Government Watch / Politics / We The People

Barr’s Warning on Education and Religious Freedom Rings True One Year Later

AMAC Exclusive – By Shane Harris

Bill Barr

As education battles continue to take center stage in the Culture Wars, it’s worth looking back on a speech given one year ago today by former Attorney General Bill Barr, who served in that role under both President George H.W. Bush and President Donald Trump. In his speech, Barr outlined why the progressive ideology being pushed today in K-12 schools is concerning, not just from the standpoint of preventing the radicalization of America’s youth, but from the standpoint of protecting religious liberty as well. His analysis, in addition to proving prescient about how classrooms would become a key battleground in the Culture War, continues to provide insight into how conservatives might approach education issues today, and why Judeo-Christian values remain so important, even for non-religious people, as the left seeks to erase them from every part of American life.

In the remarks, which were delivered to Alliance Defending Freedom as Barr accepted their “Edwin Meese III Award for Originalism and Religious Liberty,” he described how progressives, under the guise of making education religiously neutral, have instead substituted wokeness as the official religion of state-run education. Progressivism, Barr argues, has “all the trapping and hallmarks of a religion. It has its notion of original sin, salvation, penance, its clergy, its dogmas, its sensitivity to any whiff of heresy, even its burning at the stake.” Moreover, this “secular-progressivism orthodoxy” in schools is “totally incompatible with traditional Christianity and other major religious traditions in our country.”

But how did we get here? As Barr explained, public education in the United States has proceeded in three basic phases. First, early advocates for state-run schools explicitly incorporated broadly acceptable religious content into education, understanding as they did that one cannot “separate moral education from religion.” In the second phase, beginning in the mid-20th Century, “the left embarked on a relentless campaign of secularization intent on driving every vestige of traditional religion from the public square,” Barr said. But, he noted, without the common thread of Judeo-Christian values, there was no underpinning for the generic “be a good person” moral code that the left wished to push in schools. “What passed for morality [in the public school curriculum] had no metaphysical foundation,” he pointed out. “It is hard to teach that someone ought to behave in a certain way unless you can explain why.”

In the third phase of public education that we are witnessing now, Barr noted that even the “vapor trails of Christianity” have been dismantled and replaced entirely with “a secular belief system and worldview that is a substitute for religion and is antithetical to the beliefs and values of traditional God-centered religion.” The woke ideologies being foisted on schoolchildren are, as Barr describes, far from religiously neutral, but are instead a religion all their own that is “fundamentally incompatible with Christianity.”

Naturally, many parents and educators are opposed to this fundamental shift in the nature of education, and are now fighting back against it. Following Barr’s speech in May of last year, education took center stage in the Virginia gubernatorial election, with Glenn Youngkin becoming the first Republican to win statewide in more than a decade after promising to ban Critical Race Theory and give parents more control over their children’s education.

Conservative school board candidates pledging to get wokeness out of schools have also seen a wave of success over the past year, and many candidates for federal office have also come out strongly in opposition to the politicization of school curriculum. While the movement for a return to more traditional education is not explicitly based on religious motives, even many non-religious Americans understand that it is the Judeo-Christian values upon which the country was founded that are the foundation of an honest and well-rounded education.

But for Barr, fixing the problem may require more than just exposing instances of wokeism taking root in schools and winning school board elections, although those developments are undoubtedly positive. To bring about real change, he argued, Americans must first recognize that it is an utterly failing strategy to give a monopoly over public education to a secularist cult which in turn decides what students learn in schools. In pushing concepts like Critical Race Theory, the public school system as it currently exists has by and large betrayed its fundamental mission of “promot[ing] our common identity” by “separating us… teaching unbridgeable differences… [and] waging war on the nation’s moral, historical, philosophical, and religious foundations.”

Instead, he argued, parents should have the option of using the public dollars set aside for the education of their children to send their kids to schools that align with their values and beliefs. This solution also holds great promise for kids trapped in failing public schools.

Unsurprisingly, elected Democrats are terrified at the prospect that they will no longer have free rein to fill the minds of America’s youth with left-wing propaganda. When President Biden said last month that children “belong” to the school when they are in the classroom, he was saying out loud what the left has quietly believed for decades – that parents’ wishes don’t matter when it comes to what their kids learn in the classroom. This line of thinking explains why Democrats, instead of viewing school choice as a way for parents to exercise their freedom of religion by empowering them to send their children to a school that aligns with their beliefs, are outraged at the prospect that any American student should not be trained as an unquestioning, unthinking disciple of progressivism.

For Republicans, whether through enabling greater school choice or other means, addressing the influx of leftism in education presents an opportunity to deliver a victory not just for freedom of thought, but for freedom of religion as well. For the future of our country and the health of our democracy, perhaps no battle is more important to win than this one.  

