Finance / Politics

How Much Does Illegal Immigration Cost You?

Immigration Razor Wire - AMACUnlawful Immigration and Amnesty

Current unlawful immigration can pose large fiscal costs for U.S. taxpayers. Government provides four types of benefits and services that are relevant to this issue:

  • Direct benefits – These include Social Security, Medicare, unemployment insurance, and workers’ compensation.
  • Means-tested welfare benefits – There are over 80 of these programs which, at a cost of nearly $900 billion per year, provide cash, food, housing, medical, and other services to roughly 100 million low-income Americans. Major programs include Medicaid, food stamps, the refundable Earned Income Tax Credit, public housing, Supplemental Security Income, and Temporary Assistance for Needy Families.
  • Public education – At a cost of $12,300 per pupil per year, these services are largely free or heavily subsidized for low-income parents.
  • Population-based services – Police, fire, highways, parks, and similar services, as the National Academy of Sciences determined in its study of the fiscal costs of immigration, generally have to expand as new immigrants enter a community; someone has to bear the cost of that expansion.

The cost of these governmental services is far larger than many people imagine. For example, in 2010, the average U.S. household received $31,584 in government benefits and services in these four categories.

The governmental system is highly redistributive. Well-educated households tend to be net tax contributors: The taxes they pay exceed the direct and means-tested benefits, education, and population-based services they receive. For example, in 2010, in the whole U.S. population, households with college-educated heads, on average, received $24,839 in government benefits while paying $54,089 in taxes. The average college-educated household thus generated a fiscal surplus of $29,250 that government used to finance benefits for other households.

Other households are net tax consumers: The benefits they receive exceed the taxes they pay. These households generate a “fiscal deficit” that must be financed by taxes from other households or by government borrowing. For example, in 2010, in the U.S. population as a whole, households headed by persons without a high school degree, on average, received $46,582 in government benefits while paying only $11,469 in taxes. This generated an average fiscal deficit (benefits received minus taxes paid) of $35,113.

The high deficits of poorly educated households are important in the amnesty debate because the typical unlawful immigrant has only a 10th-grade education. Half of unlawful immigrant households are headed by an individual with less than a high school degree, and another 25 percent of household heads have only a high school degree.

Some argue that the deficit figures for poorly educated households in the general population are not relevant for immigrants. Many believe, for example, that lawful immigrants use little welfare. In reality, lawful immigrant households receive significantly more welfare, on average, than U.S.-born households. Overall, the fiscal deficits or surpluses for lawful immigrant households are the same as or higher than those for U.S.-born households with the same education level. Poorly educated households, whether immigrant or U.S.-born, receive far more in government benefits than they pay in taxes.

In contrast to lawful immigrants, unlawful immigrants at present do not have access to means-tested welfare, Social Security, or Medicare. This does not mean, however, that they do not receive government benefits and services. Children in unlawful immigrant households receive heavily subsidized public education. Many unlawful immigrants have U.S.-born children; these children are currently eligible for the full range of government welfare and medical benefits. And, of course, when unlawful immigrants live in a community, they use roads, parks, sewers, police, and fire protection; these services must expand to cover the added population or there will be “congestion” effects that lead to a decline in service quality.

In 2010, the average unlawful immigrant household received around $24,721 in government benefits and services while paying some $10,334 in taxes. This generated an average annual fiscal deficit (benefits received minus taxes paid) of around $14,387 per household. This cost had to be borne by U.S. taxpayers. Amnesty would provide unlawful households with access to over 80 means-tested welfare programs, Obamacare, Social Security, and Medicare. The fiscal deficit for each household would soar.

If enacted, amnesty would be implemented in phases. During the first or interim phase (which is likely to last 13 years), unlawful immigrants would be given lawful status but would be denied access to means-tested welfare and Obamacare. Most analysts assume that roughly half of unlawful immigrants work “off the books” and therefore do not pay income or FICA taxes. During the interim phase, these “off the books” workers would have a strong incentive to move to “on the books” employment. In addition, their wages would likely go up as they sought jobs in a more open environment. As a result, during the interim period, tax payments would rise and the average fiscal deficit among former unlawful immigrant households would fall.

After 13 years, unlawful immigrants would become eligible for means-tested welfare and Obamacare. At that point or shortly thereafter, former unlawful immigrant households would likely begin to receive government benefits at the same rate as lawful immigrant households of the same education level. As a result, government spending and fiscal deficits would increase dramatically.

