Newsline

Newsline , Society

Biden Has No Israel Policy

Posted on Tuesday, April 2, 2024
|
by Outside Contributor
|
25 Comments
biden israel policy; sitting in front of american and israeli flags

On March 25, the United States abstained from a United Nations Security Council vote calling for an immediate and unconditional ceasefire between Israel and Hamas. (The resolution separately called on Hamas to release its captives.) It was the first time since the war began six months ago that America has failed to protect Israel from efforts at delegitimization through multilateral institutions such as the United Nations. The United States could have vetoed the resolution, as it has done in the past. It chose not to. The shameful decision emboldened Hamas terrorists and undermined our alliance with the Jewish state.

Just don’t call it a change in policy. If you do, President Biden and his foreign policy team will become upset. “Our vote does not—I repeat—does not represent a shift in our policy,” White House national security spokesman John Kirby told reporters. Asked about Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s calling off a delegation to Washington in response to the abstention, Kirby said, “The prime minister’s office seems to be indicating through public statements that we somehow changed here. We haven’t.”

Thus, according to the Biden administration, the withdrawal of support at the United Nations is not a departure. Nor is Senator Chuck Schumer’s (D., N.Y.) recent speech calling for new elections and a new government in Israel and describing Hamas and Netanyahu, as well as Mahmoud Abbas of the Palestinian Authority and “radical right-wing Israelis,” as equivalent “obstacles to peace.”

Vice President Kamala Harris’s warning over the weekend that “any major military operation” in Hamas’s last redoubt, Rafah, “would be a huge mistake”? That must not be different from earlier administration policy, either. After all, “I have studied the maps.” It’s one smooth continuum, we are supposed to believe, from Biden’s visit to Israel and embrace of Netanyahu on October 18 to Biden’s current oppositional posture toward Israel’s tactics, strategy, and elected leader.

Well, then. The absurdity of the Biden position is not surprising. These are the same people who said that inflation would be temporary, that unauthorized crossings on the southern border were seasonal, that America would prevent al Qaeda and ISIS from recouping in Afghanistan, that the threat of sanctions would deter Vladimir Putin from invading Ukraine, and that the president’s age and memory aren’t concerns because he is really mean to staff and swears a lot. Of course they would pretend that their turn against Israel, their lurch toward a ceasefire that would allow Hamas remnants to survive, was something else entirely. Gaslighting is not just a hobby for team Biden. It’s a lifestyle.

On one level, though, I sort of sympathize with John Kirby. To change a policy, you must have a policy. And it is increasingly clear that the Biden administration has no coherent Israel policy, nor a coherent policy for the Greater Middle East. What the Biden administration has instead is a wish list. The items on this list sound nice to liberal ears: Defeat Hamas, free the hostages, capsize Netanyahu’s coalition, end the war, jump-start the peace process. But the items are also numerous. They conflict with one another. They aren’t prioritized in any way.

A policy implies a strategy, an alignment of ends with means. Yet Biden’s end—the resolution of an irreconcilable conflict—is utopian. And his means—a Palestinian state—is worse than farfetched. A Palestinian state, if established under current conditions, would be a dictatorship that threatens the lives of everyone in its vicinity. A Palestinian state would not be a gain, but an error of galactic proportions.

To believe that a ceasefire would lead to a nonviolent Palestinian state and Israeli-Saudi normalization is to succumb to delusion. A ceasefire would leave Hamas’s remaining brigades intact, emboldening its leadership and its followers in the West Bank, Lebanon, and elsewhere. A ceasefire would tempt Hezbollah to escalate its simmering conflict with Israel. A ceasefire would strengthen Iran and its proxies, including the Houthis. There is one way to restore security, reduce tensions, and promote regional integration: Allow Israel to prove its strength by ending Hamas as a coherent military force.

That answer might not satisfy the columnists who visit Biden in the Oval Office, flattering him with tall tales of historic achievements if only he bullies Israel into letting Hamas escape. It is no doubt easier to believe, as Biden and his national security adviser Jake Sullivan do, that there are no tradeoffs and that the dangers of radical Islamist movements can be wished away by reciting the mantra of a “foreign policy for the middle class.”

And yet, by privileging domestic politics over serious policy, Biden has found himself, Commander-like, chasing his own tail. Biden says he supports Israel, while desperately trying to appease the anti-Israel vote in Michigan. He promises severe consequences for Iran, its militias, and the Houthis, while granting Iran a $10 billion sanctions waiver and looking elsewhere as soon as proxy violence tapers off. He voices his frustration with Netanyahu, while saying nothing as Hamas leaders visit with the Ayatollah Khamenei in Tehran.

“In balancing U.S. interests and priorities,” writes my AEI colleague Danielle Pletka, “the White House and its allies in Europe will face two options: engage in a region ever more dominated by Iran and its proxies, or cede Iranian dominance, replete with a lethal nuclear weapons program. The choice should be obvious.” If only it were obvious to Biden and the anti-Bibi Democrats, whose dislike of Israel’s elected leader is blinding them to geopolitical reality. Absent a directed, sustained, and articulated policy of no daylight between the United States and Israel, the rift between America and her ally will widen and the world will grow more dangerous. Such is life with President Biden, amid a darkening international scene that, alas, has not changed one bit.

