Newsline

Newsline , Society

Transgenderism – New Questions

Posted on Friday, June 14, 2024
|
by AMAC, Robert B. Charles
|
33 Comments
|
Print

First, an overview: Compassion is the right answer for anyone facing a psychological challenge, fear, anxiety, depression, and what medical literature calls “gender dysphoria,” or believing one is female when genetically male and vice versa. But something new is afoot, and it’s worth commenting on.

A recent medical survey, conducted in this age of “transgenderism,” where the use of hormones and (rarely) surgery is expected to alter one’s sex, found something odd. More than three times as many men are choosing to reject their genetics for hormones, as the other way around.

Specifically, one in every 30,000 genetic males claims to be female, while one in every 100,000 genetic females claims to be male. Rendering no judgment on the survey, and putting aside arguments we know based on morality, fairness, science, and what this has done to girls’ sports, identities, privacy, dignity, and safety… why are the numbers so disproportionate?

Wider research produced no data to answer that question, but data may not be needed. In an upside-down world, where cultural, social, biological, moral, and well-established human norms are thrown aside, and replaced with deconstructionism, atheism, and anti-everything-ism, these disproportionate – although small – numbers of “transwomen” over “transmen” stand out. Why?

The answer, intuitively, is that men decide to invade women’s bathrooms, locker rooms, sports, scholarships, and protections meant for genetic girls in Title IX – taken from girls by Biden – to claim the benefits that were intended for genetic females. Classless, illegal until Biden, but true.

In other words, while possessing XXY or XYY karyotypes (male chromosomes), not X or XXX karyotypes (female), genetic men claim the right to compete against genetic women. Since males have stronger bone structure, musculature, and irreversible attributes of advantage in sport, males “identifying” as females get a competitive advantage over genetically female competitors.

Putting aside cultural, social, biological, moral, and other questions, the core fact is that incentives exist for a male with no hesitation about his physical advantages over genetic women to switch genders, pump hormones, and win in sports. The reverse, of course, does not happen.

Put differently, if ethics and personal code bet a backseat to “identifying” as a different gender and winning, we should expect more males to claim womanhood than the other way around. And that is what we see – oh and this, yes, they win more.

Is this it? Maybe, the numbers are small, but the impact on girls and disadvantage in sports is huge, knocking girls’ confidence and knocking them off the podium, and out of scholarships.

That situation, of course, was presented by Riley Gaines – knocked off the podium at the NCAA championships by a 6’4” male who swam three years as a male, then switched to swim his senior year against genetic girls – and took home trophies genetic girls would have won.

All this is upsetting, but is there more? Again, maybe. A loose survey of organizations pushing transgenderism to the detriment of genetic girls shows left-leaning women in leadership. Unclear is whether they are genetic females or “transwomen” (men “identifying” as women), of course.

Corroborating the idea that “transgenderism” is being pushed for political reasons are real surveys. Most Americans (65 percent, and 86 percent of Christians) “believe there are only two genders, man and women.” Most (65 percent, 79 percent of Christians) are not “comfortable using gender-neutral pronouns.” So, the majority – thankfully – disavow woke culture.

Instead, politically left-leaning women seem the biggest “trans” pushers, eager to push hormones and irreversible surgery on genetic males, turning them – as they see it – female. Very few men, except those involved in this process, seem to be pushing transgenderism. What does that mean?

The answer is unclear. In a prior day, the phenomenon might be called “misandry,” or human experimentation, or some new feminism, but numbers tell us this much: Three times as many men end up in female locker rooms, bathrooms, showers, and prisons as the other way around; and many pushing this radical sexual agenda, at the cost of genetic girls, are leftist women.

Make what you will of that. One way or the other, the movement continues to disenfranchise genetic girls and women, giving men an advantage the law never intended. Compassion is the right answer … including compassion toward those historically defined as girls and women.

Robert Charles is a former Assistant Secretary of State under Colin Powell, former Reagan and Bush 41 White House staffer, attorney, and naval intelligence officer (USNR). He wrote “Narcotics and Terrorism” (2003), “Eagles and Evergreens” (2018), and is National Spokesman for AMAC.

We hope you've enjoyed this article. While you're here, we have a small favor to ask...

The AMAC Action Logo

Support AMAC Action. Our 501 (C)(4) advances initiatives on Capitol Hill, in the state legislatures, and at the local level to protect American values, free speech, the exercise of religion, equality of opportunity, sanctity of life, and the rule of law.

Donate Now
Share this article:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
33 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Felix
Felix
29 days ago

Question, are men who claim to be women physically castrated, and if not why aren’t they? It seems that girls and women are complaining about men who say they are women are upset because they shower and expose themselves in locker rooms with their male parts. I also wonder if they would still claim to be female, if it was a requirement to give up their biological parts? I could be wrong. And why is this not being presented as an issue in both MSM and conservative media?

Max
Max
29 days ago

RBC, it amazing how the very few are dictating the course of society. As stated in a previous article, these few are holding the mountain tops and are spreading their philosophy unto the many. Humanity has been given free will and has to use it wisely, so those who make bad choices will suffer the consequences in the end. This administration continues to be out of hand still following the agenda of the Obama administration which clearly stated that America would be fundamentally change. It is definitely time to get rid of this type of radicalism and get back to common sense

Have a great weekend and stay safe. Semper Fi.

