Advocacy / AMAC In The Media / AMAC On Capitol Hill / Health & Wellness / Politics

Congress Could Help Millions of Patients With a Simple Tax Deduction, Senior Group Says

election 2018 government congress support tax deduction seniorCongress could help millions of patients with a simple tax deduction provided for in a bill that could be passed before the lame duck session ends, according to a conservative seniors group.

The Association of Mature American Citizens (AMAC) is touting the Good Samaritan Charitable Physicians’ Services Act as a way to incentivize doctors to offer pro-bono health care to Medicaid-eligible individuals through a charitable tax deduction for the work they do. The savings to the federal government would be in the billions, according to AMAC.

The bill would apply to the roughly 73 million Americans enrolled in Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program, AMAC’s founder Dan Weber told The Daily Caller News Foundation Tuesday.

“We’re trying to come up with alternative solutions that work in the free enterprise system,” Weber told TheDCNF.

AMAC representatives are in Washington, D.C., in December to persuade lawmakers to get behind the bill.

Republican Florida Rep. Daniel Webster introduced the bill in May.

“Americans deserve a healthcare system that that will ensure access to health coverage for all, rein in costs, and allow our health care professionals to improve health care delivery through innovation,” Webster told TheDCNF in a statement Tuesday. “This bill is a creative, common-sense solution that ensures our most vulnerable Americans have access to the care they need, from the doctor they choose, at a price they can afford.”

The bill would encourage lower-income people to form relationships with primary care physicians, AMAC senior counselor Bob Carlstrom told TheDCNF Tuesday. As a side effect, patients would be more likely to visit doctors before their ailments become too serious. Many patients put off seeking medical help until they have no choice but to make emergency room visits, which can be 20 times as expensive as physicians’ office visits.

The bill would save $6.6 billion a year in Medicaid payouts for emergency room visits alone, according to AMAC’s calculations. That’s if 7 million people who made an emergency room visit at the 2016 average cost of $1,917 instead went to a physician for a visit costing roughly $100.

Of course, that’s a drop in the bucket compared to the hundreds of billions of dollars (pushing one trillion) the federal government spent per year on health care as of 2015, according to the Tax Policy Center.

“All that’s required under present laws— it’s just a simple gap — is to permit physicians to claim a deduction,” Carlstrom told TheDCNF. “This enables them to get that deduction within their own offices … It provides greater relief to the states who are struggling with Medicaid, and it also provides an antidote to the need to expand Medicaid.”

Many physicians can and do provide pro-bono work through nonprofit clinics, Carlstrom told TheDCNF. But the bill facilitates “classic” patient-doctor relationships that can contribute to better outcomes by replacing a complicated process. To get any sort of tax deduction, physicians must go through a “ridiculous” process that involves billing patients for the services both parties already know they can’t afford, he told TheDCNF.

Weber said he has already received positive reactions to the bill from many physicians who are members of AMAC.

While in Washington, D.C., AMAC also plans to talk to lawmakers about broader goals, like chipping away at the national debt by encouraging smarter health care spending.

“We think it’s a horrible thing to do for our children and grandchildren to leave them with this overwhelming debt that is going to have to be paid off,” Weber told TheDCNF.

Weber describes AMAC as a conservative alternative to the American Association of Retired Persons (AARP), which he felt did not represent him for many reasons, including AARP’s pro-Obamacare stance. His organization was founded in 2007 and now has 1.5 million members, he said.

Other advocacy groups are in Washington, D.C., this week pushing for the lame duck lawmakers to pass certain bills. For example, business advocates are making a final push to the lame duck Congress to delay an Affordable Care Act tax on health insurance providers that they say will hurt small businesses.

Passing a flurry of bills could be complicated after votes were postponed for a week Monday due to the passing of former President George H.W. Bush on Nov. 30. The next votes will be on Dec. 10, House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy’s office said.

TheDCNF contacted all of the Democrats on the House Subcommittee on Health about Webster’s bill but did not receive any responses at the time of publication.

Reprinted with permission from - The Daily Caller - by Evie Fordham

If You Enjoy Articles Like This - Subscribe to the AMAC Daily Newsletter!

