Newsline

Newsline , Society

Why Blue State Politicians’ Tax Cartel Attempt Will Fail

Posted on Thursday, February 2, 2023
|
by Outside Contributor
|
33 Comments

Cartels are groups of organizations that collude with each other to drive up prices, crush competition, and ultimately extort huge amounts of money to redistribute to the cartel members. While the word is often associated with drugsoil-producing countries, or anti-competitive business practices, politicians from nine blue states are attempting something new in the U.S.—a tax cartel.

State legislators from California, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Minnesota, New York, Oregon, and Washington announced a coordinated set of bills to hike taxes on wealthy individuals, families, and businesses. The purpose of coordinating is to try to keep these taxpayers in their respective states by making it seem like crushing taxes are inevitable wherever they move.

But this desperate attempt to defy the laws of economics—whereby if you tax something, you get less of it—is doomed to fail.

Blue state politicians have an insatiable appetite for more tax revenues so that they can create big-government programs that serve as selling points in their election campaigns. But while politicians want to dole out programs and money to everyone and their brother, they want the average voter to believe that somebody else can pay for all these programs. So, they go after the big dogs—the millionaires and billionaires.

California Assembly Bill 259, for example, would impose a 1% tax on those with a net worth of $50 million or more and a 1.5% tax on residents with a net worth of $1 billion or more. Unlike income taxes—which in theory only apply to new income earned in the past year—wealth taxes like this would tax the same dollars year after year.

When combined with federal income taxes, net investment income taxes, state income taxes that are the highest in the nation, property taxes, and the like, some California taxpayers would face an effective income tax rate of more than 100%.

New York Senate Bill 1570 would apply an 8.2% billionaires’ tax to unrealized capital gains on the value of stocks, closely held businesses, and other investments—often based on subjective assessments of year-to-year increases in asset values.

The other seven states’ bills differ on the details but are aligned in trying to stick more of the tax burden on the rich.

Rolling out these taxes as a coordinated effort instead of in isolation is an attempt to avoid an exodus of wealthy individuals from high-tax states. The highly publicized moves of billionaires leaving for lower-tax states—like hedge fund CEO Ken Griffin moving his Citadel headquarters from Illinois to Florida, Elon Musk moving Tesla’s headquarters from California to Texas, and investor Carl Icahn moving from New York to Florida—are just a few examples of what blue state lawmakers want to avoid.

Becoming a cartel requires having control over enough of a market to take down the competition, at which point cartels can restrict output, control prices, and reap huge profits. 

That’s what this group of blue state politicians erroneously seems to think it can achieve, as Illinois state Rep. Will Guzzardi, a Democrat, explained: “That’s part of why we are working as a multistate coalition. We want to send a message that there is nowhere to hide.”

But taxpayers can still legally “hide” their wealth in certain assets like out-of-state real estate and tangible property.

And if they don’t want to hide their assets by purchasing things that are harder for politicians to tax, there are still plenty of places for them to run, much to the chagrin of these blue-state lawmakers. Wealthy individuals can escape high-tax regimes by moving to low-tax states that will welcome them with open arms. Indeed, high-income tax states are already hemorrhaging their populations.

Twenty-two states and the District of Columbia have top personal and corporate income tax rates that average above 6%.

Census data shows that last year there was a net outflow of more than 1 million residents from these high-income tax states and Washington to the other 28 states. This dramatic trend of migration into low-tax states isn’t new, though it’s accelerated in recent years.

The fact that middle-income Americans are also fleeing from high-income tax states demonstrates that when state lawmakers try to soak the rich with high taxes, everybody ultimately gets drenched.

These new taxes aimed directly at the rich would put more of the wealthiest taxpayers in the front of the exodus. And when the people who pay the most in taxes leave, that means big tax hikes on everyone who’s left.

Wealth taxes, especially, are incredibly ineffective at raising revenues. A dozen countries in Europe had wealth taxes in 1990, and all but three abandoned them either because the administrative costs were prohibitive or because the taxes were driving wealth and jobs out of their countries.

Of the three countries that kept their wealth tax, Spain’s and Norway’s are largely ineffective, accounting for only 0.5% and 1.2% of the countries’ respective total tax revenues. And those wealth taxes apply to households that accumulate only a modest amount of wealth over their lifetimes. Norway’s tax begins at only $170,000 of net taxable wealth.

Switzerland’s wealth tax generates more revenue—about 4.9% of its tax revenues—but that’s because it applies to almost all housing, working effectively like a property tax so nearly everyone—certainly not just the rich—pays the tax directly or indirectly through higher rents and mortgage payments.

This all goes to show an uncomfortable reality for blue-state lawmakers: Massive government spending schemes funded by piling the tax burden onto a tiny number of wealthy taxpayers will ultimately collapse under their own weight.

The states that attract new residents take a very different approach of using broad-based sales taxes to pay for necessary—but more limited—government spending.

And because workers and employers prefer to keep more of what they earn and like having the economic freedom to decide for themselves how to spend their own money instead of having to jump through bureaucratic hoops to see what government programs can provide for them, Americans keep moving to these states in droves.

Share this article:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
33 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Tim Toroian
Tim Toroian
1 year ago

If a “wealth” tax gets by SCOTUS it will be time to invoke the second paragraph of the Declaration of independence.

