t mean that it will happen.

11 months ago

Thought Democrats were supposed to be Americans who really cared about our country but after Biden’s catastrophe

11 months ago

Like a college freshman his first time away from home. Drink, party, spend. Phone dad for more money. And we’re dad. Raise our taxes and then print all the money you need. Soon it will all come crashing down.

11 months ago
Reply to  CoNMTX

But dad eventually cuts the cord and the funds while the child has a tantrum and tries to sue for their “entitlement “.

John Reid
11 months ago

The demoncrates will succeed. Sadly the ballot box proves how gullible the voting public is.2 terms of Obama and them a joker that hid in his basement. One who continues to hide in his basement. Not I but we the people voted against Trump. This country is doomed.

11 months ago

The corrupt democrats will do ANYTHING to obtain access to money.
They will fleece,steal, lie,and destroy America.
It is the party of evil, with no morals,no shame, no loyalty to the Citizens or this Great Country.
They are communists, socialists,racists,anti American scum, intent on destroying America!!!
They must be exposed, prosecuted and removed from office for Crimes against America.

11 months ago
Reply to  Garye

You summed it up very accurately Garye!

11 months ago
Reply to  Garye

You said it correctly.

11 months ago
Reply to  Garye

I forget who said it, but the quote is, “Anyone who will kill babies, is capable of anything”. And the demo/globalists are capable of anything.

11 months ago

More games being played that spell the demise of the free enterprise system and economy. A means to make more citizens dependent on the government and thus slaves to that government. Pure politics for politics sake, to improve their standing, achieve power and profit from the disaster…..a re-run of the same movie, in a different theater.

J. Farley
11 months ago

Pardon me, but, screw-um !!!!!!!!!
God Bless America !

11 months ago

It will backfire at the ballot box unless the Democrats and the media continue their lying and fraud.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x