Sign Up Today
Read more articles by Outside Contributor
Notify of
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Dan W.
1 year ago

If you really want to incent primary care physicians (PCPs) to provide pro-bono treatment in their offices, offer the PCPs a tax credit instead of a tax deduction.

Keith H
1 year ago

You want to help Seniors ? Stop giving our Social Security to everybody on Planet Earth !!! For Heaven Sake !!! Social Security is for Seniors ONLY.!!! No one else should get it. And if you don’t contribute, you don’t get any. I’m 62 now and I’ve been paying for since I was 16. By the time I start at 66 and 4 months. There won’t be any. You know that theft started by a bunch of Libtard Loser Dumocrats way back when. Those Greedy Commie Loving Libtards !!! That Cancerous growth we can’t seem to get rid of. These… Read more »

1 year ago

Our Congress and Senate contain many members from both parties that do not give one DAMN about the people who put them in office. They care for themselves only.

David Conover
1 year ago

First set tat tax break up for pro bono health care to senior citizens on Medicare. We don’t always have the extra cash for deductibles and co payments or our meds.

1 year ago

you can’t beat a F’ING libTURD demoRAT when it comes to F’ING something up!

1 year ago

Seniors don’t need for their money to be given to illegals and their kids. If you want to help Seniors, HELP SENIORS!!! I cannot afford 2 of my prescriptions which are $50 each after Medicare pays their part. So I don’t get them and don’t take them, though I am supposed to do so. Without the Medicare part paying they would be $350.00!!!

1 year ago


Tracy Lee
1 year ago

Make a simple change to the tax code, to allow a tax credit or deduction for the cost of nutritional supplements. Preventing or delaying chronic diseases will save even more money than creating cheaper ways to treat diseases.

Brian C.
1 year ago

Sounds great on t he surface but I agree with Dan. When are people going to figure out that a tax deduction is nothing more than a discount amounting to your current tax rate. Whatever it is, is still costing you money. Another clever redistribution – those rich doctors should pay more by giving away their time free. A tax credit would spread it across the entire tax base. Still redistribution but at least across an all inclusive base.

Toni K Weaver
1 year ago

This is all well and good for those on Medicaid. But those who don’t qualify for Medicaid ,what about them?

Robert Messmer
1 year ago

Quote: “To get any sort of tax deduction, physicians must go through a “ridiculous” process that involves billing patients for the services both parties already know they can’t afford, he told TheDCNF.” You do not get a deduction, you simply report your actual income. If the patient does not pay, you do not have income. Really a quite simple process. It applies to work billed for and for pro bono services in every business and has been in effect since 1913.

Roseann Riddle
1 year ago

Great idea. As the wife of a physician, I know he would have been able to give away more of his services if he could have deducted them, instead of having to take more paying patients to earn his living.

Randy Heikens
1 year ago

Did not realize Amac was “in bed” with Obama on his highly expensive Obamacare plan for the country. NO FRIGGIN THANKS.

H.E.Butler M.D., F.A.C.S.
8 months ago

Shouldn’t Congress and our states/commonwealths adopt Virginia’s tax-credit (I) for treating indigent people?
(1). Donations of Professional Services, Code of Virginia, available online

Betty Hicks
1 year ago

Medical bills are outrageous and prescription drugs are over priced. We also need a simple tax system. a value added tax would be ideal that way everyone pays their share of taxes, illegals, tourist, plus all those people who live on welfare. make an exception for food with no tax. The system is already in place as the states collect sales tax. Just think no sweating the April 15th deadline anymore and we are never sure we have them filled out correctly.

Cara Mercer
1 year ago

What about people who have NO health insurance? Neither my husband or myself have had insurance for almost 3 years now due to the cost. Almost 2x as much as out house payment, I see a doctor that does not accept insurance and am on a monthly payment. Seems fine until you need testing outside of his scope of practice. So, again, my health suffers. We need a plan to help folks like us, also.

Neil Davie
1 year ago

This seems a good start to decrease taxpayer support of healthcare while giving more care benefits.

1 year ago

Seems to be a sensible proposal.

Joe Smaha
1 year ago

Great idea

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x