Newsline

Newsline , Society

New York Times Editor Quits Amid Claims of Bullying and ‘New McCarthyism’

Posted on Wednesday, July 15, 2020
|
by Outside Contributor
|
62 Comments
|
Print

New York TimesNew York Times op-ed writer and editor Bari Weiss has quit the so-called “paper of record,” alleging in a resignation letter that she was bullied for expressing conservative viewpoints—the very reason she said she was brought on board in the first place.

“I was hired with the goal of bringing in voices that would not otherwise appear in your pages: first-time writers, centrists, conservatives, and others who would not naturally think of The Times as their home,” Weiss wrote in a letter to the newspaper’s publisher Arthur G. Sulzberger.

She said she was hired three years ago amid a bout of soul-searching at the paper after its “failure to anticipate the outcome of the 2016 election” and an apparent conclusion on the part of the publication’s leadership that the New York Times had missed the mark on what drove people in parts of America.

The priority in Opinion was to help redress that critical shortcoming,” she wrote, calling the opportunity to work towards that goal an honor. Yet in due course, she became increasingly disillusioned, arguing that a “new McCarthyism” had taken hold at the paper, forcing journalists to conform to an ideological “orthodoxy,” with the Twitter mob serving as “its ultimate editor.”

She claimed the paper came to view “truth” not as “a process of collective discovery, but an orthodoxy already known to an enlightened few whose job is to inform everyone else.”

“I was always taught that journalists were charged with writing the first rough draft of history. Now, history itself is one more ephemeral thing molded to fit the needs of a predetermined narrative,” she wrote.

Weiss claimed she was subjected to “constant bullying by colleagues who disagree with my views,” alleging that fellow journalists at the New York Times would call her “a Nazi and a racist.”

“There are terms for all of this: unlawful discrimination, hostile work environment, and constructive discharge,” Weiss wrote, adding, “I’m no legal expert. But I know that this is wrong.”

Further, she said her experience was not unique.

“The truth is that intellectual curiosity—let alone risk-taking—is now a liability at The Times. Why edit something challenging to our readers, or write something bold only to go through the numbing process of making it ideologically kosher, when we can assure ourselves of job security (and clicks) by publishing our 4000th op-ed arguing that Donald Trump is a unique danger to the country and the world? And so self-censorship has become the norm,” she wrote.

Her letter sparked a flurry of reactions on social media.

Ayaan Hirsi Ali, a human rights activist and fellow at the Hoover Institute, wrote in a tweet: “The New York Times was once a great paper. Not anymore. It is now held hostage by a small group of censorship terrorists. Yesterday they hounded out James Bennet and today it is Bari Weiss who must leave. Who is next?”

The Media Research Center, a conservative media watchdog with a focus on reporting liberal media bias, wrote in a tweet: “The @nytimes has proven that their paper does not seek the truth. @bariweiss’ resignation is just the beginning of the downfall of the New York Times.”

The New York Times did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Share this article:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
62 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
PaulE
PaulE
4 years ago

Yet another liberal NYT editor consumed by the socialist mob for the sin of NOT BEING SUFFICIENTLY in lock-step with the latest leftist dogma. Aw, such a surprise…NOT!!! It’s not like this woman was a staunch believer in a fair and honest press. She OK’ed hundreds of the most vile, dishonest and disgusting Op Ed’s in her tenure. Her crime was that she didn’t grovel and continuously bow fast enough before the ever-more demanding leftist mob.
 
This is what happens in all socialist / communist movements. One less then sufficiently enthusiastic response or action in conformity to the latest dictates of the mob and you are deemed a traitor to the cause and OUT YOU GO! This is how it played out constantly in Russia, after the communist revolution, in China, Argentina, Bolivia, Zimbabwe, North Korea, Venezuela and all the other socialist / communist Utopias over the last 100 plus years. You exist only to serve the cause unconditionally and the second you don’t display enough enthusiasm or unbridled commitment to everything associated with the latest edicts, you are gone. Positions of any minor authority or power in these Utopias were essentially revolving doors, as there was always someone willing to feed others to the mob for the sake of their own self-promotion up through the ranks. Fortunately for her, we haven’t yet fallen to pure socialism or communism or her fate would have been far worse than simply being forced to quit her job. I’m sure, being the typical NYC leftist liberal that she is, she isn’t smart enough to realize that though.

Stephen Russell
Stephen Russell
4 years ago

How wide spread is this in leftist media: IE Twitter, FB, LA Times, WaPo, Salon, etc etc A-Z
Any more care to resign?? See Lara Logan on Fox Nation as model, Need more
I say sue NYT for abuses alone.

par
par
4 years ago

Good for her. I am sure she will be called upon by any other more worthy newspaper.

