Newsline

Newsline , Society

Newsom’s Deeply Cynical Reparations Power Grab

Posted on Thursday, May 18, 2023
|
by Daniel Berman
|
41 Comments
newsom

AMAC Exclusive – By Daniel Berman

California Governor Gavin Newsom, who spent much of 2022 organizing a shadow challenge against Joe Biden, has problems aplenty in his home state in 2023, many of which are self-inflicted. Yet rather than addressing them, he and California Democrats seem set to use the budget shortfall and a debate over reparations to crush remaining opposition to their rule over the state.

California faces a nearly $23 billion budget shortfall, which may make Newsom’s decision to fritter away a nearly $100 billion budget surplus over the preceding two years appear less than wise. The bill is now coming due for the largess which Newsom used in part to secure his victory in the 2021 recall election and his 2022 reelection.

Fiscal mismanagement is not the only bill for Newsom’s self-aggrandizement that is now coming due. In the heady days of the summer of 2020, the State of California commissioned a body to look into methods of paying reparations to African Americans. At the time, it was a free gesture to the omnipresent social justice zeitgeist. Politicians are always happy to virtue signal when it costs them nothing, but are remarkably skimpy when taking any action that carries a cost.

“CA just became the first state in the nation to mandate the study and development of proposals for reparations. Our past is one of slavery, racism, and injustice. Our systems were built to oppress people of color. It’s past time we acknowledge that.”

So Governor Newsom proudly proclaimed on his official Twitter account when he signed the bill into law on September 30, 2020. At the time, BLM had swept elite opinion not just within the Democrat Party, but much of America’s corporate and social elite as well. Senator Mitt Romney marched with BLM activists in Washington, D.C. that summer.

For Newsom, it looked like a solid bet. If Biden lost, he would have taken a clear step to win the loyalty of the Democrat base. Even if Biden won in 2020, there was at the time a widespread assumption even among Democrats that he would be a one-term president, thus leaving the door open for a Newsom presidential run in 2024.

But nothing testifies to the ruthless cynicism of Gavin Newsom’s political career more than his willingness to embrace the most extreme causes with nary a second thought when they appear advantageous, and then to dispense with them when the political winds, or his own needs shift.

Since 2020, the popular appeal of Black Lives Matter has faded, along with California’s budget surplus. Joe Biden not only won the election, but is seeking reelection, despite Newsom’s flirtation with a shadow campaign. While Newsom survived a recall in 2021, and then won reelection in 2022, the experiences seem to have attracted his attention to a potential backlash closer to home. His margin in 2022, at 58 percent to 42 percent, was the smallest for any Democrat candidate in 12 years.

There were other signs that Californians were becoming fed up with progressive politics as well. In San Francisco, three members of the school committee were recalled for, among other things, seeking to rename schools named after Abraham Lincoln. San Francisco voters also recalled Chesa Boudin, their far-left District Attorney who placed “social justice” above public safety.

Newsom is unlikely to face a Democrat primary before 2028, if ever. But if he is not careful, he might have to face angry California voters even sooner.

This goes a long way to explaining his shift in tone when it comes to the reparations proposals. Dealing with the legacy of discrimination “is about much more than cash payments,” the Governor told reporters this week, when asked about the Task Force’s proposal to reward black residents of California payments of up $1.2 million each if they could prove to have suffered under specific areas of discrimination, or that their ancestors had done so.

In fairness to the Task Force, nominally at least the payments are not purely racial, but rather based on proving that oneself or one’s ancestors suffered discrimination on the basis of black identity. In theory this would exclude recent immigrants, but in practice, the extensive and near all-encompassing definitions of both eligibility and discrimination seem more like a (probably futile) sop to legal challenges under the 14th Amendment than actual attempts at nuance.

Areas of discrimination include “mass incarceration,” for which “the proposal suggests providing $115,260 per person in 2020 dollars — or $2,352 for each year of residency in the state since 1971, which was the first year of the war on drugs,” and healthcare disparities, “including environmental pollution and discrimination by health care workers — the task force recommended $13,619 per person for every year lived in California.” It went even further. “For those who faced discriminatory housing policies between 1933 and 1977, when redlining mostly occurred, the proposal suggested $148,099 per person, or $3,366 for each year.

These are astounding numbers, and they produce astounding totals, with estimates of the total cost ranging as high as $800 billion, almost four times California’s annual budget of $237 billion. Without a doubt this will not be paid, and Newsom’s remarks are a reflection of that reality. But there is a cynical threat in them to California residents as well, when he suggested that “it is about more than cash payments.”