Tim Toroian
Tim Toroian
1 year ago

I want to see Gavin Newsom go bald.

Sharon Ormsby
Sharon Ormsby
1 year ago

Our teachers from Spain had to send a lot of their checks back to Spain to pay taxes. They would speak of it in our teacher’s lounge. I’m not sure how that worked, but it was something that was built into them being able to work within the states and in Texas. I guess it had to do with immigration law or specifically with them being from Spain. I foresee a lot more of that happening with so many illegals having crossed our Southern border happening with their children and needing Spanish speaking teachers. We didn’t have enough of them in Texas, so I know the nation doesn’t have enough. They’ll have to get them Spain, as the countries to the South don’t have enough education to come here to teach. The ones who do, will stay in their schools there. Does anyone know how those taxes work?

tlanger
tlanger
1 year ago

Well… just look at the states involved. That’s why people are leaving them by the car load. As noted, states that do this kind of thing lose population, money and more. And people that have that kind of money didn’t get it being stupid. There are 43 other states, the off shore havens where people like the Pelosi families and others keep their money. Who was it who said from each according to his abilities to each according to his need… wasn’t Karl Marx or someone????

Rik
Rik
1 year ago

I live in California under the Dictatorship of Nancy Pelosi’s nephew, Governor Gavin Newsom. At 75, I still have to work. I do petitioning in front of mainly grocery stores and have noticed that probably 90% of people that sign petitions are Republicans. Now that more Republicans are moving out of here I’ve noticed a drop in the number of signers. I really believe that 90% 0f ALL Democrats are stupid and have been believing all the lies they hear from the majority of media outlets. What befuddles me is that they NEVER LEARN!!!
They STILL vote and support these lying Liberals! . . . I guess it’s just “stupid is, stupid does”!

teresa Ann d'alessandro
teresa Ann d'alessandro
1 year ago

so then tax biden and alllll the nutz who voted for a demobrat – they brought more cartel into this c ountry

Neal
Neal
1 year ago

They are utterly delusional, because they will simply drive the millionaires and billionaires out of ALL blue states with such ridiculously burdensome tax schemes and into red states that have far more reasonable tax rates or even no state income tax.

Carol
Carol
1 year ago

These leftist governors really believe they own those who live in their states? We have freedom in this country to live where ever we want! We can move anywhere too! Remember what happened to the America in Atlas Shrugged when the leftist passed a wealth tax in that book? The country stopped producing and moving forward and the more the leftist become tyrannical, the more the people just stopped!!! How long will the voters of these leftist clowns take before their eyes are open to the evil of all these leftist policies?

Ann S
Ann S
1 year ago

The woke will never wake up. Because they like that the government thinks for them. All this is to have control over not only the people but the very rich as well. It won’t work. Not in America land of opportunity and home of the Free and the Brave.

Kyle Buy you some guns,and learn how to shoot
Kyle Buy you some guns,and learn how to shoot
1 year ago

And the politicans w onder why rich people send money overseas. Kyle L.

Kyle Buy you some guns,and learn how to shoot
Kyle Buy you some guns,and learn how to shoot
1 year ago

Billionars and Millionars run out of states ,then move out of the countryu. Money goes with them.

Mary Whitley
Mary Whitley
1 year ago

Just truly sad. They need to leave those state and go to red or purple states.

James P.
James P.
1 year ago

If everyone knew the TRUTH about liberal Democrats, there wouldn’t be any!

NewDay
NewDay
1 year ago

These Democrat state are run by poeple who have no clue about how things work in the real world. If they could take every cent from everyone in their state they still would not have enough to satisfy them.

Bob Chase
Bob Chase
1 year ago

Collusion over taxes. Seems that should be illegal. Seems many issues from the LEFT should be illegal!

Giordano Bruno
Giordano Bruno
1 year ago

At some point, does the 13th Amendment to the US Constitution come into play? That would be the one that says slavery & involuntary servitude is Constitutionally illegal in the USA!!!

John Konvalin
John Konvalin
1 year ago

Don’t these politicians ever read history which is full of examples of increasing revenue by lowering taxes. A flat tax is the most logical solution. But then, we elect the most incompetent leadership.

johnh
johnh
1 year ago

Trump campaigned last weekend & said that he reduced National Debt while in office, but the records show debt increased more than $7 Trillion during his term. And which one is real & which one is fake news? And Biden has said he reduced debt in first year by $250 Billion & what is real news on that?

An older blonde women laughing in the kitchen with a grey haired man.
AMAC’s Medicare Advisory Service
The knowledge, guidance, and choices of coverage you’re looking for. The exceptional service you deserve.
The AMAC App on 3 different iPhone
Download the AMAC App
The AMAC App is the place to go for insightful news wherever you are and whenever you want.
Joe Biden speaking with attendees
NEW YORK - OCT 10:American homeless sleeps in New York city subway on October 10 2009.A 2013 report show that the number of homeless people recorded in NYC topped 50,000 for the first time.
Former President of the United States Donald Trump speaking with attendees at the 2023 Turning Point Action Conference at the Palm Beach County Convention Center in West Palm Beach, Florida.
gen z and boomers; election - pick your side poster

Stay informed! Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

33
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Subscribe to AMAC Daily News and Games