Centurion
Centurion
4 years ago

I didn’t know the NYT had hired a conservative. Not surprising that it didn’t last. It won’t be long after November that the NYT will be placed on top of the trash heap of history.

David Spade
David Spade
4 years ago

So the liberal left are starting to “eat” their own. When the NYT and others in their diminished class stray so far from their mission, it’s no wonder that they disenfranchise themselves from a legitimate news organization. Their marching orders are given by the Marxist left in concert with the Democrat hierarchy to the detriment of one who reads their garbage.

Norris58
Norris58
4 years ago

NYT is in the hip pocket of the socialist liberal left. They never exposed the Clintons or Hillary’s crimes and cover-ups of Bengazi and her computer files. “You mean clean it with a rag?” That comment alone proves what a calculating socialist she is. The New York times is nothing but a rag paper It is not factual or unbiased. It is the mouthpiece of the socialist democrats.

Jane E. Walters
Jane E. Walters
4 years ago

The ongoing trend of reporting opinions in place of or on top of facts is disturbing.
Thank you for attempting to return to free speech, open discussion, and the idea that sharing on opposing point of view is not “hate speech.”

Mike D
Mike D
4 years ago

The NYT has never been “a great paper”. They ignored the holocaust of WWII and have always shown a leftist bias (not to be confused with liberal). They have done a great job of promoting themselves over the years. Crossword puzzles and book reviews don’t make a “news” paper great… unbiased reporting does.

Ann
Ann
4 years ago

I guess NYTimes as we know it is gone, long been gone. Whereas a paper is supposed to report the news for the reader to come to their own conclusion, it now makes up the conclusion themselves. Have stopped reading the paper long time ago.

R.J. from Arizona
R.J. from Arizona
4 years ago

It was on news yesterday that Liberty University has filed 10 million dollar suit against the paper. Good for LU

Rik
Rik
4 years ago

No tears shed for this Liberal lackey who I assume wouldn’t move far enough left to save her job. But no problem, I won’t be surprised that she’ll get another such position on another U.S. Pravda publication! I know she’ll just love the weather here in Progressively Communist California.

KEK
KEK
4 years ago

All of the major cities so called newspapers are all communist fronts and wants nothing more than to over throw the government but first and foremost is to get Trump and make sure he is not in no way re-elected for a 2nd term!

Shoe
Shoe
4 years ago

To understand WAPO and NY Times, you have to remember they were both in bankruptcy and saved by liberals. Jeff Bezos personally bought WAPO and a consortium headed by Mexican billionaire Carlos Slim bought The NY Times. Carlos is not majority owner but he is the largest single shareholder. In essence, The NY Times isn’t even an American newspaper.
Since those ownership changes they have increasingly hired radical editors.

Jack
Jack
4 years ago

The NYT is only good for bird cage lining. It’s already full of crap and more on the outside is all it’s good for.

Trish
Trish
4 years ago

Maybe…. just Maybe this will open her mind to a more level headed way of thinking. She could become a fashionable TRUTH seeking journalists!

Mytake
Mytake
4 years ago

She will get a better job in a better place. New York Times is corrupt and evil. Socialist and communist influence.

Kenjack
Kenjack
4 years ago

It’s common knowledge, or it should be anyway, that the New York Times abandoned bonafide news decades ago. They embraced the left wing narrative and never looked back. If the journalists and editors don’t conform, as in this case, they become persona non grata and are forced off of the NYT staff. The Times is not a newspaper, it is a myopic views-paper, the preeminent bully-pulpit for the leftists. You’d better conform if you want to work for the Times.

Melinda Alicia Ellison
Melinda Alicia Ellison
4 years ago

Somewhat like sheep in a pasture… They hear the ‘loud noise’ at the far end of the pasture… Then, they stampede their way to the cliff!!… The ‘Witch Hunt’ begins; running, shouting, destroying, and accusing!… Actually, animals on a farm behave more intelligently. Its a phenomena!

Gordon
Gordon
4 years ago

The New York Times needs to grow a set of ?? and start telling the truth and quit catering to the left and the Democrats. If they continue to follow the media herd then people should not buy or read what they have to say. How the once mighty fall. What a shame this woman had to find out the hard way. She should join a paper that will respect her work.

carol
carol
4 years ago

If the left keep eating their own everytime one of them won’t bow to the idols of the day, then maybe in the end they will destroy themselves! One can only hope!

Sid Stringer
Sid Stringer
4 years ago

It Seems to me New York has been completely taken over by any and all anti Americanism possible.

Paul W
Paul W
4 years ago

A little glimmer of integrity and journalistic honesty at the slimes. No wonder she felt compelled to exit that den of radical propaganda.