R Anthony Botti
R Anthony Botti
29 days ago

you forgot about the other subclass of dudes pretending to be female: the perverts who do it to gain entry into women’s restrooms and locker rooms for the purpose of committing sex crimes against REAL women and girls

Frances
Frances
29 days ago

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has won a major victory against the Biden Administration’s Department of Education (“DOE”), stopping its attempt to rewrite Title IX to force Texas schools to adopt radical “transgender” policies in violation of state and federal law. 
The court order explains: “[The Biden Administration] failed to follow the proper procedures here. Rather than promote the equal opportunity, dignity, and respect that Title IX demands for both biological sexes, [the DOE’s] Guidance Documents do the opposite in an effort to advance an agenda wholly divorced from the text, structure, and contemporary context of Title IX.… Thus, to allow [the Biden Administration’s] unlawful action to stand would be to functionally rewrite Title IX in a way that shockingly transforms American education and usurps a major question from Congress. That is not how our democratic system functions.” 
texasattorneygeneral.gov/news/releases/attorney-general-ken-paxton-secures-major-win-blocking-biden-administrations-attempt-force

Fredrick
Fredrick
29 days ago

There are only two sexes !! It’s time to stop giving validity
to those who have delussions of gender. They need mental health
consuling.

Melinda
Melinda
29 days ago

Another factor in more men transitioning may be the lack of male role models in the home, i.e. unwed mothers. I’m not aware of any research making this connection.

lawrence greenberg
lawrence greenberg
29 days ago

Transgenderism is a mental illness. Instead of accommodating these people, they should be sent for help. Those who promote and advocate this insanity are just plain evil and should be treated accordingly.

George Ruben Rivera Jr
George Ruben Rivera Jr
29 days ago

I would like to see a study of the rise in Soy Baby Formulas and elevated Soymilk production with male feminization. The term “Soy Boy” did not rise out of a vaccum, and a link to transgenderism might be enlightening.

Linda Robertson
Linda Robertson
29 days ago

At the risk of just throwing gasoline on a bonfire. let me suggest this. There seems to a real anxst against a “Manly Man”. Look at the blowback that football kicker has gotten and still receives. We have force fed the female population that there is something threatening, offensive, harmful………. about a “Manly Man”. GOD created us different and for very good reasons. But the liberal left’s “wokism” has push this thing so hard that if you are a “Manly Man’ you are dangerous

Granny26
Granny26
29 days ago

I think the males that want to be female is because they are wussies and can’t handle manly things….and like a few comments below…only to get access to female restrooms, locker rooms, etc. Should be separate rooms for them.

Valerie Waddelove
Valerie Waddelove
29 days ago

I hadn’t thought about it this way, but I can see how transgenderism is more beneficial for men than women.. Only legitimate females should be playing girls’ and women’s sports. It’s so obvious and common sense to separate sex-at-birth division for men and women’s sports.

Walt
Walt
29 days ago

What is the percentage of the 1 in 30K that are “athletes?”

Agnes
Agnes
25 days ago

I have trouble believing I
1 in 30,000 men want to be female and 1in 100,00 females want to be male. I know 6 young women and 3 of them want to be male. I only know if one male who is transgender.
Is it where I live that is different!

Nick
Nick
26 days ago

None of you were okay with gay people, so we had to force you to be. We’ll do the same with this. Yes, as you’re so fond of saying, it will be crammed down your throat. If you can’t be a decent and tolerant human being, you’ll just have to settle for being outnumbered.

anna hubert
anna hubert
29 days ago

How is it going in the moslem countries and China? We don’t hear much about these issues there

Robert Zuccaro
Robert Zuccaro
29 days ago

Boomer opinion: I think they’re gay but don’t want to admit it so by claiming their “something else in something else’s body” they can internally argue they aren’t “gay” and claim pity points by being “afflicted with a condition” not of their doing. In any case, leave children alone, groomers!

Mike
Mike
29 days ago

I read an article in the late 60s or early 70s (around the time that Masters and Johnson were publishing) This article was about how moms hormones during fetal development could impact on “the child’s development towards individual sexuality”. Have not seen this subject come up at all in the past few years related to gender dysphoria.

Jeri
Jeri
29 days ago

If you are a beta male becoming a girl gives you access to everything an alpha male has. Am I wrong?

Secret Service agents rush Donald Trump off the stage.(AP: Evan Vucci)
President Joe Biden greets President of the People’s Republic of China Xi Jinping, Wednesday, November 15, 2023, at the Filoli Estate in Woodside, California.(Official White House Photo by Carlos Fyfe)
President Joe Biden speaks on the phone with Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick to discuss his approval of a FEMA disaster declaration in response to the impacts of Hurricane Beryl, Tuesday, July 9, 2024, in the Oval Office of the White House. (Official White House Photo by Adam Schultz)

Stay informed! Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

33
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Subscribe to AMAC Daily News and Games