Newsline

Newsline , Society

Turkey’s Earthquake – America’s Response

Posted on Monday, February 13, 2023
|
by AMAC, Robert B. Charles
|
23 Comments
|
Print
Turkey

The Earthquakes in Turkey (7.8) and Syria (7.5) are the worst in nearly a century, affecting tens of millions, killings tens of thousands – but a second shoe may fall. Geopolitical reverberations may be significant. Americans need to watch the situation closely, and act with foresight.

What happens next could improve – or undermine – Turkey’s position in NATO, NATO’s position with respect to Ukraine and Russia, push Turkey closer to China, affect Turkey’s economy (80 percent inflation), sideline the nation as a potential peace broker, possibly tighten ties to key Mideast nations.

First, Turkish presidential elections, set for May 14, are going to look different. While a viable opponent to strongman Tayyip President Erdogan is not obvious, Erdogan’s economic mismanagement is. It will get worse with the earthquake.

Already performing a high wire act, engineering a temporary solution to 80 percent inflation and collapse of the country’s currency, down 30 percent this year against the dollar, his act just got harder.

Erdogan is a controversial, autocratic, pro-Muslim President of a nation historically secular, reliable, and collegial. Over the past 20 years, 2003 to 2014 as Prime Minister then 2014 to 2023 as President, he forcibly remade every institution in the country, persecuted the press, gutted the judiciary to military.

Methodically consolidating power, he has silenced, arrested, and marginalized critics, has an eclectic style, was arguably the least cooperative NATO member. He has advanced his own aims, often frustrating US and European allies on issues from refugees and energy to Syria, Russia, and the Kurds.

Now, he has a major challenge to address – and many are beginning to ask whether the death toll had to be as high as it is, whether some 6000 collapsed buildings needed to collapse, whether the government was ready. All this will be part of his case to make – or defend – in May, assuming elections go forward.

Second, the US – and dozens of other countries – are sending major aid to Turkey, including US search teams, pre-loaded packages from USAID totaling $85 million dollars. China sent one team and $6 million dollars. Perhaps surprisingly, nations like Saudi Arabia have sent multiple planes of aid to Turkey, and continue doing so.

All this adds to a potential shift in relations with the rest of the world. On one hand, the US could – with other European allies – solidify relations with Turkey, causing Turkey to drop opposition to admission of Finland and Sweden to NATO, reducing Erdogan’s tendency to migrate away from team play.

On the other hand, if China ramps up aid to Turkey, this could outflank Western efforts, creating incentives for closer relations between China and Turkey, tipping the balance against closer NATO cooperation, and perhaps even tipping Turkey’s role as a potential peace negotiator between China’s ally Russia and Western ally Ukraine.

As an aside, Middle Eastern countries that crossed swords with Turkey in the past– like Saudi – may be able to craft new and more mutually supportive relations with Erdogan and Turkey, realigning players and allegiances – both before and after the May elections.

Third, below the radar – in the Turkish population itself – how this earthquake affects, and how recovery affects, the way people feel about their government may be affected. At the least, major population centers within Turkey containing millions of citizens have been adversely affected.

This devastation will affect the poverty level, economic wellbeing, public health and safety, perhaps even encouraging regional criminal elements, such as drug traffickers who transit Turkey. Also affected may be ambitions of regional terrorist groups in Syria and points south.

All this suggests several obvious action items. US national security is enhanced by securing a NATO partner, aiding and potentially supporting Turkey’s swift recovery – to strengthen NATO collectively. Direct dialogue with Erdogan would help architect a future that includes admission of Sweden and Finland, a stronger position in addressing Russia’s belligerence, elevating Turkish support for Ukraine.

On the China front, how the US responds to this crisis – versus China – may influence how Turkey perceives the future, economically and militarily, but also how other non-allied countries see the US and China.

Net-net, we live in highly fluid times, defined by a need to solidify alliances, stand for values we have always stood for, reassure longstanding friends, deter overeager adversaries, and in particular blunt – wherever possible – efforts by China to reset global relationships.

Turkey is at a crossroads, which are complex, involving a headstrong leader who has been insufficiently cooperative, a presidential election that may unseat him, a national tragedy affecting millions, and a chance for the US and Western allies to showcase what we do when others are in peril. 

Americans help – and always have in response to global earthquakes, back to 1812 – for humanitarian reasons, but we should also keep one eye on the future and American interests. The Turkish earthquake may have far wider reverberations.

Robert Charles is a former Assistant Secretary of State under Colin Powell, former Reagan and Bush 41 White House staffer, attorney, and naval intelligence officer (USNR). He wrote “Narcotics and Terrorism” (2003), “Eagles and Evergreens” (2018), and is National Spokesman for AMAC.

