Newsline

Newsline , Society

House Votes To Stop D.C. Bill Endangering U.S. Citizen Voting Rights

Posted on Friday, February 10, 2023
|
by Outside Contributor
|
4 Comments
|
Print
Citizen

Last week, the U.S. House of Representatives voted 260-162 to pass H.J.Res.24 to halt a dangerous election proposal that threatens U.S. citizen voting rights. The dangerous proposal is D.C. Bill 24.300, which would dramatically redefine who can vote in the nation’s capital and cost $2 billion to implement. The majority of the House appropriately disapproved of these changes in order to protect American voting power from dilution, relieve burdens on taxpayers, and refocus D.C. on addressing its failures in election integrity.

Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez opposed the House resolution, making the hyperbolic claim that it is “expanding in the history of disenfranchisement that goes all the way back to the legacy of slavery.” She falsely claimed that the House resolution would be “denying that right to vote to an overwhelmingly Black city.” But her claim is wrong, and the facts about the bill actually demonstrate the opposite: the minorities who are U.S. citizens born and raised in D.C., including the descendants of slaves, will have their votes diluted if D.C.’s non-citizen voting bill becomes law. 

D.C. Bill 24.300 would lower the qualifications for voting to only a mere 1-month of residency. D.C. would discard current requirements of U.S. citizenship, current legal immigration status, or future legal authorization to reside in the U.S. These changes would apply starting in 2024 for multiple elections: D.C. mayor, city councilmember or chairman, attorney general, Advisory Neighborhood Commissioner, State Board of Education, as well as on initiatives, referendum, recalls, and changes to the D.C. charter.  

Changing the qualifications for who can vote has an impact on voters who already meet the qualifications. The D.C. council’s Racial Equity Impact Assessment listed the benefits of the bill as providing non-citizens a “sense of purpose,” “building networks,” and a way to formally “express” their views. But what about the impact of this election change on existing voters—the people that the D.C. City Council members are supposed to currently represent—and the assessment on how it impacts American voters? 

Reducing the qualification for voting from U.S. citizenship to a mere one-month residency means the voting power of U.S. citizens is diluted by a new electorate who all pledge allegiance to a different country, and broke U.S. immigration law to reside in D.C. We shouldn’t reward lawbreakers with a new power to change the law. D.C. estimates they would add to their voter rolls at least 21,000 who are illegally present in D.C.! Because those in the country illegally don’t have immigration papers, the assessment notes, “it is hard to know exactly how many people identify as non-citizen residents.” The Racial Equity Impact Assessment failed to assess the costs of illegal immigration. A Federation for American Immigration Reform report found that illegal immigration in 2017 cost D.C. a total of $282.4 million, by calculating the services and benefits used, including schools, law enforcement, health care, and public assistance. D.C. Bill 24.300 only will incentivize more illegal immigration.

In addition, temporary visitors to the U.S. would be able to vote under D.C. Bill 24.300. This includes people scheduled to leave after a certain date because their immigration status is temporary, as well as those anyone who just visits the nation’s capital for a month. That minimal qualification to vote can be manipulated by those who are diametrically opposed to the American way of life, because they will have an easy way to influence U.S. elections and pick leaders who share allegiances to foreign powers over the U.S. And those who plan to leave the United States will be granted power over the lives of Americans for years after they leave. Our government has its legitimacy because of the consent of the governed shown at the ballot box. But do visitors like a member of the foreign press or a tourist really share the same interest in a place they visited for a month, as those who were born, raised, and lived in the District of Columbia all their life? Many people come to the nation’s capital from across the globe and are welcomed as visitors, but it does not mean they also should be voters.

