Newsline , Society

New Attack on Parents? Parens Patriae

Posted on Thursday, April 13, 2023
by AMAC, Robert B. Charles

No one is writing about this, but children – and the nation – are at risk of left-leaning courts and legislators making an unconstitutional end-run around parental control over our children with the so-called “Parens Patriae” doctrine – misusing it to assert state control over America’s children.

If you think this idea is absurd, ask yourself how much of what you see today was unimaginable a decade ago. We have teachers unions, rogue teachers, administrators, and politicians acting like self-appointed child-snatchers, as if they own our children, pushing hyper-sexualization of six-year-olds, transgenderism, hormone therapy, genital mutilation via surgery, often no parental knowledge.

We have legal and political challenges to parental control over America’s children, on the basis that parents resist “the state” – woke educators and politicians – indoctrinating their children politically, morally, sexually, and psychologically, directly challenging a parent’s right to raise their children.

You have – at the same time – a bizarre twist within the federal executive, parents investigated by the Justice Department, visited by the FBI, threatened with prosecution under the Patriot Act (an anti-terrorism statute) for speaking at school board meetings about public safety, aiming to protect their children from racism, sexualization, anti-Americanism, anti-religious, and transgender policies.

Now, a chorus is rising from top Democrats and in the media that implies traditional Christian, Jewish, Muslim, and Buddhist views about morality, sexuality, and childrearing are wrong, and should justify activist attacks – including violent attacks. The inference is that these views should be illegal.

If you think this is overstatement, note that neither the Biden White House nor congressional Democrats highlighted the likely motivation for the deadly March attack by a transgender student on a private Christian school that does not promote transgenderism.

Stunningly, the “mainstream” media reported that attack with material omissions, one network directing reporters and anchors not to “mention” the “transgender” nature of the attacker, another systematically omitting any reference to the “Christian” nature of the private school.

Not one mainstream network noted the obvious, a link between the violent transgender student, her former attendance at the same Christian school (which did not promote transgenderism), and her killing of innocent children and teachers – likely motivated by this divergence of views.

In sync with anti-Christian, anti-traditional, anti-parent sentiment, the Biden Justice Department has disproportionately arrested and is now prosecuting peaceful pro-life protestors, while they fail to arrest those destroying and defacing pro-life pregnancy centers and pro-life churches.

Moreover, we just learned they directed Federal Marshals not to arrest the violators of 18 USC 1507 for protesting at the homes of, trying to intimidate, and physically threatening conservative Supreme Court Justices and their children, after the Dobbs draft was illegally released, in time reversing Roe v. Wade.

Meantime, anti-parent rhetoric continues to grow from Democrat activists, including national teachers’ unions, advocates at the state and federal levels of policies resisted by concerned parents.

So, this warning about abuse of “Parens Patriae” – used rarely to allow state authority over parents for egregious offenses against children – is made against an unprecedented backdrop. The idea that parents, and especially conservative parents, may be overridden by state power is not absurd.

This doctrine is reserved for highly unusual cases, when the state interest in protecting a child obviously overrides prerogatives of an abusive parent. But even that is changing, as the left redefines what makes a parent deficient, increasingly suggesting state controls the child should trump the parent.

Two examples show the evolution. First, some states have begun misapplying the doctrine – arguing not that some egregious illegality should be found but that “best interests of the child” should decide matters. This is plainly, by longstanding common law and statute, dead wrong. The Supreme Court has said so.

The other example is another use of this doctrine. Federally, courts have begun saying the state’s ability to override traditional limits should be allowed, for example allowing lawsuits to be filed by blue states against the federal government, demanding EPA regulate private companies to stop “rising seas” from “swallowing” state lands.

Net-net, the left is pushing hard to control America’ s private life. One big area is parenting, where the attempt to control and brainwash children is in high gear. Another is private enterprise, demonizing gas-powered cars, stoves, and refrigerators and energy producers. 

The trend is toward disenfranchising individuals and companies, intimidating and encroaching on parental rights – as parents fight to protect their children from the political left. Do not be surprised if the anti-parent, anti-Christian, pro-control lobby – in and out of government – begins using “Parens Patriae” to justify what is legally and morally unjustifiable.

Let’s be honest, uncompromising in stating the truth: Parents and children arguably share life’s strongest bond. The government has no right to misuse any legal doctrine to undermine that bond. Period.

Robert Charles is a former Assistant Secretary of State under Colin Powell, former Reagan and Bush 41 White House staffer, attorney, and naval intelligence officer (USNR). He wrote “Narcotics and Terrorism” (2003), “Eagles and Evergreens” (2018), and is National Spokesman2 for AMAC.

We hope you've enjoyed this article. While you're here, we have a small favor to ask...

The AMAC Action Logo

Support AMAC Action. Our 501 (C)(4) advances initiatives on Capitol Hill, in the state legislatures, and at the local level to protect American values, free speech, the exercise of religion, equality of opportunity, sanctity of life, and the rule of law.

Donate Now
Share this article:
Notify of
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
5 months ago

this idea in the U.S. goes back publicly to the late ’70s. those of us alive then fought it off, but the numbers of low IQ people or “AI fake people” running around today are much greater.

5 months ago

I disagree. I’m sure the Obama children go to the best private schools in their area. If you remember, all government workers were exempted from having to use Obamacare as their insurer. Crud for thee but not for me. That’s their mantra!!

5 months ago

Dear Government and Federal Progressive Kooks…BUTT OUT of my life. Period.

Kyle Buy you some guns,and learn how to shoot
Kyle Buy you some guns,and learn how to shoot
5 months ago

Let the revolution start. Kyle L.

David Millikan
David Millikan
5 months ago

Help that way and all the other aliases you use shows what kind of a Coward you are. Your mentality shows that you have an I.Q. of a Fart in a Dust Storm.
Best part, one day you might get old but when you do. NOBODY is going to help you.
So why don’t you go ahead and die first so we can rid of STUPID idiots like you and save taxpayers money and medical supplies.

5 months ago

You first.

5 months ago

Honestly RBC, this is what is done in most authoritarian countries. In those countries, the populations have no way to push back against the ever-escalating control of the state. We still have the means, but apparently not the will to do much of anything. It’s very tough to motivate sheep to push back against a pack of wolves. Until that changes, the left will only be escalating their actions.

Blonde Women Wearing sunglasses on a man with a hats back having fun
Our Sponsors Make This News Possible
We encourage you to support the many companies that support AMAC.
The AMAC App on 3 different iPhone
Download the AMAC App
The AMAC App is the place to go for insightful news wherever you are and whenever you want.
Plane flying Illegal Aliens over the southern border as per Joe Biden
Mexico border wall showing illegal immigrants trying to pass through
Iranian flag in handcuffs on the background of the American flag.
Astronaut on surface of the Moon. Earth on background. Apollo space program. We Explore the Moon. Dark crater.

Stay informed! Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x

Subscribe to AMAC Daily News and Games