Phil Hammersley
Phil Hammersley
4 years ago

The “Slimes” is a piece of toilet paper! Always been far-left. In the 1930s Walter Duranty got a Pulitzer for articles praising Stalin’s Potemkin villages, knowing that he was being used by Stalin. He still wrote the phony articles!!

Art A
Art A
4 years ago

Bari Weiss resigned her position as a writer where she expressed or reported on conservative viewpoints and was bullied because she was doing the job that she was hired to do. How long had she been bullied? If the situation was so bad,why did it take her so long to leave? The Times must be having hard times. It almost would make you believe that she suffered some sort of Stockholm Syndrome. I am not acquainted with anyone who stayed working at a toxic position for very long. Perhaps she will find her niche at her next stop.

Mandy
Mandy
4 years ago

How long is it going to take Americans to realize that this is a Communist movement to take down America?he leadership of the DNC are Communists….Clintons and Obama as well as most likely others. I know this from reading the book “You Can Trust the Communists (to be Communists), written in 1965 and can be found free online if you search the title provided. Or purchase an copy of the book online with an addition by David Noebel.  The first 20 pages or so are slow reading but after that, I couldn’t put the book down.
 
This book states the USSR only allowed those to visit that they believed they could use and then remember, they gave permission for Bill Clinton to visit when he was a Rhodes scholar.
 
Bernie Sanders was able to visit, pictures of him dining with the Communists.
 
People should ask, why were these two men were so infatuated with Russia.
 
Obama also has Communism in his upbringing. Remember Obama and Michelle hung Mao Christmas ornaments on the White House tree and no one made a big deal out it. Jay Carney had pro-Communist posters on his dining room walls.
 
Open borders policy is part of it also as the US wouldn’t know how many schools, hospitals etc we would need with open borders, it would create chaos, bring down the country and the open borders crowd would rebuild as the desired totalitarian country they want. Covid-19 should have made all of us aware that we can’t have open borders.
 
Another commenter who went to Columbia U back in 1983 stated most of the rich white kids identified as Commies, Marxists, Socialists anything but for a freedom loving American. Now those people are working to destroy our country with creating chaos (Antifa) as well as attempting to remove history & they have already taken over education.
 
This is why Hillary was/is so furious she isn’t the US president now because I assume she would have been the last US president by bring down the US with whatever she would have implemented. The Communists thought they were so close…..and then Donald Trump rose to take on these Commies and save America. After him, I have no idea where the US will go since they have indoctrinated so many young people within the education system to love Socialism/Communism.
 
“Often described as Chinese cultural centers, Confucius Institutes are funded by China’s communist regime. Several lawmakers have identified them as vessels through which China can engage in nontraditional intelligence collection, obtain taxpayer-funded research, and spread communist propaganda on American campuses.The National Association of Scholars, one of the most vocal critics of the institutions, has documented 90 Confucius Institutes operating in the United States as of July.
 
But the public criticism appears to be making administrators reconsider the value proposition of the institutions. Three Florida universities alone shuttered their institutions last year, as did Texas A&M University. President Trump signed a law last summer that bans defense funding for Chinese-language programs at colleges that host the institutions and requires colleges to make public their agreements with Confucius Institutes.

Chris
Chris
4 years ago

Its Time To Defund The New York Times

James
James
4 years ago

Weis needs to understand that when a well-reasoned conservative viewpoint is expressed, the liberal side crumbles. The NYTs will have no part of that! The NYTs has far too much time and money invested in the liberal diet. The NYTs knows it’s far better to follow the example of the fraud news networks like CNN, NBC etc. and simply eliminate conservative ideology.

Susan D
Susan D
4 years ago

Isn’t the very reason that people emigrated to the USA because they wanted the freedoms of speech, religion, carry arms, etc, etc.? What’s happening to us? The press was created to deliver news, not to invent their biased opinions.

Sherry Dobbs
Sherry Dobbs
4 years ago

Way to go!!! Finally wisdom from NYC!❤️❤️❤️

Angelica
Angelica
4 years ago

Don’t guess I have ever opened a copy of the nyt in my life and don’t intend to…I agree with the person who said it was only good to line bird cages with!

Ralph S
Ralph S
4 years ago

I would hate to demean the supermarket tabloids by lumping them together with the NY Times and Washington Post under the heading of “news”…
The First Amendment protects their right to print [bs or not] ultimately they are still suitably fit to wrap fish.

ScarletDove
ScarletDove
4 years ago

Bari Weiss, her moderate/centrist liberalism and the NYT’s leftist radicals did not mix well…they both got what they deserved, she being naive enough to think she could matter, but in the best radical leftist/marxist manner, she was a detriment to the haters on staff. As a journalist/writer, I am glad that she so eloquently exposed in word, the cesspool that is the NYT!

Allan Brem
Allan Brem
4 years ago

It is good to see that there are people who will finally take a stand on principle. It is a shame that the NYT affiliated Houston Chronicle has no one like this on their staff.