The final phase of amnesty is retirement. Unlawful immigrants are not currently eligible for Social Security and Medicare, but under amnesty they would become so. The cost of this change would be very large indeed.

Immigration Map - AMAC

From Heritage.org

If You Enjoy Articles Like This - Subscribe to the AMAC Daily Newsletter!

Sign Up Today
Subscribe
Notify of
408 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
гдз по физике 10 класс рымкевич лабораторные работы
1 year ago

What’s up to every single one, it’s in fact a fastidious for me to go to see this site, it includes priceless Information.| а

adam smith
1 year ago

love how this site is just all b.s. not backed up with any actual facts. There are no government sources, just all conjecture based on fear. And immigrants use more welfare than American citizens? Bull. Back that up. My wife is an immigrant and has never used it. She has plenty of her own money, and she graduated from medical school, in her own country. How many Americans can say the same thing?

Handone
2 years ago

What about the American Citizen who getsn no benefits because they make 10.00 over the wage that the illegal makes. Like me for a example, I make 10k a year & am not eligiable for any welfare benefits, so how can they be? “Oh” that’s right I am not here illegaly. Take care of American citizen’s FIRST. OfferAmericansa chance to live their dream instead of having to live without dignity& get by on bare neccessities. We do not have enough resources & room to house 2 more million law breakers. No More immigration till Americans get to live their dream, instead of giving the opportunity to some illegaly alien. SEND THEM BACK TO WHERE THEY CAME FROM. No child should be a citizen if born on American soil. Their parent’s & the unborn child are still under their country’s thority & protection protection, that child is also.

Jesus coming
2 years ago

We live in a very twisted world the love of money is the root of all kinds of evil not money itself people coming over illegally are not all good people many nations have hated us and they have terrorists mixed in as well as good but most people who have come here in past came in legally so ask yourself why not legally what do they have to hide watch jack van imp over 200 terrorists camps in America since Obama became president and open borders .since America stopped holy bibles in schools,prayer,Ten Commandments anything of god satan has taken over more and more see thru hate,shootings, all bad is demons controlling people putting evil thoughts read holy bible genisis read how Eve was deceived by serpent Satan who used to be a beautiful angel god created turned on god was kicked out of heaven with one third fallen angels. You can’t see them they can speak to your mind or posses people holy bible explains all.to protect ourselves we need to know god’s word.put on the full armor of god get the book when you have repented of sins ask god to forgive you accept Jesus god will open your eyes to truth. So glad I did satan wants to steal,kill and destroy everyone even families his time is getting very short during armeggedon jesus second coming he will put satan in bottomless Pitt demons in hell with fallen and unbelievers of jesus then new heaven new earth new jerusalem no more sickness no more wars no more aging no more death man will never be who god is perfect.

Jim
2 years ago

Why does’nt the government find out how many are here and how much this is going to cost thus should be declare national emergency and the wall should be built on that claim you are seeing are country being destoy

susie sue
3 years ago

THe citizens of u.s.a have feed, educated and insured all these immigrants, they are an asset to their natural born country they should go back and change their goverment with all their knowlegde. Go back smarter.

Karen
3 years ago

Then make them legal. They pay taxes and spend the money they earn here. Problem solved. Your numbers are way off as a matter of fact…but you don’t care as long it convinces people to not let brown people in. Plenty of white illegal immigrants that no one seems to be bothered by. But you’re not the least bit racist. And besides our government loves illegal. They fill private for profit prison beds and keep investors like Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton happy and rolling in incarceration profits. You’re all fkn looking where they want you to….which is the other direction from the truth.

Joseph Hickman
3 years ago

Basic math, it doesn’t match… when the For father’s wrote the Constitution. They didn’t have a crystal ball to for see that a parasite country south would flood (yes contrary to p.c. liberals) un educated orphans of a backward misbegotten colony of Spain would release from their prison cells and point north and don’t come back

Leonardo DiPartlow
3 years ago

What I don’t understand is, why don’t the illegal undocumented immigrants who broke the law by coming here to the United States and ask the American people for forgiveness instead of making up lame excuses for being in the country illegally in the first place? Because, if you’re truly sorry for entering the United States illegally you wouldn’t have an issue with going back to the back of the legal immigration line. I understand that most undocumented illegal immigrants are coming to the United States to make livingood to survive but what they fail to realize is, that by coming here to the United States illegally has a affect on the poor and middle class Americans and helps the corporate American elite line their coffers by cheating the poor and middle class out wage hikes. And keeping the wages very low so American citizens can’t make ends meet.