Newsom seems to have grasped that in the debate about reparations there is a chance to kill several birds with one stone. By rejecting impossible demands for cash payments, he can acquire a fake moderate veneer. Then, he can use the Task Force’s identification of areas of historical discrimination to seize control of areas of the economy in California such as housing, healthcare, and law enforcement.

Newsom and California Democrats have long chafed at their power over all three. Fortified by Proposition 13, which freezes residential property taxes at the time of purchase, homeowners have resisted Democrat efforts to raise taxes or break up residential communities for favored developers. Democrats have long claimed Proposition 13 is “racist,” but by using the guise of reparations for housing discriminations, California Democrats can move to outlaw single-family zoning.

At the same time, local control of health provision and law enforcement frustrates Democrats. California became famous for how long it kept its schools closed during COVID-19, but that was more a reflection of the power of the teachers’ unions than a policy preference by Sacramento. Newsom and the legislature would have liked to crack down on the public during COVID much more heavily than they did, but were prevented by the decentralized nature of California’s government.

Local sheriffs publicly refused to enforce many COVID-19 restrictions, to the fury of Newsom. They have also openly defied Newsom’s efforts at gun control, with the legislature recently passing a law to restrict police from privately purchasing firearms. If Newsom can use the pretext of fighting discriminatory policy to shift control of law enforcement from local areas, where Republicans and moderate Democrats can win office, to Sacramento where they don’t stand a chance, it would allow him to eliminate opposition to his and the legislature’s social engineering agenda.

Control of education is another area where Californians should be concerned by Newsom’s ominous comment expanding the definition of reparations. In 1996 California Voters passed Proposition 209, which banned the use of race in admissions to the state university system. For Democrats, that act has become an original sin, the one legacy of Ronald Reagan’s California they have failed to erase despite decades of rule. In 2020, at the height of the George Floyd protests, they believed the time had come to erase it, and the legislature referred Proposition 16, which would have repealed Proposition 209, to the voters. It lost by a devastating 57 percent to 43 percent margin.

Democrats have raged at their defeat, and the counterattack against Woke DEI power in state schools in red states has only whetted their appetite to take full control of the California university system. If Newsom and Democrats can reclassify Affirmative Action not as racial preferences in admissions, but rather as a form of reparations in which a certain number of spots are set aside for victims of racism, they can use the expansive definition of discrimination provided by the task force to reverse the will of the voters.

All of these actions would do much to advance the power of California’s Democrat rulers, and remarkably little to help the supposed victims of discrimination, who if anything, would see worse housing, less safe streets, and a degrading higher education system.

But that might be why these measures would appeal to Sacramento even more than cash payments. At the end of the day, payments, even to favorable constituencies, are a diversion of money they do control in the state budget to money they do not. By contrast, a redefinition of “reparations” to involve allowing them to use the institutions of the state to their own ends, costs them almost nothing and provides profits.

That these policies will harm the African American middle and upper classes the most is beside the point. If those voters leave the state, along with the white middle class, it is an advantage. Democrats prefer a state inhabited by the very poor, who are dependent on their largesse, and the very rich, preferably tech corporations and firms which exist only on paper but pay extensive taxes. Actual workers are much more apt to complain about taxes, and homeowners about misgovernment.

This is something missing from analysis of the mass migration of taxpayers out of California. It is a feature, not a bug of the California model—at least to the people in charge. It serves to remove the very voters around whom opposition might coalesce. If stripping the few remaining red counties of their sheriffs, guns, schools, and housing values will make them pack up and move to Idaho, well, “good riddance” Newsom would say.

Both the embrace of reparations in 2020, and how Newsom has quietly transformed well-intentioned concerns about the ills of slavery into a power-grab for himself and his cronies, are illustrative of the nature of government in California and the attitudes of the current Democrat Party in blue states. Racial justice was not about fixing the problems, which is why Democrats lost interest in issues such as qualified immunity, civil forfeiture, or any of the issues brought up in Senator Tim Scott’s bill. For the left-wing ruling class, it’s all about the power.

California is unique not in its direction, but in how blatant its leaders are about what they are doing. That is the truly scary part of the entire reparations debate.

Daniel Berman is a frequent commentator and lecturer on foreign policy and political affairs, both nationally and internationally. He holds a Ph.D. in International Relations from the London School of Economics. He also writes as Daniel Roman.