Matthew Continetti is the director of domestic policy studies and the inaugural Patrick and Charlene Neal Chair in American Prosperity at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), where his work is focused on American political thought and history, with a particular focus on the development of the Republican Party and the American conservative movement in the 20th century.

Reprinted with permission from AEI by Matthew Continetti

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of AMAC or AMAC Action.

Share this article:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
25 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Max
Max
22 days ago

WHAT!!!! Someone does not believe that this Biden administration has any kind of foreign policy???? The Foreign policy for this administration is whatever it is told and directed to do by the strings that are in control. Every decision made by this corrupt leadership is meant to destroy this nation.

Joanne 4 justiice
Joanne 4 justiice
21 days ago

Does Biden even KNOW THE DEFINITION OF A POLICY????

Patriot Bill
Patriot Bill
20 days ago

Biden regime uses taxpayer money to fund Hamas terrorists. So they have an agenda, they want to destroy Israel along with our Constitution.

Bacon Nivison
Bacon Nivison
21 days ago

Leftists fighting against the Jews is nothing new and amplifies the mystery it is that so many Jewish Americans vote for demonicrats. What does Iran need, that it wouldn’t have if not for Peddo-Joe? Billions of dollars!!

mark maple
mark maple
21 days ago

Im with the majority of clear thinking folks; Im sick and tired of the crap, gaslighting, fraud, treason, all in the name of Their new and better Democratic Republic.

anna hubert
anna hubert
20 days ago

United Nations Security council would be a laugh had it not been so evil The whole organization exists for criminal purpose only

Anonymous
Anonymous
20 days ago

Obama crew are pro Iran. They would never do anything that helps Israel.

harry
harry
20 days ago

I sure pray that prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu would never listen, or care what biden says. Who does biden think he is, king of the world?

Robert Zuccaro
Robert Zuccaro
20 days ago

This administration mentions American histages held by Hamas as many times as They mention the 13 dead servicemen killed the last days in Afghanistan… ZERO! But ask them about “Gazans suffering”… they’ll never shut up! They have no problem criticising Israel but I don’t remember anyone criticising America for “Taliban” or “Iraqi” suffering.

John Shipway
John Shipway
21 days ago

One should never sympathize with “Admiral” John Kirby. The creature is a pathological liar and a traitor to our nation and needs a one on one meeting with a rope,

Rik
Rik
21 days ago

Jackass Joe is Nothing More than a Presidential Imposter!

Sean Rickman
Sean Rickman
20 days ago

The only policies that”tik-tok joey”has are screw AMERICAN citizens,let criminals out of jails to roam and kill,kiss the aliens behinds and ship dollars out of our country”faster than a citizen can escape illinois”

Stephen Russell
Stephen Russell
20 days ago

Never had 1 day 1

At a place where truth rules
At a place where truth rules
19 days ago

WHO???? Is the voice behind this empty shell? We need to call the truth to the right people. Don’t ya think?

Robert
Robert
19 days ago

Iran took Americans hostage from our embassy and tortured them till Reagan took office. They then let the hostages go because they rightly thought Ronald would nuke Iran. I feel for the hostages but if they weren’t released how vastly more lives would have been saved in the long run by their experiencing a nuclear strike? Would there even be such a thing as terrorists movements after a reprisal like that?

Old Silk
Old Silk
20 days ago

Israel having a policy is all that counts where Israel is concerned, and just because they don’t advertise their policy so that they can be overcome and overwhelmed does not mean that Israel doesn’t have one.

Randall L. Beatty
Randall L. Beatty
20 days ago

He can’t do nothing overseas right so what can we expect here in this country. No matter what he does wrong to Dems in this country he can do no wrong people in this country overlook all the illegals he let into this country more then likely because it was him they just do not care and crime well they point there fingers at President Trump anything that is bad in this country is all Trump’s fault. All the cities that have people living in tents well that shows what is going on just like a 3rd world country it will only get worse.

Glen
Glen
20 days ago

“Biden Has No Israel Policy” —- Exactly right, because he is the PUPPET NOT the PUPPET MASTER.

An older blonde women laughing in the kitchen with a grey haired man.
AMAC’s Medicare Advisory Service
The knowledge, guidance, and choices of coverage you’re looking for. The exceptional service you deserve.
The AMAC App on 3 different iPhone
Download the AMAC App
The AMAC App is the place to go for insightful news wherever you are and whenever you want.
Joe Biden speaking with attendees
NEW YORK - OCT 10:American homeless sleeps in New York city subway on October 10 2009.A 2013 report show that the number of homeless people recorded in NYC topped 50,000 for the first time.
Former President of the United States Donald Trump speaking with attendees at the 2023 Turning Point Action Conference at the Palm Beach County Convention Center in West Palm Beach, Florida.
gen z and boomers; election - pick your side poster

Stay informed! Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

25
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Subscribe to AMAC Daily News and Games