Besides that, illegal immigration puts and heavy strain on the education system with overcrowding. You are getting benefits you don’t deserve from the United States welfare system because it wasn’t earned.

I and remember sick and tired of people who say the illegal undocumented immigrants who snuck into the United States or over stayed their visa are hard workers and will do jobs Americans won’t do. That not the true. Americans won’t do hard labor unless they are getting paid a decent wage. Cheap labor doesn’t really help the American people. It only help the corporate elites who use cheap labor to undercut the majority of the American people’s wages. While the corporate elites lined their money coffers to get rich at the expense of the majority of the American people.

The big lie was, illegal immigrants help revitalize residential and commercial property. That was one of the biggest lies told to justify why illegal immigrants should be able to stay in the United States after breaking the law to get here. It’s not all about illegal immigrants from Latin America coming here, it’s about all undocumented illegal immigrants breaking the law to get into the United.

In addition to that, their has been a high level of diseases that the United States had virtually eliminated has begun to make a comeback because undocumented immigrants bring in diseases andoing other illnesses undetected. By the time it’s realize what going on itso too late. The damage is done.

Where the undocumented immigrants make the mistake in doing is, trusting the American elites over poor and middle class Americans. They look down poor and needed Americans as though it their fault why they are in a wretched condition. What if the majority of Americans did that to them? They wouldn’t like it.

Most Americans are sympathetic to the undocumented immigrants who have snuck into the United States illegally. . But they don’t accept the demands the undocumented immigrants want to put on the American people as a whole. Why, because you are here illegally in their country. Plus, many illegal immigrants have this “take all” attitude. They act allspice though they allure back in their country of origin. Trying to be nationalistic in a country not your own is detrimental because some illegal immigrants refuse to simulate fully into American society. Some illegal and legal immigrants also bring in their own form of racial views. They try to treat some Americansort like second class citizens in their own country.

The majority of Latino immigrants from Latin America think of themselves as being closer to Caucasian people even though they a people of color themselves. Maybe in their country of birth they really classified as white but here in the United States the “one drop rule” rules the day. Just because you look closer to white don’t make you white. You can have blonde hair and blue with a Caucasian complexion and still have that black grandma in the closet basement or attic waiting to tell her story.

White America used illegal immigration to dilute the political voice of the Native Indigenous and the “Middle Passage” community here in the United States to exploit them politically. They gave the black community the “cracks epidemic” of the eighties and nineti6es era. Why was that? That’s because they were trying to replace the “Middle Passage” community with the undocumented illegal immigrant population. And turned right around and started criminalizing the Latino community with the same thing, especially the Hispanic community. That is because the powers that be don’t need them any more to help hold the “Middle Passage” in a constant perpetual state of turmoil as their bottomline to get rid of the “Middle Passage” community by any means necessary.

Lic Bag
3 years ago

This was fun. According to your own numbers: “in 2010, the average U.S. household received $31,584 in government benefits and services in these four categories.”, then “in 2010, in the whole U.S. population, households with college-educated heads, on average, received $24,839 in government benefits”, then “in 2010, in the U.S. population as a whole, households headed by persons without a high school degree, on average, received $46,582 in government benefits while paying only $11,469 in taxes. This generated an average fiscal deficit (benefits received minus taxes paid) of $35,113.” , and then the coup d’etat, “In 2010, the average unlawful immigrant household received around $24,721 in government benefits and services”, meaning that they receive almost $11,000 less than college educated households. And there are far more households without a high school degree than there are illegal immigrants, estimated at about 12% of the population of 320,000,000, which amounts to 38,400,000. How many illegal immigrants are estimated to be in the US? 3,700,000.
Let’s have some fun now. Which number is SIGNIFICANTLY larger? 3,700,000 or 38,400,000. For the sake of your argument, “typical unlawful immigrant has only a 10th-grade education”, let’s remove every single illegal immigrant from the population that has no high school degree, which now equals 34,700,000, or 10.6% of the leaches on the system, that again, according to your own numbers, take $11,000 more than illegal immigrant.
Or, if you want to go by average fiscal deficit, uneducated Americans cost $35,113, where illegal immigrants cost $14,387. Maybe if we educated Americans, #1: they’d be able to read between your very blurry lines in an attempt to make a very suspect point. #2: They’d be more of a contributor to our fiscal bottom line, rather than a drain. #3 They’d vote a hell of a lot more maturely rather than on emotion. Oh yeah, and you tore your own argument with the 4th to last sentence in your garbage attempt at scapegoating illegal immigrants: “As a result, during the interim period, tax payments would rise and the average fiscal deficit among former unlawful immigrant households would fall.” Let me explain your killing of your own argument – for 13 years, illegal immigrant will pay taxes, but get very little benefit for it. Thus, reducing their ‘fiscal deficit”.
Again, if we spent more on education, stupid people would read between the lines for what racist rhetoric this is, rather than read with their feelings