Shane Harris is a writer and political consultant from Southwest Ohio. You can follow him on Twitter at @Shane_Harris_


We hope you've enjoyed this article. While you're here, we have a small favor to ask...

Support AMAC Action. Our 501 (C)(4) advances initiatives on Capitol Hill, in the state legislatures, and at the local level to protect American values, free speech, the exercise of religion, equality of opportunity, sanctity of life, and the rule of law.

Donate Now

If You Enjoy Articles Like This - Subscribe to the AMAC Daily Newsletter
and Download the AMAC News App

Sign Up Today Download

If You Enjoy Articles Like This - Subscribe to the AMAC Daily Newsletter!


Subscribe
Notify of
24 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mario Capparuccini
1 month ago

Vote the Democrats out. They are evil. Vote them all out.

John Cochrane
1 month ago

Barr’s comments while correct, lack verve because of his lack of courage in defending President Trump.

Bill on the Hill
1 month ago

Amac puts this out there, despite the fact Bill Barr turned on his president as did the VP, with Pence now stumping for one of the most corrupt governors in Georgian history, Brian Kemp with his deep CCP of China ties & all that Chinese ballot paper, lacking barcodes & watermarks along with their SOS now suddenly waking up to the 2020 Georgia senatorial election fraud in Jan. of 2021, must be reelection time folks!
Back to Barr, Barr repeatedly stated he saw ZERO signs of anything resembling voter fraud, even in those ( 6 ) Key States, i.e. secretly he wanted Trump gone just as bad as the Democrat/RINO’s did…
Yes, Barr made an impassioned speech on the evils of CRT & those that were & continue to be behind it…
Barr obviously had a problem with Trump personally as did VP Pence & in the end both of these men DO NOT deserve the print coverage that Amac would appear to feel Barr deserves, allowing this Shane Harris piece to be put out for mass consumption, it feels like back peddling to me as Barr doesn’t deserve getting this credit after stabbing his president in the back & lying to the American people to boot…Barr BROKE his solemn oath to the US Constitution when he knowingly denied any election fraud existed to any great extent in 2020 & puts John Durham in as Special Council, to investigate the Russian Collusion Hoax…
In the end, history will NOT be kind to Barr, Biden, Harris, Pelosi, Schumer, Mueller, Rosenstein, Clapper, Brennan, Comey, Wray, pencil neck, Rice, Obama, Hillary & Bill Clinton, her campaign lawyer Sussman & associates at Perkins Coie & on & on it goes, this is a short list of traitors, most deserving to be indicted for SEDITION & whatever verdict is handed down as a final result…
As I understand it, Sedition & Treason fall under penalty of death back when we used to have genuine patriots within all ( 3 ) branches of our government, now look what he have… :~(
In closing, ” When government fears it’s people we have LIBERTY, when people fear their government, we have Tyranny. ”
Bill… :~)

Max
1 month ago

Your final sentence is on the mark.

John Cohrane
1 month ago

Bill on the hill,
Your comments are great. They are spot-on!
God bless America ????????????????????????

ops
1 month ago

Want to change society then begin with the children!

Bill on the Hill
1 month ago
Reply to  ops

Hitler knew this only to well, hence the Hitler Youth League & many in fact died as the end result…
Biden is pretty much saying the same thing when he very recently stated, the ” teachers own our children ” when in the classroom, NOT…I’m writing from VT & our very small rural middle school, K -8 is teaching CRT as they call it something different in various clever ways when reading the school’s budget report mailed out to taxpaying households across ( 2 ) towns here in north central Vermont…It started with the liberal colleges decades ago & has now moved into the public school systems across America, with some exceptions, i.e. my immediate neighbor NH FORBIDS any form of it being taught in K-12, by law in their public schools…
Bill… :~)

Max
1 month ago

Correct.

Morbious
1 month ago

Barr is one of many who throw red meat to salivating dogs (us) then promptly proceed to act in ways that advance their supposed idealogical enemies. We have legions of alarm sounders who scamper away when action is needed . We had one champion and these cockroaches hated his demeanor , his voice, his hair etc. When they turned on trump they showed what they are. Spare me the pious speeches.

PaulE
1 month ago
Reply to  Morbious

Well said Morbious. I am frankly sick and tire of all these inside the beltway officials, who were all dead silent and did little to nothing to help the President when they were in a position to do so. To address the very subjects, they now complain about. Now suddenly, with a book to sell and looking for either a lucrative TV consultant gig or a position in some future administration, they are all crawling out of the woodwork to opine on a variety of topics.

Morbious
1 month ago
Reply to  PaulE

Thanks. The irony slaps me that construction has begun on a medal of honor museum. At the same time we’re beset with wealthy cowards who would be risking what exactly? Frowns? Disinvitations to fancy balls? Their book will come out, as you say, painting themselves as a mix of washington, lincoln and heston as moses. Their silence was noble. Their inaction bravery. Imagine if even a few well placed officials had put principle ahead of their precious sensitivities.