Besides the cost to representative government, the financial burden of the bill is money D.C. doesn’t have. The D.C. Fiscal Impact Statement reported costs over $3 million, and the current D.C. budget “[f]unds are not sufficient.” To implement D.C. Bill 24.300, D.C. needs to change voter registration applications, voter registration cards, voter rolls, and ballot machine systems. Notably, D.C.’s plan also includes an optional expenditure of $721,000 for outreach to non-citizen voters to encourage them to vote. So if D.C. can’t afford to pay for this bill from their own D.C. coffers, who foots the bill? It’s likely D.C. will again demand a bailout from the rest of the taxpayers around the country. D.C. Mayor Bowser requested a $10 million bailout from the federal government after an uptick in illegal immigration to D.C. just last year.

What really needs to change in D.C. is not the definition of voter; it’s how the elections system treats its current voters. D.C. should focus on fixing its current election system rather than experimenting with new changes. D.C. already has a history of incompetence in running elections, and as recent elections show, its track record is getting worse. In 2016, the D.C. Auditor reported that the D.C. Elections Board failed to follow federal and local laws requiring voter registry updates, leaving rampant inaccuracies, including dead people and voters with birthdates in the 1800s, on the voter rolls. Unfortunately, this mismanagement has only continued. Last year, the interstate voter rolls sharing database group ERIC (Election Registration Information Center) after issuing multiple notices and probation letters, warned D.C. that inaccuracies could kick them out of ERIC entirely. Because of its poor voter roll management, D.C. has a much higher rate of undeliverable mail than the 1.4% national average. D.C.’s undeliverablerate was 11% in 2020 and increased to 17% in 2022. And even when the election officials had a deliverable voter address, they sent the wrong ballots. In 2022, officials sent 574 voters ballots for the wrong neighborhood advisory commission within D.C. A new election system and all the changes will only compound the existing systemic problems. 

DC Bill 24.300 is backwards; instead of diluting citizen voting power, we should retain the privilege of voting for those who chose to go through the naturalization process to obtain the great privilege of being an American along with those who are born and bred Americans who treasure their voting rights. H.J.Res.24 will retain U.S. citizen voting power, stop irresponsible use of taxpayer funds, and focus election planning on restoring confidence in elections that has been lost in D.C. A vote for H.J.Res.24 is good for American voting rights of all races in D.C. and improves voter confidence across the country.

Share this article:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
4 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
David Millikan
David Millikan
1 year ago

Congress must pass a Bill that you MUST be a Citizen of the United States and have a Legal I.D. to Vote in ANY and ALL elections in the United States and Territories.
That is the ONLY way to ensure election integrity and eliminate Election Fraud by democrats for Legal and Fair Elections.
Also to PROSECUTE those who commit Election Fraud for TREASON. NO EXCUSES or protection from FAKE news.
Remember, politicians are NOT ABOVE THE LAW as DICTATOR Beijing biden thinks he and only his party are. They are NOT since They Are the MOST GUILTY in Election Fraud.
Just look who is in the White House
Illegally and Unconstitutionally because of Election Fraud. He sure as hell DIDN’T get over 80 million votes since we ALL know the math does NOT add up.
Especially, since he Hide and didn’t even have more than a dozen people at his rallies and vast majority were from FAKE news as attending.
That speaks volumes alone.

ELIZABETH A MURPHY
ELIZABETH A MURPHY
1 year ago

I am glad to see the House stand up to this. The congress must pass a bill that makes voting legal ONLY to US citizens over 18, who have a photo ID. I also believe that election day must be a national holiday. We must do away with voting for months at a time. This only allows more opportunity for fraud. Mail voting should be only for those in the military, or those not capable of getting to the ballot box due to impairment, or those who are out of state for death or illness. Unfortunately, there will always be fraud. We need to make it as difficult as possible.

jim nicholson and kamala harris with bible and rosary behind them about her anti-catholic acts
ActBlue logo
United States Treasury check and American flag. Concept of stimulus, economic recovery payment, tax refund. Federal government grant, loan, benefit and assistance
poland and germany flags on map with euros

Stay informed! Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

4
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Subscribe to AMAC Daily News and Games