ANM
3 years ago
Reply to  Lic Bag

Liar. Take that phony number you use for illegals present here (3,700,000) and multiply that by a factor of 10 to arrive at a starting point to calculate numbers of illegals currently here. Based on a normal track for pop. growth in Mexico alone, they are presently short 30 M persons who should still be living there but are not.

Young
3 years ago

It’s an outrage. Stop funding illegal invaders or they will just keep coming, another two million per year. Current and future retirees are largely impacted by these criminal invaders.

Floria Mcgee
3 years ago

I feel that this is very unfair to US citizens for an immigrant to come into my country and receive benefits that I and many other US citizens so badly need. Why are immigrants living better than I? They have better educational schools, better medical, better housing and everything that I have worked so hard to enjoy but I have nothing because every thing that belongs to me as a citizen I am not able to obtain because you the government’s is giving what belongs to me to someone else why is this so and how could you do such a thing toe and have no remorse about doing so. You are not for me you are against me, but guess what the shoe will end up on the other foot and let’s just see how you will like that. Signed VERY CONCERNED…

manuel martinez
4 years ago

sounds good, better help your fellow man than building destroyers that just float around doing nothing.

manueI martinez
3 years ago

plus, why should l work when you have more and should give it to me.

Judith Chernek Rimdzius
4 years ago

Completely agree with the stance AMAC has taken. I’m sick and tired of the immigration problem buy mostly I’m sick and tired of paying for it. I have many people in my own family and neighborhood that could use a helping hand but there is no money for them because it’s going to so many immigrants. My ancestors were immigrants from Ireland. When they got here our government didn’t give them a dime. NO free food, no medical care, no housing NO NUTTIN. They had to work hard for everything. This is a huge difference from many of today’s immigrants.

Hazel Thomas
4 years ago

It is very discouraging that we have become the purse for ever deadbeat who want free everything under the sun + Sending our children to fight wars for the Cowards. While our politicians rob us.(see GWBush, Chaney,& Haliburton). Thank God for Trump! Get up a petition. I’m 78 without the skill but I WILL SIGN’ we are tired of being suckers! Round them ALL up &Send them packing!

Dave
4 years ago

I do dislike illegal immigrants, pretty much everything about them. The way they suck up our resources, crowd our educational and medical systems, and then have the gall to go out in the streets and demonstrate and burn American flags is enough to hate their guts. I don’t understand why people are compassionate to these thieves. I’m not looking for explanations, nothing will explain the permissive attitudes about half of Americans have, nor the attitude towards the muslims. Why do Americans want to see America fail? Just don’t get it

Dave
4 years ago

Ya that’s just plain sad. Too many immigrants. No education, no assets, just liability

Carly
4 years ago

So billions are spent on illegal immigrants, yet the the poor but working is offered a storage cardboard box with a lid shown on 19 action news as a way for their infants to get healthy sleep.

Yvette Celaya
4 years ago

Where are your sources, data… have you ever heard of MLA or APA.

Loretta
4 years ago

We need to stop supporting illegals and this would help to control the illegal immigration. If they didn’t get everything free here they would not come. My own family had to fight to get what help they could when my fathers work was slow. He was in construction and thru the winter h boss would not have work for him. This was not right . My mother would not even get enough foodstamps to feed us a week much less a month and because we were white they didn’t think we should be getting anything or less than families that had fewer children. We saw this with our own eyes. So you cannot tell me anything about being poor we were some of the poorest children in our school which was mostly black and no one ever offered to help us. What little we did have my father and mother struggled to get for us and they both came from share cropper families and would go barefoot in summer to save there one pair of ragged shoes to have something to ware in winter. Illegals do take our jobs and they are not jobs our people will not do. My husband was a remodeler and stopped because he could not get any work due to illegals getting them all and he was reasonable on his job estimates and the only way they could have done them cheaper was someone had to felt sorry for them and gave them matrials cheaper. or the government supplementing them . Also I had only one pair of shoes about helping these illegals help our people born here and whose families built this country. Some of mine came over on the Mayflower and some met the boat!!!!!

408
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x