Bill on the Hill
1 month ago
Reply to  Morbious

The Texas Medal of Honor Museum endorsed by Bill Clinton, George Bush Jr. & Barack Hussein Obama himself… I ask, what’s wrong with this picture? How involved is Governor Abbott in this, after all he is a RINO, no getting away from this folks…
How’s that southern border wall coming along Gov? Still allowing them to walk right in?
Bill… :~)

Max
1 month ago

I tried to think of a witty response to your question but nothing jumped out. Endorsed by Barack surprised me. Endorsement by COUSINs Bill and George did not as they have use their drug, oops, family monies for something so the southern invasion can continue.

Toni
1 month ago

Satan is alive and well and each of these leftist demons have been indoctrinating your children into a life of pure evil…yes, that sounds bizarre to some people but just think about people who are good and their beliefs, and people who are bad and their beliefs…why is it polar opposite? Would one rather see people with love and understanding or a society that is continuously getting more and more perverted or twisted like “no such thing as women only birthing people”, or “there are many sexes”, or “men can have babies”, or allowing a 5 year old to decide what their “real” sex is, or that an unborn child can be murdered even after being born or assisted suicide for sick or old people because life doesn’t mean anything…so you see humankind left to its own devices inherently destroys itself with evil…back to my original statement, Satan is alive and well my friends…

gin
1 month ago
Reply to  Toni

Not much longer. “As in the days of Noah” See Genesis chapter six verse five. Jesus who is one with God, and the only way to God, will remove His church, all people who are trusting Him as Savior, not a particular denomination. Then the antichrist will be revealed. He will seem good at first. People who don’t know scripture will end up taking the mark of the beast when they are told they need it to buy and sell. Time for everyone to wake up.

John Cochrane
1 month ago
Reply to  Toni

Yes, evil and satan are real. God is real also, so let us all work on becoming better Christians and God-believers and spread the love and truth of God.

anna hubert
1 month ago

I wonder where left stands on islam and would they dare touch it on the other hand both are rigid and controlling so perhaps some compromise might be reached

Dave
1 month ago
Reply to  anna hubert

I’m sure they’re all in with islam, you will always get their attention when the subject of ‘virgins’ comes up…

Max
1 month ago
Reply to  anna hubert

From the stand point of religion, ISLAM is the one and only religion. All people will accept and convert to ISLAM or face death by beheading. ISLAM DOES NOT DALLY with its mission and they openly tell you of their objective. ISLAM DOES NOT OR WILL NOT COMPROMISE. They do not have to tell the TRUTH except to fellow believers of their faith. They are biding their time with the world as they slowly infiltrate the world’s society/nations, waiting to rear its ugly and hateful head. From a Christian point of view, ISLAM and the Qur’an/Koran are nothing more than SATAN’s religion and playbook that opposes the TRUTH of GOD’s book, the BIBLE.

Bill on the Hill
1 month ago
Reply to  Max

Thanks Max, that was beautifully stated & I’m glad you pointed it out that Islam allows their members to lie to any & all Infidels & can go as far as killing them as written in the the Koran…Now enter the Kenyan, along with his Photoshopped birth certificate, a devout member of Rev. Wright’s Church for ( 20 ) years preaching non-stop anti-America propaganda sermons…The Kenyan Community Organizer becomes potus, word gets out about his Rev. Wright obsession, Obama disassociates himself & his family from Wright’s Church…
( 8 ) very long years of a potus with pro-Muslim, i.e. Islam opinions & anti-Christian rhetoric his entire presidency…
Bill… :~)

James Jensen
1 month ago
Reply to  anna hubert

I think that Camel-a should be sent to Iraq wearing a gay pride burka. She could negotiate the nuclear weapons deal while under the influence of gravity from the top of a 3 story building.

Dave
1 month ago

Thirty-five years ago, I became aware of this happening and did what I could to bring attention to the rest of the class in hopes of fixing the problem.

It’s sort of like seeing the neighbor bring their dog to the public park and let it do what dogs need to do (just not there). I complained and pointed it out to people, but the ‘neighbor’ had friends who thought that I was ‘harassing them’ and said it was ok. Now the ‘town park’ is more like the ‘town dump’, people complain about the stench and mess, can’t enjoy the space…and now they reach out to me bit₵hing and complaining that I need to fix it…

Don’t care…I’ve moved on, YOU clean it up…

Joey Mize
1 month ago
Reply to  Dave

Dave Dave Dave,,,, As you stated you saw it coming…. so did many of us,,and sat by and did nothing, but now that it is here,? and we are all swaying to the music, come on down, Jump in, this cesspool of Liberal indecision and lawlessness is what it’s all about. Can’t wait for the midterms.

Dave
1 month ago
Reply to  Joey Mize

Can’t wait for the midterms.

Why? I’m sure the fix is in…

24
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x