We hope you've enjoyed this article. While you're here, we have a small favor to ask...

The AMAC Action Logo

Support AMAC Action. Our 501 (C)(4) advances initiatives on Capitol Hill, in the state legislatures, and at the local level to protect American values, free speech, the exercise of religion, equality of opportunity, sanctity of life, and the rule of law.

Donate Now
Share this article:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
41 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Lieutenant Beale
Lieutenant Beale
11 months ago

If this joker manages to run & “win” the WH in 2024, America is toast.

jocko
jocko
11 months ago

BEING WHITE, I WANT REPARATIONS TO FOR ALL OF THE JOBS I APPLIED FOR BUT THESE WERE GIVEN TO UNQULAIFIED BLAX DUE TO THE AFFIRMATIVE ACTION

Enuf Said
Enuf Said
11 months ago

Why haven’t NATIVEAMERICAN INDIANS sued the entire population of the USA for stealing their land from them?

Stephen Russell
Stephen Russell
11 months ago

See CA then see applied to the nation

Leesson1
Leesson1
11 months ago

Articles like this, while well presented, are , frankly, a waste of time to read as nothing in California, nor my current state (Illinois), will ever change. The large metropolises, filled with liberal Democrat voters, placated with never-ending free, free, free stuff, will keep the Democrat Party in control for decades. The GOP has no way of countering it..and wouldn’t if they could. Sad, sad, sad.

JML
JML
11 months ago

He is, TRULY, a DI*K!!!

Rik
Rik
11 months ago

I have resided in California since 1991. I believe we suffer from one of the worst economy’s in the country because our Comrade Governor greatly mismanages every phase of governmental influence in/over our lives. And since our current Jack*ss running our country is the worst President ever, and since the Communist wannabe Democrats have NO POSSIBLE WORTHY CANDIDATES, they FAULSELY BELIEVE THAT COMRADE GOVERNOR NEWSOM IS THEIR BEST CHOICE! Just compare the State of California’s economy to Republican run States, so GOOD LUCK with that!

P2burner
P2burner
11 months ago

…”Our past is one of slavery, racism, and injustice. Our systems were built to oppress people of color. It’s past time we acknowledge that.”

Keep throwing money at a it, buddy…bankrupt a perfectly good state and wonder why your citizens are leaving by the millions. What a conundrum.

anna hubert
anna hubert
11 months ago

Our past is of endurance perseverance hardship and overcoming it all It is that which built this country There were slaves in Africa before the white man They did not built much If African American wants to be repaid he must ask the country that originally sold him If Newsom wants to pay out of his own pocket I have no problem with that

Seriously?
Seriously?
11 months ago

I am a 4th generation immigrant from Hungary. My families – both sides – came here at the turn of the 20th century. Why should I have to pay reparations? Taxing me, or anyone in my family to pay reparations for something which we had no involvement is ludicrous. My family can’t be unique – after all Ellis Island was taking immigrants for many, many years. NONE of those families ever owned slaves – none of those families should be FORCED to pay reparations.

Rebecca
Rebecca
11 months ago

If payment is made for ancestors that were slaves I too want payment. I want payment for my ancestors that fought and died during the Civil War on the north’s side. If they died I want double. I don’t believe I can be denied this since they were fighting to stop slavery. Now Newsom believes he has the answers to everything. He’s been schooled at his aunt Nancy’s knee how to cheat and rob for his own gain. By keeping the masses down he can control perhaps seeking the title of king. But Newsom has forgotten the fighting spirit of Americans. We are a country which took on England and won. We have gone forth so many times and succeeded. Make people downtrodden and sit back and watch them rise and crush you. You have forgotten history sir, if you ever read it, and Californians will take you and your fellow idiots down. This I believe.

johnh
johnh
11 months ago

History is history & we need to learn the lessons from this. We cannot change the past & we also need to quit getting rid of history lessons because it might offend someone. The changes to pancake syrup is a good example of knee-jerk reaction that did very little good to anyone in America.

CoNMTX
CoNMTX
11 months ago

I recently met Newsom’s twin brother. What he was doing on the back of my shower curtain I’ll never know. My wife gave me some spray and he went away. If only the Fornicalia Newsom was that easy to get rid of.

Judith Carroll
Judith Carroll
11 months ago

Great picture. Wish that was a live bear on the flag!