We hope you've enjoyed this article. While you're here, we have a small favor to ask...

The AMAC Action Logo

Support AMAC Action. Our 501 (C)(4) advances initiatives on Capitol Hill, in the state legislatures, and at the local level to protect American values, free speech, the exercise of religion, equality of opportunity, sanctity of life, and the rule of law.

Donate Now
Share this article:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
23 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
PaulE
PaulE
1 year ago

When Erdogan was a Mayor, he leveraged the devastation from another major earthquake to begin his meteoric rise up to his current position. He took Turkey from a secular nation, that made sense to be part of NATO and the western community and transformed it into what is largely an Islamic centered nation. One where Turkey is more of a hindrance, than a help on several occasions. Erdogan’s openly stated intent is recreating the Islamic Ottoman Empire, with him as its supreme leader for life. It would be fitting that another earthquake and his dismal performance to date served as his downfall.

Yes of course the United States and the West should aid the people of Turkey, as we do for any nation after a major natural disaster. That’s who we are as a people, despite what the domestic anarchists otherwise known as the Democrat Party have to say. However, we should NOT do so in such a manner that would allow Erdogan to politically benefit from that aid. We must ensure any aid provided gets to the people and doesn’t simply end up lining Erdogan’s pockets. Turkey’s future would best be served if Erdogan was ultimately relegated to the dust bin of history and the country was allowed to return to the type of government Turkey had before Erdogan.

Michael J
Michael J
1 year ago

Humanitarian assistance should be rendered as ordinary people really are the ones that suffer, either in natural disasters or domestic ones.

Kyle Buy you some guns,and learn how to shoot
Kyle Buy you some guns,and learn how to shoot
1 year ago

Otherwords the guy is a dictator. Kyle L.

Kay
Kay
1 year ago

Every county regardless of political favor should be helping Turkey and Syria. These are innocent people who are dying, starving and have lost everything.

Granny
Granny
1 year ago

I hope we haven’t come to the point that assistance is only based on what political edge it can give the giving country. This is a horrendous disaster and should be treated as so. The survivors need help now, more than the poor victims. This is all prophesized sadly.

Gene
Gene
1 year ago

Do the math $85 million vs $6 million from China only one team from China as well? Saudi’s sending many transport planes! Are the innocent people really being helped and who helps the United States when we have earthquakes or natural disasters? Just saying!!

Joanne 4 justice
Joanne 4 justice
1 year ago

Very informative ???? article!
God Bless and help Turkey!!!!

David Millikan
David Millikan
1 year ago

Excellent article.
Won’t be long from now that the USA Inflation will be at 80% like Turkey. Then who will help US?
Answer: NOBODY.

David Capps
David Capps
1 year ago

We should not help these Islamists at all,they wouldn’t help us,it’s just some Karma for this land of evil.

MJB
MJB
1 year ago

Syria is a terrorist state that is behind many bombings of US installations that have killed many Americans! Assad is behind most if not all of these terrorist acts against the free world! I wouldn’t give a single dime to any terrorist sponsoring country that has killed thousands of Americans and our allies. Let dead dogs lay where they fall. As for Turkey, they’re almost in the same boat as Syria!

Were it not for the billions of dollars we Americans pour into Turkey each year, they would be equal to Syria in their hatred of the United States!

Terri Matson
Terri Matson
1 year ago

Why exactly is this our problem? A lot of US Seniors are having problems with food, mortgages and utilities as prices go up and up. We owe these other countries nothing. Would Turkey come to our aid if we had a giant earthquake? Nope. We do not need to be the world’s piggy bank and emergency fund. Our country is in a mess. Maybe we need our precious tax dollars to be used to repair THIS country first.

Phoenix
Phoenix
1 year ago

They chose Russia, ask them for money.

An older blonde women laughing in the kitchen with a grey haired man.
AMAC’s Medicare Advisory Service
The knowledge, guidance, and choices of coverage you’re looking for. The exceptional service you deserve.
The AMAC App on 3 different iPhone
Download the AMAC App
The AMAC App is the place to go for insightful news wherever you are and whenever you want.
Former President Donald J Trump spoke at The People's Convention hosted by Turning Point USA and Sponsored by AMAC
AMAC CEO Rebecca Weber addressing AMAC Members & Delegates during her speech at the AMAC Action Delegate Summit 2024
Donald Trump, President of United States of America, during press conference at NATO SUMMIT 2018. 12.07.2018. BRUSSELS, BELGIUM. Press conference of Donald Trump, President of United States of America, during NATO North Atlantic Treaty Organization SUMMIT 2018.
Public schools block lettering on the side of a yellow school bus

Stay informed! Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

23
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Subscribe to AMAC Daily News and Games