Bob Pritchett
Bob Pritchett
4 years ago

The media today is not honest in the attempt to report the news, they are more interested in ratings and in selling “fish wrappers”. In my opinion the reporters take things at face value, “spice it up” for ratings and publish it. Also the media appears to be in the “hip pocket” of the left wing as much of what is reported is clearly slanted towards the left. If one reads the Federalist Papers and then reads what is published today and compares the depth of thought then vs now it is clear than not a lot of thought is given to issues today. It is sad and is a result of the dumbing down of our society.

Chuck
Chuck
4 years ago

Does George Soros own and dictate to the NYT?

Donald Lau
Donald Lau
4 years ago

Very interesting..always wonder if their were any conservative report at the times…

LauraC
LauraC
4 years ago

Why are we still calling these people the media? Most of these rags are just Communists with pens. So much for their Constitutional mandate to keep the government honest. Any kind of honesty is a thing of the past. Propaganda is all we can hope to see from them.

Drue
Drue
4 years ago

I actually am glad that Weiss resigned. It exposes the NYT for what it is; a leftist, liberal-run rag. At one time, we had great newspapers in this country. Today we have hate-filled propaganda rags masquerading as news outlets. I no longer believe anything I read in most newspapers. R.I.P. NYT. You deserve what you have sown.

Bill Brown
Bill Brown
4 years ago

Americans, we are in the middle of a Communist Revolution!!  Stand-up for America!!  Remove Every Democrat!!!!!

Bill Brown
Bill Brown
4 years ago

Anyone watching CNN, MSNBC, ABC, CBS, NBC National News and Local News, are being BRAINWASHED!!!  Almost nothing but LIES, DECEIT, and PROPOGANDA!!  Includes almost half of FOX News Broadcasts.  Turn-off Mainstream News!!!!!

Bill Brown
Bill Brown
4 years ago

Today, with few exceptions, the Humanists have achieved their goal (began in approximately 1825) of making Public Schools mandatory and the government brainwashing Children into believing the lies of Socialism and Communism.  The marxist/engelist lies have been crammed into our Children who no longer have the protections of Christian Principles.  IF YOU LOVE YOUR CHILDREN, find an alternative to Public Education.  It destroys individual thinking!!  Charter and Parochial Schools can be OK but Home Education is best although it may require lifestyle changes.  EACH OF US MUST CHOOSE!  “IF YOU LOVE YOUR CHILDREN…”

Jim
Jim
4 years ago

Evil indeed does eat its own . Get in line or else!

Lorey
Lorey
4 years ago

Bari u don’t have 2 worry your a bigger man then all the men working 4 the new joke times. So i guess what I’m getting at role changing it fits the bi-itch men perfectly

Steve
Steve
4 years ago

xxx

Steve
Steve
4 years ago

This lady probably wants to work for a “non-rag” publication. Good luck to her. Is leaving the NYT unusual ? I would’nt think so.
I would think that dozens leave every day. This is the toilet paper that denied that the Holycaust occurred in the ’40’s. Does anyone on
this blog know anyone who subscribes to this “product” ? I don’t. Its sad that the NYT didnt realize 30 years ago that its time is up.

Dr. Cissero
Dr. Cissero
4 years ago

The New York Times has always been a left wing publication, in the mid 1950’s it supported Fidel Castro with pro Castro propaganda written by Columnist Herbert Matthews so much that President Eisenhower bought into Castro as a “reformer”. How did that work out?
 

Brenda Blunt
Brenda Blunt
4 years ago

The truth doesn’t seem to matter to big time newspapers or media in general these days. How very sad. The individual should be the one to determine how to think for themselves instead of the media telling the person how to think.

BruceM
BruceM
4 years ago

The answer here folks is easy….don’t read it! If you’re doing an online search and one of the ‘hits’ is an article from the NYT, don’t click on it.

kate
kate
4 years ago

 

kate
kate
4 years ago

Whatever else this woman did or didn’t do before her departure, her resignation letter in its entirety was an epic, clear, thorough assessment of what’s wrong the the American press and the American political dialogue. It’s about time she caught on, and I think it’s a positive thing that it was so well expressed and – at last- widely read. I am surprised that it wasn’t suppressed by the rest of our so-called free press.

Latest Articles

politics, american flag and democrat and republican logos
gun control, the US constitution
midterm elections of 2026 shown under magnifying glass
Little Rock, AR/USA - circa February 2016: Replica of White House s Oval Office in Bill Clinton Presidential Center and Library. Little Rock, AR/USA - circa February 2016: Replica of White House s Oval Office in William J. Clinton Presidential Center and Library in Little Rock, Arkansas

Stay informed! Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

62
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Subscribe to AMAC Daily News and Games