Ed J
Ed J
11 months ago

Yep! Great exposé on the “reparations” nonsense being perpetrated by our libtard governor here in the Peoples Republic of ☭alifornia. Unfortunately, this article speaks of what is only the tip of the iceberg regarding our Comrade Governor Gruesome. He is truly the poster boy for being a “King Midas in Reverse” in that everything he touches turns instantly to sh*t!

Gabe Hanzeli
Gabe Hanzeli
11 months ago

ah ah you black democrats got used, abused and cut loose again.

When are you going to learn that is all you are tot he democrats. they will always do you this way.

Ralph S
Ralph S
11 months ago

Next, I expect the DumocRATS will expect reparations for the descendants of the members of the Union Army who sacrificed their lives to help free the slaves.

Rose Ann Stone
Rose Ann Stone
11 months ago

California had nothing to do with slavery. As usual, this is just a ruse of the dems.

Granny26
Granny26
11 months ago

No one today has been a slave and no one today has owned a slave that I know of. This reparation thing is a bunch of crap. I should ask for reparations for my family (Jews) being killed by the Nazi’s. It’s just as likely. And the POS Newscum should have to pay back the money he used for fighting his recall, etc. He is a freaking thief.

Myrna Wade
Myrna Wade
11 months ago

The impression I have is that Democrats are very aware that some of their bribes will not be legal or fiscally possible. Some of them propose forgiving student loans or paying reparations fully aware that what they offer will not happen. They will blame outdated laws or stinginess. They just want credit for a shiny offer. But they are ignoring real problems that need work.

RobinMD
RobinMD
11 months ago

If in 2024 the democrats take back the House, keep the Senate, and the White House, don’t be surprised if the dems don’t try to make this “reparations” thing nationwide. But instead of giving each black $$$, since they feel this country has mistreated them and/or their ancestors, offer to pay their way to a country of their choice, completely paid for by working, tax paying, Americans, and to include enough money to get by for about a year. Once the house (country) has been cleaned, it will be utopia.

GTPatriot
GTPatriot
11 months ago

The media never tells us the truth which is that California wants to go so far in debt that our stupid
fed govt ( meaning taxpayers all over the nation) bails them out. This is so obvious but no one says it. So workers in the other 49 states will have to take a second job to bail out Calif. So you either raise hell about this or take the second job. Your choice.

GTPatriot
GTPatriot
11 months ago

If a person murders someone does it mean that the murderer’s children and grandchildren must
pay “reparations” to the family and offspring of the victim ? Of course not. Remember, we do not
compensate victims in this country. If you walk into the wrong alley and get your eye punched out
that’s your problem. The US is notorious for never compensating victims other than the 911
families who each received $1 million . Not the $5 million the San Fran freaks want.

M.B.
M.B.
11 months ago

It will be interesting to see this clown fall on his own sword. There is no way this will happen. This is all vaudeville bullsh*t to divide this country further then it is. I don’t see African Americans moving to California to collect cash. They know this won’t happen . They’re not as stupid as Gruesome thinks they are. Whatever doesn’t make sense is what these so called politicians do. Another episode of Clowns in charge.

tika
tika
11 months ago

these are the nonsense issues of a want-to-be on the national stage despite being a high-profile total failure in everything to this point in time. he doesn’t meet the threshold requirements for further higher level consideration unless you immersed in today’s worlds’ issues in a “dear teddy bear” type relationship useful to voters on grammar school intellect.

Dov
Dov
11 months ago

Another dumbocratic attempt to buy the Black vote.

Randall L. Beatty
Randall L. Beatty
11 months ago

He will do anything to look good to the black vote I do not care what they do out there as long as I do not have to give my money to them I would burn money before I would give that guy one dime.If people out there have so much money then give it away who cares does not make a difference to me I do not care The state with filth in the streets people sleeping in tents what a great example for this country and to show the world the great USA.what it has become.

An older blonde women laughing in the kitchen with a grey haired man.
AMAC’s Medicare Advisory Service
The knowledge, guidance, and choices of coverage you’re looking for. The exceptional service you deserve.
The AMAC App on 3 different iPhone
Download the AMAC App
The AMAC App is the place to go for insightful news wherever you are and whenever you want.
Biden Admin’s War on Women
China
Donald Trump speaking with supporters at a campaign rally at the Prescott Valley Event Center in Prescott Valley, Arizona.

Stay informed! Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

41
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Subscribe to AMAC Daily News and Games